5 ms·

There is a good reason. The government wants to incentivize people to make long term investments into certain types of small businesses. You are very free to

There is a good reason. The government wants to incentivize people to make long term investments into certain types of small businesses. You are very free to disagree with that, but the government often uses the tax code to encourage/discourage certain types of investment. Also given that you have an investment that qualifies, it seems like it is an easy thing, but it’s a pretty narrow exception. It is a giveaway to the rich in the sense that any stock based tax incentive is a giveaway to the rich, but there are a lot of giveaways to a lot of people in the tax code.

griffinkelly 5y ago
Exactly. If the tax rate on capital gains is excessive, what's my incentive to invest in a small startup? Its extremely risky as it is, but without this, parking my cash in my brokerage account becomes all the more likely.
- agency 5y ago
  Is there a big problem with investors not being incentivized to invest in startups? I’m not really hooked into things these days but pre-pandemic seemed like probably the best time in history to raise money as an early stage startup and I can’t imagine that reducing or taking away QSBS would meaningfully affect that. VC firms seem to be doing just fine.
  - griffinkelly 5y ago
    If you're investing in startups because its your hobby, as many do, no tax break is going to change that. As for others, if you're looking for returns and have the option to be an LP in a VC, make angel investments, or just park your money in the S&P500, a few of those options look more promising. While everything does have inherent risk, it is an added benefit to angel investing that you get QSBS, while being an LP or investing in the S&P necessarily don't have the same tax benefits. Incentivizing investment in small & new businesses is probably a better thing than just having the ultra wealthy invest in AT&T.

griffinkelly 5y ago

Exactly. If the tax rate on capital gains is excessive, what's my incentive to invest in a small startup? Its extremely risky as it is, but without this, parking my cash in my brokerage account becomes all the more likely.

agency 5y ago
Is there a big problem with investors not being incentivized to invest in startups? I’m not really hooked into things these days but pre-pandemic seemed like probably the best time in history to raise money as an early stage startup and I can’t imagine that reducing or taking away QSBS would meaningfully affect that. VC firms seem to be doing just fine.
- griffinkelly 5y ago
  If you're investing in startups because its your hobby, as many do, no tax break is going to change that. As for others, if you're looking for returns and have the option to be an LP in a VC, make angel investments, or just park your money in the S&P500, a few of those options look more promising. While everything does have inherent risk, it is an added benefit to angel investing that you get QSBS, while being an LP or investing in the S&P necessarily don't have the same tax benefits. Incentivizing investment in small & new businesses is probably a better thing than just having the ultra wealthy invest in AT&T.