3 ms·
Ironically the size of this deal is only about half of what S&P said that they need to see to avoid a credit downgrade for the USA from AAA to AA. Such a credi
by btilly 15y ago
Ironically the size of this deal is only about half of what S&P said that they need to see to avoid a credit downgrade for the USA from AAA to AA.
Such a credit downgrade is likely to cause our interest rates to arise. A back of the envelope calculation suggests that the increased interest costs could cost us in the neighborhood of $2 trillion over the next decade. (See https://plus.google.com/u/0/114613808538621741268/posts/b7uwPS2H7g7 https://plus.google.com/u/0/114613808538621741268/posts/b7uw... for a line of reasoning suggesting that it could cost us that much.)
So the end result over the next decade is that we cut government by $2 trillion, raise the debt ceiling by $2 trillion, and pay $2 trillion more in interest. Thus leaving our actual deficit about the same, but causing our government to deliver $2 trillion less.
I hope the tea party is proud. Unfortunately the general public doesn't understand the numbers well enough to see how stupid this whole exercise was.
- ars 15y agoI'm not sure that math is quite so simple. Interest rates for an entity as large as the US government are not decided by ratings. They are decided by supply and demand. Since there are no other AAA rated markets as large, people will have no choice but to buy US debt. That demand will keep interest rates low.
- jeffreymcmanus 15y agoSupply and demand for bonds is heavily influenced by ratings, and investors always have choices. There are plenty of stories out there of large institutional investors who have already reduced their asset allocations on treasury bonds because of this dangerous brinksmanship on the part of the Republicans.
- btilly 15y agoTake another look at the graph. Historically US debt traded at a substantially lower interest rate than other AAA debt. In fact we even hit a negative interest rate. People paid to loan us money! (They were willing to do it because markets were incredibly volatile, and buying treasuries was cheaper than putting large amounts of money in a warehouse, paying for a guard, and risking theft. I'm not joking.) With the USA downgraded to AA and widespread awareness that stupid politics can result in us not paying, it is hard to conceive of a way that our interest rate will not rise. Don't get me wrong. We'll still have a large and liquid debt market. But we won't enjoy the absurdly low interest rates that we have gotten used to.
- gbhn 15y agoI can easily conceive of it. Where else are you going to put it? Europe? The interest rates are set at auction, and if the stock market is really sour, and European bonds are less attractive, capital will pour into US bonds no matter what these ratings clowns say. (Aren't these the same folks that brought us AAA rating for MBSs less than five years ago, BTW?)
- 3pt14159 15y agoBut if they made no cuts they would have been downgraded anyways. They should have raised taxes and done cuts to the point where they would not have to pay another 2 trillion in interest.
- btilly 15y agoNot true! If we'd voted for the usual "bare increase" back in Feb, the bond markets would have not noticed and our rating would have been fine. The cause of the downgrade is that our politicians demonstrated that even when they are negotiating under the best of all possible circumstances to solve our long-term problems, they act like idiots. A "grand bargain" was the only way that put us on a course to actually bring debt under control. Our inability to negotiate that combined with our long-term fiscal problems is a major long-term problem. If you want to know more about our fiscal situation, I highly recommend http://www.kpcb.com/usainc/USA_Inc.pdf http://www.kpcb.com/usainc/USA_Inc.pdf. It is very long, detailed, and depressing. Here are a few key facts. Our government's cash flow last year was -$11,000 per household. Our government's net worth, if we used standard business accounting, is -$44 trillion. Or -$370,000 per household. By 2025, CBO projections show that our total tax revenue will be entirely absorbed by interest payments and entitlements. As a country we need dramatic changes. Soon. And there is absolutely no indication that the political will exists anywhere to create them.
- 3pt14159 15y agoSo we are in agreement. Anyways can mean different things, but it is better to face the (and I have -$100T NPV accounting) -$44T crisis earlier than later, what with the baby boomers still working. My only point is that at least this brought the looming debt problems to the forefront of Americans mind, albeit at a undesirable outcome. If this crisis had actually resulted in real cuts now and real tax increases now it would have softened the blow in the long term.
- btilly 15y agoIf this crisis had actually resulted in real cuts now and real tax increases now it would have softened the blow in the long term. I'm not positive that that is true, but that is what S&P thinks. The possibility to the contrary is that our economy is slowing again and we have more financial problems dragging us down. Real cuts and tax increases would slow it further. Reduced GDP growth increases our long-term fiscal problems. How exactly those factors would balance out against each other is a heavily debated problem in economics. (The two major political parties have sharply different opinions about the answer.) But while that can be debated, my belief is that either "kick the can without the political fight" or "grand bargain" would have been better for us than what we actually wound up with. And I think we're in agreement there.