3 ms·
Even a very 18th-c conception of the federal government doesn't have it receiving no direct tax. In fact it was considered necessary that it have its own direct
by _delirium 15y ago
Even a very 18th-c conception of the federal government doesn't have it receiving no direct tax. In fact it was considered necessary that it have its own direct source of revenue, since its financial dependence on the states was one of the things crippling the Articles of Confederation government. Import tariffs were long the main tax. In that case, the Constitution does make sure that federal taxation means no state taxation, because states are prohibited from enacting tariffs. The other traditional main source of federal revenue was income from federal lands (mining, forestry, etc.).
- IanDrake 15y agoYes, I should have been more clear. I don't think individuals should pay direct taxes to the Federal government. I prefer the pre-16th amendment scheme of apportioning amongst the states. Regardless of today's law, I am currently of the opinion that direct taxes should be collected at the most local level possible with each community paying it's parent an apportioned amount for the service, privileged, and protection it provides.