5 ms·
Visualizations are tough. It seems there is always a visualization you can use to show the story you are trying to tell, almost like "p-hacking", but "chart se
by taeric 5y ago
Visualizations are tough. It seems there is always a visualization you can use to show the story you are trying to tell, almost like "p-hacking", but "chart searching."
For this data, I'm not at all clear on why a standard line chart isn't better. I'll confess, I don't find these charts bad; I just don't see them as clearer than the standard charts. What is the specific advantage?
The commentary on lag of reporting being a surprise is, itself, surprising at this point. That was a big point of contention earlier, but I'm not sure I have seen it pan out in a way that matters.
I'm torn on the commentary of the failure of governments. Policy choices have been very hard with more emotion driving choices than analyzed results. I'm personally in the bend of "be overly cautious," but I also get an uneasy feeling in just how little control there is in comparisons. About the only thing I know not to do now, is get cocky for any region and assume that anyone is already through this.
- breck 5y ago“Chart hacking” is a great term, thanks. I’m gonna start using that.
- nixpulvis 5y agoYears are cyclic, no? EDIT: Months to be precise.
- taeric 5y agoBut a year over year line chart already shows trends well enough. Splitting not by month, but by season, would be neat to see. But I'm sceptical there are any learnings to be had here.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nixpulvis 5y ago> I'm not at all clear on why a standard line chart isn't better. > ... well enough.
- taeric 5y agoI'm not clear on what you are trying to say. My, "shows trends lines well enough" should be assumed as followed with "such that I do not see anything new in the post charts."
- kiberium 5y agoI don't know if this makes it better but my mental model of the calendar year is a circle divided into quarters.
- mcculley 5y agoAuthor here. Maybe I am too strident in my commentary on the failure of governments. I firmly believe there have been many failures. We should have implemented testing at scale in March of 2020. Now we are doomed to have partisan arguments about vaccinations and masks after having spent trillions on handouts.
- taeric 5y agoI wish I knew how the partisan debate became the debate. :( For myself, I am not convinced we know what the world would have looked like given any alternative response. I do not think we should give up. I just don't know what has actually worked. Hard to argue against more testing, though. Edit: also, to be clear, I am not trying to argue you shouldn't do the charts this way. Rather, saying I probably need some training to align to what you think this makes more clear. And I believe it could just be different licks, and all that.
- mcculley 5y agoI think that there is any confusion at all is more an indication that I have failed to make a good case for this being more useful. I found it more useful for my own needs looking at my state and trying to understand the normal expected seasonal variation versus 2020-2021. This is the kind of feedback I was looking for. Thank you.
- taeric 5y agoThanks for sharing! I see you got pointed suggestions for moving the legend and changing the scale. Looking forward to seeing them after those changes.
- mcculley 5y agoI have regenerated the graphs to use the square root of the count as the radius to keep the area constant, as others have suggested. I appreciate the feedback.
- belltaco 5y ago>It seems there is always a visualization you can use to show the story you are trying to tell, almost like "p-hacking", but "chart searching." Is there a visualization that tells the story that deaths due to covid weren't a big issue? The only way(other than just making up numbers) I have seen this done is to look at the last few months and use the reporting lag to mislead people into thinking there were fewer deaths than past years.
- taeric 5y agoFair. There are some stories that can't be told with the data anymore. That said, I haven't seen that one attempted. Unless it is to get and show good non uniform the risk involved is. The main question/story seems to be around just how preventable this was. And on that one, stories are all over the place.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- PennRobotics 5y agoThree such visualizations: data that are confusing to the layperson, and data that minimize personal danger, and data that bend the brain's ability to comprehend. A plot of Case Fatality Rate would go down over time as the number of cases goes up. A somewhat related, slightly confusing example is cumulative deaths on a log plot. A handful of people would look at the line without much focus on the axes or title. A plot of Covid deaths by age group could make it more likely that young people engage in riskier activities, since it downplays the risk for "most" people---well, except someone else's grandparents who were gonna die soon anyway. And, in the WTF category: https://images.theconversation.com/files/330304/original/file-20200424-163098-1myrevx.png https://images.theconversation.com/files/330304/original/fil...
- UncleMeat 5y ago> Is there a visualization that tells the story that deaths due to covid weren't a big issue? Yes, sort of. There was a great paper in CHI this year discussing how heterodox communities use visualizations (https://dl.acm.org/doi/fullHtml/10.1145/3411764.3445211 https://dl.acm.org/doi/fullHtml/10.1145/3411764.3445211). The rough conclusion is that visualizations do not just empower people to express the truth but are also used in skilled ways by heterodox communities.