3 ms·
peterbonney's right for exactly the reasons that the public trying to reason its way through interpreting studies like this unaided is dangerous to public healt
by shadowgovt 5y ago
peterbonney's right for exactly the reasons that the public trying to reason its way through interpreting studies like this unaided is dangerous to public health.
This is an observational study. It's not possible for it to control for (among other things) the possibility that those who were infected and survived already possessed enhanced natural immunity due to some other cause. All we know is that people who get COVID-19 and don't die from it are less likely to become symptomatic with the delta variant than people who are inoculated, not whether or not they were always less likely to become symptomatic with the delta variant.
People who interpret this study to mean "I don't need the vaccine" are really rolling the dice on the possibility that there's an X-factor here to COVID-19 survival... And they don't have it.
- peteradio 5y agoApparently a high percentage of X-factor was present in this study. Do you see something funny in the demographics of the recovered?
- shadowgovt 5y agoI see they recovered. You're correct... One interpretation could be that a high percentage of X-factor was present in this study's recovered group. But since we don't know what the X-factor is, an unvaccinated person is rolling dice by assuming they have it. Nothing about this study guarantees an unvaccinated individual survives a brush with COVID-19; it suggests they're likely to survive a second brush with it (and likelier still if they get vaccinated).
- peteradio 5y agoI see what you are saying. The study is not relevant for unvaccinated and uninfected people.