3 ms·
> Take your pencil and put a dot on a random point on the x-axis; you might hit a point whose coordinate is a rational number, but your chances of doing so are
by crazygringo 5y ago
> Take your pencil and put a dot on a random point on the x-axis; you might hit a point whose coordinate is a rational number, but your chances of doing so are infinitesimal!
But see, that's precisely the kind of intution I'm arguing against -- the kind of "analogy" that seems indefensible to me.
After all, I can select any pixel from an infinitely zoomable number line on my computer and it will always be rational, every time. Or any measurement you take of a pencil on paper will always be bounded by two rational numbers measured by counting off ticks on a ruler, and unknown within that. One could argue it's impossible to even define what it means to point with a pencil to an irrational number on a straight line. What does it even mean to select a value randomly from multiple infinite sets? And if you define that in some particular way, how do you justify that a pencil could ever do that on paper?
I understand perfectly everything you describe about mapping -- I'm familiar with the math. It just seems misguided and potentially dangerous to me to draw any practical comparisons to it, such as your pencil-and-paper one, because they seem to break down instantly.