4 ms·
We should be careful with this part: > Unavoidable false positives are not great in the context of your device ratting you out to the authorities. [emphasis ad
by Jtsummers 5y ago
We should be careful with this part:
> Unavoidable false positives are not great in the context of your device ratting you out to the authorities. [emphasis added]
If the detection were immediately sent to authorities, this would be an issue. And it's possible in the future (or in practice) that the manual review could be removed or will be a rubber stamp. However, they do have a manual review process slated for this. The reason I promote caution with regard to this element of your argument is that if you have an easily rebutted statement, people will disregard the rest. It's why hyperbole in most political arguments should be strongly avoided, it makes it easy for people to dismiss the rest of the statement(s) no matter how valid.
- snowwrestler 5y agoNot only does Apple have their own manual review step, if an alert gets through that, then NCMEC (in the U.S) does their own, additional review, and then law enforcement would also do a manual review before seeking a warrant. And unlike Apple, law enforcement can and will review the actual full-resolution file(s) in question.