5 ms·
If you use M3 (total money supply) as the definition of inflation, which is a pretty bogus thing to do. Why is it bogus? Because we have more people than we h
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
If you use M3 (total money supply) as the definition of inflation, which is a pretty bogus thing to do.
Why is it bogus? Because we have more people than we had in 2000. We have more houses, more cars, more computers, more phones. If M3 stayed the same, that would be deflationary, because the same amount of money would be spread over more stuff.
- xqcgrek2 5y agoYou don't really explain why the S&P rising slower than M3.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> You don't really explain why the S&P rising slower than M3 Why do you think a constant fraction of every dollar the Fed creates should go into the S&P 500? Private markets, debt markets and bank reserves have soared since 2008, for example. This chart is the financial equivalent of "a series of tubes."
- throwaway09223 5y agoIt seems an obvious answer would be that there has been a lot of growth outside of the 500 large companies picked to comprise the s&p 500. The s&p 500 is not an index of all corporate growth.
- jimminy 5y agoThis is the correct answer and is actually somewhat visible if you also look at the DJIA and NASDAQ figures. The S&P 500 and DJIA are limited to a fixed number of corporations. The NASDAQ is allowed to expand it's number of listed companies over time. If you look at the NASDAQ figures it's able to show considerable and relevant growth, as more companies have listed. (Still not at 2000's peak, but much closer than the S&P or DJIA.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dvt 5y agoDoesn't M0/1/2/3 have to keep up with population growth? I'm no economist, but dividing the S&P by M3 seems like a category error. In the US, we've got 130 million more people than we did in 1970, and 50 million more than we did in 2000.
- h4x0r12345 5y agoMoney supply cuts through this obscurantist / disingenuous bullshit. It's an objective metric.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Money supply cuts through this obscurantist / disingenuous bullshit. It's an objective metric. Solar luminosity is an object metric. That doesn't make it useful for pricing the S&P 500. Price levels are a function of money supply and velocity. Ignoring the latter throws out a deep body of empirical evidence.
- h4x0r12345 5y agoThis is exactly what I mean by "disingenuous bullshit". CPI is a distorted corrupt measure of price levels. Money supply cuts through that.
- gruez 5y ago>CPI is a distorted corrupt measure of price levels. Money supply cuts through that. So you would also agree that the US economy has shrunk 50% in the last 25 years? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28309004 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28309004
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- h4x0r12345 5y agoAre you typing on a Chinese computer or a US computer? If you were using a computer 25 years ago, what about then? Made in USA or China? And how's your infrastructure looking these days? Last time I was at LAX 10 years ago it looked worse than a third world country airport
- gruez 5y ago
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoLet's say two dollars exist in the world. Your stock is worth one of them in 2000. I quadruple the money that exists in the world to 8 dollars by 2020. The market says your stock is worth two dollars in 2020. Did you lose value, gain value, or stay the same? For more thought experiments compare your stock value to coffee or a Big Mac. https://inflationchart.com/spx-in-coffee/?show_adjuster=1&logarithmic=1 https://inflationchart.com/spx-in-coffee/?show_adjuster=1&lo... https://inflationchart.com/spx-in-bigmac/?show_adjuster=1&logarithmic=1 https://inflationchart.com/spx-in-bigmac/?show_adjuster=1&lo... Essentially no gain, it's all paper, your purchasing power stayed exactly the same even invested in one of the greatest "bull run" stock markets of all time.