3 ms·
That doesn't seem political. Weighing whether an infringement of personal rights have a legitament purpose and are justified is the court's job. The "public goo
by bawolff 5y ago
That doesn't seem political. Weighing whether an infringement of personal rights have a legitament purpose and are justified is the court's job. The "public good" is a huge part of that calculus
Edit: as an aside, the upvotes/downvotes on this post are wild. One moment its +3 the next moment its -3.
- chrisco255 5y agoNo, it's not. "Public good" is some evolving, tenuous, emotional standard, not a legal definition. If you want to renegotiate property law, we have a branch for that: your state's legislature.
- babesh 5y agoRead the Constitution. It limits powers even when it is in the so called public interest.
- kelnos 5y ago> Weighing whether an infringement of personal rights have a legitament purpose and are justified is the court's job. No it's not; the court's job is to determine if the matter brought before them is legal and constitutional or not. It's Congress' job to decide where the line between property rights and the public interest is. While I'm very much in favor of an eviction moratorium right now, it does feel like the CDC exceeded their legal authority here.