3 ms·
It's because they kinda follow the same rules as finitely sized sets. Say you have two sets: A and B. A has five elements and B has seven. That means that for e
by bitwize 5y ago
It's because they kinda follow the same rules as finitely sized sets. Say you have two sets: A and B. A has five elements and B has seven. That means that for each element in A there is a unique corresponding element in B, but the reverse is not true: B has elements that do not map to elements in A. OK, now say A is the set of integers, and B is the set of points on the x-axis. Same deal applies, you can map every integer to a point on the x-axis and still have points on the x-axis that do not map to integers. So we've formalized infinite sets in a way that preserves our intuitive notion of what it means to have more or less of something, without having to count or measure the sets which would be bloody impossible! Yes, it's a game but so is all of math!
As for "almost all", in statistics we have this notion of "almost surely", which is formally defined as "with probability 1". It turns out that a probability of 1 doesn't guarantee that something will happen, because 1 less an infinitesimal is still 1! So roll a spherical die that yields a real number between 0 and 1; if you roll a 0, you lose. The probability that you will win is still 1, but you might still roll that goose egg! So we say that you will "almost surely" win at this game.
If you think of rational and real numbers in terms of our two sets with different cardinalities, not only is there a real number for every rational number (because the rationals are a subset of the reals), but you can map an infinite number of real numbers to each rational number! Take your pencil and put a dot on a random point on the x-axis; you might hit a point whose coordinate is a rational number, but your chances of doing so are infinitesimal! Therefore, in a formal probabilistic sense, you will "almost surely" choose a point with an irrational coordinate. Therefore, we say that "almost all" the real numbers are irrational.
- crazygringo 5y ago> Take your pencil and put a dot on a random point on the x-axis; you might hit a point whose coordinate is a rational number, but your chances of doing so are infinitesimal! But see, that's precisely the kind of intution I'm arguing against -- the kind of "analogy" that seems indefensible to me. After all, I can select any pixel from an infinitely zoomable number line on my computer and it will always be rational, every time. Or any measurement you take of a pencil on paper will always be bounded by two rational numbers measured by counting off ticks on a ruler, and unknown within that. One could argue it's impossible to even define what it means to point with a pencil to an irrational number on a straight line. What does it even mean to select a value randomly from multiple infinite sets? And if you define that in some particular way, how do you justify that a pencil could ever do that on paper? I understand perfectly everything you describe about mapping -- I'm familiar with the math. It just seems misguided and potentially dangerous to me to draw any practical comparisons to it, such as your pencil-and-paper one, because they seem to break down instantly.