5 ms·
Would Netflix have to do this if it actually had content people wanted to watch? It's just sad watching it double down on this pulp because every other copyrigh
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
Would Netflix have to do this if it actually had content people wanted to watch? It's just sad watching it double down on this pulp because every other copyright holder took their ball and went home.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoNobody was ever going to make all TV and movie content available for $9 a month to everyone. The idea that Netflix could last the way it used to be was ridiculous.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoCopyright infringement makes everything ever created available for $0 a month. If streaming services can't do the same, they suck and are failing to compete.
- ocdtrekkie 5y agoThe position that "theft is free, so anything not given away fails to compete" is not a realistic position to argue with.
- HWR_14 5y agoI don't know if that will be unrealistic in the future. Once AI is making the content you consume, the price seems like it would rapidly approach zero.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoToo bad theft is an option then, because the paid services must compete with it. There are more dimensions than price. (Also infringement isn't theft but if you haven't been convinced by now...)
- matheusmoreira 5y agoTheft is not free, copying data is. They're the ones making everything worse for everybody because they can't deal with that reality. These streaming services can't even manage to produce a video player with decent controls, we had better software in the 90s. Also, copyright infringement is not theft. It's copyright infringement and it's only a problem if you accept the notion that copyright is a legitimate system to begin with.
- pjc50 5y agoIt's the only realistic position. Heck, it's the only reason streaming services can exist; without piracy pressure everything would be pay per view or pay per stream at far higher rates.
- coldtea 5y agoCopyright extension is theft by lobbies pressuring the legislative body against the spirit (and original letter) of the law. In this sense, thousands of movies and albums (stuff recorded before 1970) would be public domain now based on the 1901 copyright terms... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Term_Extension_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_Term_Extension_Act
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah. They reap all these benefits. When it's OUR turn to exercise our public domain rights, they change the rules of the game. They move the goalposts. Why respect their rights when they don't respect ours? There is absolutely no reason to recognize their "property" as legitimate.
- prepend 5y agoWhen theft has a better user experience that’s important. Important because it’s more user oriented than the plethora of poorly designed apps with dark patterns to piss me off but keep me subscribed. It’s important because it’s the reality. Today, my janky RSS feed setup dumping stuff to a network folder is better for discovering new shows and movies. I’m more likely to see new content released through my tracker, browsing in 10 seconds than spending minutes scrolling through Netflix, and Hulu, and Prime. Just to see if there’s something new. These services make it hard to use. I’d pay extra if Netflix just gave me an RSS feed and let me filter it. The fact that pirates are able to do this, volunteering is only part of it.
- krige 5y agoAt the core it's a matter of convenience. When there's only one service to pay for or even two or three most people don't have a problem with paying a fee to have access to everything they want to watch. But when there's fifteen services to pay for, even if they collectively cost less than the above example, many simply give up and turn back to piracy.
- account42 5y ago> At the core it's a matter of convenience. Conveninece also means different things for different people. For me is includes being able to re-watch my favorite content whenever I want and on whatever device I want - no exeptions - even if the the internet is down, even if the creator no longer wants to make it available. The only thing that can guarantee that is something that gives me DRM-free files that I can manage however I want. Unfortunately for movies and shows noone provides this - best non-piracy option are physical discs but even those are so filled with anti-piracy measures (and other questionable technical decisions) which only serve to make the experience worse than piracy.
- mewse-hn 5y agoYeah, netflix saw this balkanization of streaming services coming and they started spending other people's money on original content so they couldn't have the ball taken away from them. It seems to be working for now - they've had 619 emmy nominations - but when there's 15 services that each have 1 show you want to watch, piracy will flourish
- blahblahblogger 5y ago> It seems to be working for now - they've had 619 emmy nominations I canceled my Netflix sub. Maybe this is why? Netflix became desperate to be legitimized by "big Hollywood"/"big entertainment". It used to be the new thing that didn't need to conform with its titles.
- emkoemko 5y agoi bet eventually they will be doing cross platform streaming rights deals, only one i can think off that might never do that is Disney. Your content can only be consumed so much on a closed platform before it losses its profitability and then you just sell its rights to bring extra profits. otherwise i can't see how this will be sustainable this is going to be more expensive then tv channels were . Yes the content have much better production value but who will be able to afford so many stream services other then just people hopping after consuming what they wanted to watch. maybe there will be a pay to watch service that has everything and you just pay for the right to watch the specific content.
- dmitriid 5y ago"Video streaming giant Netflix had a total net income of over 2.76 billion U.S. dollars in 2020, whilst the company's annual revenue reached 25 billion U.S. dollars" [1] Yes, they can last the way it used to be. Well, they did slightly increase the price because they were forced to spend ridiculous amounts of money on their own content, but they are doing just fine. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/272561/netflix-net-income/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/272561/netflix-net-incom...
- coldtea 5y agoDeals with content companies aside, why not? Storage and delivery wise its much chaper than YouTube (which is 100000 times bigger in storage needs due to user generated content), and makes all this available for $9 without ads...
