6 ms·
>I’m not sure what you’re trying to suggest about hypothetical rent control in London I'm stating that the extreme lack of supply ascribed to rent control also
by pydry 5y ago
>I’m not sure what you’re trying to suggest about hypothetical rent control in London
I'm stating that the extreme lack of supply ascribed to rent control also exists in similar cities without rent control.
So maybe rent control's effect on supply is vastly overblown as you can see by looking at the large amount of house-building in NYC before 1974 in the graph above, which is when rent control laws started getting really watered down.
>It should be clear that London was geographically exhausted long ago
Thats kind of absurd. It only recently caught up to prewar population levels. Property prices skyrocketed way before that.
>The truth is that being a rent-controlled landlord is easy mode.
If they like it so much why do they try to trick/bully tenants into leaving or offer large sums of money to tenants to leave if that fails?
>And you’re still ignoring all of the people locked out of the system by the ensuing decade-long wait
Give leveraged landlords market rent in restricted supply environments like SF and the FIRST thing they will try to do is to inhibit further development with NIMBYism that might bring down their rents and damage their investment.
Detractors of rent control tend to feign support for new residents but theyre perfectly happy for them to be priced out alongside the long term residents of the city.
More social housing fixes the underlying supply issue. Higher property taxes fixes the underlying supply issue. Wanting to kill rent control before or instead of fixing these things means being concerned with profit, not people.
Rent control is a band aid while that happens to keep long term (especially elderly/vulnerable) renters housed.
And landlords loathe it.
- rguillebert 5y ago> So maybe rent control's effect on supply is vastly overblown. Just because rent control negatively affects supply doesn't mean bad supply is only caused by rent control. I live in London too and I'm baffled by the lack of tall buildings in pretty central parts of the city. The real solution is more supply. > Rent control is a band aid while that happens to keep long term (especially elderly/vulnerable) renters housed. At the expense of people who don't currently live in London but could, such as immigrants or people from poorer parts of the country finding a good paying job here.
- pydry 5y ago>At the expense of people who don't currently live in London but could, such as immigrants or people from poorer parts of the country finding a good paying job here. Kicking grandma out of her rented apartment and on to the street isn't going to suddenly mean that Romanian cleaners won't be living 7 to a house in zone 5. This housing crisis was deliberately engineered in London as a result of the 1980s war between Thatcher and local government. Council housing was privatized as a result (& some of those gains were capitalized by existing residents through right-to-buy). Councils were starved of tax funding through the UK's comically low council tax rates. This meant that not only was owning property a much better deal but also that councils lacked the funds to increase the supply of housing. Hence prices taking off like a rocket. There's your supply issue. Rent control would be a drop in the bucket compared to that.
- rguillebert 5y ago> Kicking grandma out of her rented apartment If she's retired, she can move somewhere cheaper so someone who actually needs to live there for their job can move in. The rest of what you've written is completely unsubstantiated.
- around_here 5y agoAh yes, the classic “you’re useless now grandma, the fuck on outta here” line. I bet you’re a real gem in the family. A landlord is to housing what a scalper is to tickets (or for the nerds, graphics cards). Only one of them leaves you fucking homeless.
- rguillebert 5y agoAh yes, the classic "I got here first so it's mine forever".
- KittenInABox 5y agoI'd rather a grandmother be housed than be homeless, even if it means her grandchild has to live in a further flat.
- zajio1am 5y ago> More social housing fixes the underlying supply issue. How could social housing fix the issue? The underlying issue is too many obstructions to building new houses, which restrict supply. If commercially motivated developers cannot build enough houses due to bureaucracy and obstructions by NIMBY groups, then municipality would likely fail too.
- 6510 5y agoMy house was build some 30 years ago by students who paid for their education. They added a new badge of construction workers every year (and the oldest badge got their diploma). I have no idea what happened with the concept. They are now back to [the usual] building things next to and inside the school then demolishing it. I imagine the collective mind could greatly benefit if everyone had to spend a few (education focused) months in construction (and/or say farming etc) Its not boring if its just a short period. In construction you can learn the basics of a discipline (and make yourself useful) in just a few days. But I agree it is the obstruction that prevents cheap housing. Its probably intentional (to some extend) simply to drive up prices.