7 ms·
What is the law in Spain for squatting? In the US for most states squatting doesn't really 'pay' as legally you have to occupy the location for a relatively lo
by duxup 5y ago
What is the law in Spain for squatting?
In the US for most states squatting doesn't really 'pay' as legally you have to occupy the location for a relatively long period of time, maintain it, sometimes even pay taxes regularly before you have any real rights at all.
- john_yaya 5y agoI think the goal of the squatters isn’t to own the property, it’s to just get a roof over their heads and extort the owners in the process. They’ve carefully chosen a legal zone where they have a lot of room to maneuver.
- tecleandor 5y agoMost of the squatters aren't trying to extort, they're just trying to get somewhere to live for free or for cheap. Yeah, some are freeloaders, but lots of them have lost their jobs and/or are suffering the combination of the crisis and the spectacular surge of pricing on real estate this last years. Even with this problems, squatting incidence have been falling on the last 5/10 years.
- slothtrop 5y agoThey squat because houses are nicer and more spacious to live in, not for lack of any place to stay. On top of extortion.
- tecleandor 5y agoI didn't say it's for lack of space, I said it's for a lack of money. In fact, more than 10% of the homes in Spain are vacant. I think you may be talking about your experience in a different country or about a very concrete personal experience, and not in general.
- slothtrop 5y agoFair enough
- toomuchtodo 5y agoCould Spain not increase taxes on vacant/vacation/second home properties to fund efforts to reduce homelessness and provide affordable housing? Some of these folks own two, three, and four homes that are sitting empty.
- spaniard89277 5y agoThey did. Also, municipalities tax by property ownership. They don't do it more because they know most vacant property is owned by regular folks. It's just a supply demand problem here. People in Spain just refuses to believe it because there are some narratives circulating, specially in the left, about how the housing bubble ruined spain so constructing is speculation and bad capitalism yadda yadda. They don't want to hear about public housing neither because "it's expensive" while they advocate for more public spending in other useless stuff. They want price control and such. The whole situation is just so stupid.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoDo you have some citations you could share? I would love to educate myself on the situation in depth.
- spaniard89277 5y agoUff man, I don't know if there's any resource that summarizes any of this, or at least I don't know any. Do you read spanish? I may find something for you, but probably not soon.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoI do. No rush. Thank you.
- llampx 5y ago> Most of the squatters aren't trying to extort, they're just trying to get somewhere to live for free or for cheap. Yeah, some are freeloaders, but lots of them have lost their jobs and/or are suffering the combination of the crisis and the spectacular surge of pricing on real estate this last years. So much speculation. Do you have any proof for these claims?
- tecleandor 5y agoYou don't get any legal rights over the property even after long periods of time (as in some countries or US states that give you rights kind of similar to a tenant if you stay long enough). Here you can only wait to get evicted, and that'll happen sooner or later. But as right now the courts are understaffed and overworked, it's more later than sooner. Probably between a couple months to two years. Also, during the pandemics, evictions were suspended to avoid situations of people loosing their jobs, and then their homes and having no surviving options in the middle of a lockdown,
- dragonwriter 5y ago> You don't get any legal rights over the property even after long periods of time (as in some countries or US states that give you rights kind of similar to a tenant if you stay long enough). Adverse possession actually gives title to the property, not “rights kind of similar to a tenant”.
- tecleandor 5y agoAh sorry, I was thinking of the "tenant-after-30-days-in-a-hotel-room" laws and some other examples in Europe that are different. Thanks for the correction.
- jknz 5y agoIf you leave the property unattended and squatters move in, after 48h of them being on the property, you cannot have law enforcement kick them out and have to use the courts for months of proceedings.
- mreezie 5y agoI clearly don't understand all the dynamics here - but this seems completely ludicrous. So I go away for a weekend, someone breaks into my home, and when I come back I am homeless? Where is the delineation between "someone breaking into my home" and "squatting"?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jknz 5y agoTo avoid confrontation in the 48h window, a good squatter strategy is to target summer or weekend houses that have typically other weekend houses next to it so that neighbours aren't there and won't alert the owner. Then squatters move in in two steps. First they do a small break in and leave, observing whether someone notices and fixes the first break in. If the first break in goes unnoticed, it is probably safe to move in, change the locks and squat there permanently as nobody will confront them in the 48h window.
- ectopod 5y agoIt's difficult. Sometimes in England a landlord will be attempting to illegally evict a lawful (non-squatting) tenant, so the tenant calls the police for help and is surprised when the police assist in the illegal eviction! Obviously this is not supposed to happen. The police should not be evicting people just because some random told them he owned a property and it was being squatted. On the other hand, the legal situation for evicting squatters in your home isn't so bad here. You have 28 days after you find out you are being squatted, and the eviction only takes 24 hours. Unless you register all tenancies with the state (which seems like massive overreach) how can the police quickly determine the lawful possessor?
- temp50010 5y agoThis refers specifically to adverse possession and differs by state. If memory serves New York is 10 years, Texas is measured in months, both require real improvements to the property and a formal legal process.
- Digory 5y agoYou can gum up an eviction in the States for several months on very flimsy grounds. “We had an agreement” is sometimes enough to get the police to go away, requiring a lawsuit. The real experts find a target and record fake deeds, almost guaranteeing a year or two. Add in the federal “moratorium,” and landlords or sellers in this market will often pay for them to leave.
- 908B64B197 5y agoIn the US it might end as soon as the squatters are found trespassing illegally on someone's property, especially if the homeowner notices a forced entry (could be reasonably interpreted as an intention of harming the occupants) [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law
- thehappypm 5y agoIn the US to get actual squatter's rights you need to be somewhere for years and basically not get noticed or requested to leave at all. The idea is pretty interesting: if a piece of property is being completely unused to the point where its legal owner does not even know someone is living there, it's better for society for the squatter to live there and keep an eye on it, and it doesn't even really negatively impact the legal owner because how can they possibly care about a place they never visit?
- seoaeu 5y agoYeah, adverse possession laws which kick in after years/decades of using some property make a lot of sense. You can even think of them as a sort of statute of limitations on property disputes
- avidiax 5y agoMy understanding is that the most common use of adverse possession is something like I have a dock on the property line. That dock has been there for 20 years, but my neighbor sells their property and the survey shows the dock is over the line by 6 inches. By adverse possession, I get that 6 inches of property and don't have to move the dock.
- bdowling 5y ago> By adverse possession, I get that 6 inches of property and don't have to move the dock. AP needs to be exclusive. So if you didn't have a fence keeping the neighbor off the dock, then what you'd get is a prescriptive easement. You'd get to keep using your dock where it is, but the neighbor would still have title to the strip of land. There may be some conditions in which the neighbor would get to access the part of the dock on his land.
- respondo2134 5y agoBy the US definition this isn't squatting, it's more B&E followed by extortion.
- pvaldes 5y ago> What is the law in Spain for squatting? Totally different as represented here. The "48h or is mine" for example is a rumor that journalists love to repeat, very good FUD element, but is false. The laws don't say that. Journalists know it of course, but they spread the rumor from time to time, because outrage attracts eyeballs. This is a very local problem, maybe in tourist flaws, and empty houses or factories owned by banks, not so much to private homes, neither main or secondary. You can find outrageous cases in private homes involving vulnerable poor people that rent some room to the wrong people, or local politicians or judges that choose not to act, but is not the general rule. If you see some TV channels or tabloids it seems that is happening everywhere and that the police don't do anything of course, but it depends a lot on the place.
- pvaldes 5y agotourist flaws -> tourist flats