3 ms·
> But you will get it in the form that I would like you to have it, not as it happened. And that's actually a very large part of why I don't use something that
by eropple 15y ago
> But you will get it in the form that I would like you to have it, not as it happened.
And that's actually a very large part of why I don't use something that makes rebase easy. Because, fundamentally, I do not care how you "want" me to get it. I want to get it how it was put into the repository to begin with. I want to get it how it was committed--because how it was done matters to me, as a developer and as a person. This is an entirely emotional position and I don't care: show me how it was done. It matters to me, and given my personal axioms there is a decent argument, in my mind, that doing otherwise is disrespecting people who might want to see how you "put it all together."
You're certainly welcome to disagree. But because I use Hg for my projects and for any project I contribute to, and because my usual co-workers aren't going to go through the hassle of enabling Hg's rebase extension and using it just for the hell of it, I generally get what I want in the areas I care about. =)
- fr0sty 15y agoIf your workflow or VCS doesn't allow rebase natively then people will implement it in the filesystem by never committing. Git's approach to committing is: "commit early, commit often". The coro;lary is: "don't worry about perfection, we can fix it later". Such flexibility to me is very enabling and allows for a lot of very beneficial experimentation in the process of developing features. Honestly, I don't understand your fascination with the sausage-making. If I were to give you the pre-rebase and post-rebase version of patches I would wager you would find much more value in the latter. And if not. Even if seeing the wandering, hacking, slashing, typoing, re-indenting, etc. is instructive to you, any future maintainer of the code will be far less pleased.
- astine 15y ago"I want to get it how it was committed--because how it was done matters to me, as a developer and as a person." Or as a micro-managing boss. I don't need someone staring over my shoulder as I work or after I work. My mistakes aren't your business and I find your attitude unpleasant.