- xmprt 5y agoA big issue for me is that Netflix now has so much content that everyone watching different things and there's no longer "the show" that you have to watch to talk about with your friends. Instead, there are a handful of good shows every year spread across all platforms and it's come to the point where if I'm just going to watch things on my own, I might as well just watch YouTube.
- crateless 5y agoThat's been pretty much my conclusion as well. I can mostly find some kind of long-form content to consume and although the feed algorithm sucks, the recommendations on the video page itself usually make up for it.
- alistairSH 5y agoThis. A few years ago, I subscribed to Netflix. That was it (no cable, no other streaming). The amount of good content was reasonable. Now, I have to cycle through Netflix, Hulu, HBO, Apple, and Amazon. I unsubscribed to most of them most of the time, and resubscribe as a show or movie comes to my attention (Dune will get me resubscribed to HBO for a month or two, etc). I still spend less on streaming than I did on cable, but if the whole ecosystem gets any more fractured or any more expensive or any more annoying to navigate, I'll probably start cancelling and just find something else to do. Unfortunately, finding books isn't much better, or I'd likely spend more time reading than watching TV. But a bad book, for me, is 100x worse than a bad TV show.
- ggggtez 5y agoMaybe you should treat books like TV then: give it a half hour, and if you're not hooked, close it and find another. I know many people say books take longer to enjoy, but a bad TV series can take ~12 hours per season. Most people can probably finish a novel in 12 hours.
- xmprt 5y agoMaybe I'm going about this the wrong way but I feel like books are more comparable to movies. A bad movie lasts under 2 hours and I can usually skip around without losing much context because pictures and video convey a lot more information than text. I can infer things that I miss based on background elements whereas in a book if the characters go to a different location, it's hard to know that unless I read the part where they go to said location.
- tornato7 5y agoNetflix REALLY went for quantity over quality with their library. I'm certain that there are some great shows in there, but I have to start ten different series just to find one I like. On the other end of the spectrum, the Disney+ library is rather small, but I find at least half the shows to be enjoyable, so that's where I turn to first.
- HWR_14 5y agoNetflix started out with a huge amount of content. I'm sure they're scared that no longer seeming to have everything will hurt their subscriber base. One way to make it look like you still have everything is to have an overwhelming amount of stuff.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat will work in the short term, but perhaps hurt them in the long term.
- fumblebee 5y agoHm, I really don't understand the approach of choosing shows/films based on what the algorithm tells me I'll like. Watching a series is such an incredible time sink that it's necessary to gather more information in advance of choosing. I've found a much better model is friends or critics' recommendations cross-checked against Rotten Tomatoes and IMDb ratings. (Which implies you need some people to use the scattergun approach, but I'd rather not be the guinea pig). This way it doesn't matter if good Netflix shows are "needle in a haystack".
- mumblemumble 5y agoI don't really feel like there's much quantity, either, though. The stuff they're doing is just so very stylistically homogenous. I guess it's down to how you frame it? Some people see 100 different flavors of ice cream. I see 100 different flavors of chocolate ice cream. Both perspectives are accurate. Which one is more useful to you perhaps depends on how much you like chocolate ice cream.
- dazc 5y agoAnd this is the obvious answer that they somehow manage to keep overlooking. Just cancelled my sub and won't be activating it again until Christmas. I should then get a decent month of viewing before I cancel it again. In the meantime I'll be paying amazon much more money for stuff outside of the Prime offering that I want to watch and am willing to pay for (albeit grudgingly).
- nsgi 5y agoThey do, though. They produce a lot of garbage but their best rivals HBO
- dogman144 5y agoThe best get cancelled two seasons in, while HBO does not.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoTheir best shows were produced before they stopped caring about quality and started churning out garbage by the truckload.
- tsjq 5y ago>Would Netflix have to do this if it actually had content people wanted to watch? very well said. that line is spot-on. for my taste / prefs, I could notice a clear state of uselessness around late 2019. I stopped netflix subscription starting Jan 2020.
- blahblahblogger 5y agoI also stopped Netflix at some point early in the pandemic. More and more I was seeing good shows go away and nothing decent replacing it. Then they had all these weird shows (Cuties?) coming around that left a bad impression. Ultimately my canceling of Netflix went along with canceling big tech as my disillusion has grown across the board: * Amazon (this was hard to cancel, my prime subscription is still paid for the next 6 months) * Facebook (still use the messenger app to chat w/ friends though) * Google (search and Chrome - but still use gmail of course and at work) I'm going to cancel something from Apple to do a full de-fanging of FAANG :) Actually here's what I'll cancel: Apple Arcade. Everything they release now is just a "+" game from a non-Apple-Arcade title. "Somegame+" where it means no ads and maybe a little extra content. Originals on Apple Arcade are now harder to find and everything in my new/recommended/trending/etc is a "plus title".
- boublepop 5y agoCome on, this is beyond hyperbole and absolutely absurd. Yes, Netflix has content people want to watch. That’s not a fact up for debate, it’s is absolute certainty and proven beyond all reasonable doubt. To suggest otherwise is on par with arguing that the moon doesn’t exist.