9 ms·
> He also alleges the nude image constitutes child pornography... However, Elden's lawyer, Robert Y. Lewis, argues that the inclusion of the dollar bill (which
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
> He also alleges the nude image constitutes child pornography... However, Elden's lawyer, Robert Y. Lewis, argues that the inclusion of the dollar bill (which was superimposed after the photograph was taken) makes the minor seem "like a sex worker".
I wish the courts were ok with a response of "Are you fucking kidding me, or are you just batshit insane?" Even remotely arguing that this is somehow like child pornography is a grave disservice to all the actual victims of child porn. I sometimes wonder what it's like to go through life with absolutely no shame.
- corndoge 5y agoAt the same time he never consented to a nude image of himself being plastered on one of the most popular albums ever made. Even if it is a cash grab I think he's got a point.
- Zelphyr 5y agoHis parents consented for him. If he wants to sue anyone, he can try going after them. I think he'll get about the same outcome as this lawsuit, though.
- corndoge 5y agoI think that the idea that parents can post nude pictures of you without your consent is bullshit, which was a subtext of my op.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoWell, if you have kids, especially newborns, you do take and send a whole lot of pictures. That alone suggests Apple CSAM thing will have a busy time trying to figure out which is CP and which is just a parent sharing their own kid pictures. Naturally, it does not help that we now effectively have no privacy.
- ghaff 5y agoYou're probably getting downvoted because Apple CSAM does not look at a photo in isolation and "decide" whether it crosses the line into child pornography or not. It's comparing hashes to a child porn database as I understand it.
- jonplackett 5y agoThe reason you're getting down voted, I would guess, is that that is not the way CSAM scanning works. Apple have a list of photos they know are CSAM, or rather hashes of them, and the look for those and only those on your device. They also introduced another thing that scans your kid's incoming and outgoing messages for what look like dodgy photos - that does look at general photo content (rather than compare to a list) which has been the source of a lot of the confusion. (FWIW I still think the CSAM scanning is an incredibly bad idea and horribly slippery slope to start sliding on.)
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoI don't mind. I do find the reaction interesting though. In a practical sense, they could have called it anything and since they announced it in the same breath, my mental map keeps it under the same umbrella. It is not on me that Apple communicates poorly. But lets get past that. The 'dodgy photos' functionality ( because that was indeed what I was referring to vs hash db ) is where it is going to get tricky. I am sure there will be parents, who will absolutely love it. Just as I am sure that there will be ones who think this will not end well.
- nullc 5y ago> Apple have a list of photos they know are CSAM, or rather hashes of them Technically, that government agencies claim are CSAM and the "hash" is highly vulnerable to preimage attacks: I can take random unrelated photos and make them match other hashes, https://github.com/AsuharietYgvar/AppleNeuralHash2ONNX/issues/1#issuecomment-903094036 https://github.com/AsuharietYgvar/AppleNeuralHash2ONNX/issue... This means people can take child porn images and modify them so they match targeted innocent images, and take innocent images and modify them so they match child porn.
- S_A_P 5y agoThat is a whole other ball of wax. Age of consent is a thing. As a parent I wouldn’t choose to let my child be part of that sort of photo. I also don’t think his parents had any malice in putting Spencer in that photo. Until recently he seemed completely ok with drawing attention to the photo by recreating it multiple times and giving interviews. Let’s not pretend that he would be suing Nirvana if that album sold 5000 copies either.
- Freak_NL 5y agoThat's what makes this so highly probable that it is just a vulgar money grab. The image was recreated when he was 10, and again in 2016 (!).
- hackersword 5y ago>Elden says his parents never signed a release authorising the use of his image on the album.
- jonplackett 5y agoIf that's true, then why isn't he pursuing that as an argument rather than claiming it's child porn?
- kevingadd 5y agoHe can pursue multiple issues in a single lawsuit, it's not weird for some but not all of the claims in a case to be dismissed
- TuringNYC 5y ago>> His parents consented for him. According to the article, there was informal consent but no signed release. I'm was pretty surprised to hear that -- isn't obtaining releases pretty standard for large corporations?
- Zelphyr 5y agoI think things like that were handled quite a bit more loosely back then. If memory serves, the cover of one of the Deftones albums (the one with the girl in the bathing suit I believe?) came from a random shot taken at a party and the subject didn't even know about it until the album was released.
- cherrycherry98 5y agoSame situation Matchbox 20's Yourself or Someone Like You, one of the most popular albums of the 90s. The guy on the cover apparently never consented to his photo being used and went after them years later.
- Normille 5y agoHe needs to sue his parents for getting such a shit deal for use of the photo, in the first place. I'll bet if, instead, they'd negotiated a penny for every copy of the album sold, he would be overjoyed that 'everyone in the world' had seen his chipolata.
- lifty 5y agoThe consent was given by his legal parent. So he should sue them not Nirvana.
- corndoge 5y agoPerhaps he should. Nirvana has more money though and one must operate within the incentive structure of the US legal system.
- lifty 5y agoI think I understand the motivation. Sad state of affairs. We are on our way to total loss of trust in societal institutions, and trying to take full advantage of the incentive structure, without any other considerations. In other words, we are getting to the "fuck it!" phase of the process.
- hackersword 5y agoDon't know if it is true or not, or how affects claim ... but he claims >Elden says his parents never signed a release authorising the use of his image on the album.
- lazyasciiart 5y agoA written signed document is not the only way to make a legal agreement, it's just the most easily referenced and proven one. The parents consented to letting a professional photographer take photos of their child to use in commercial work, and nobody appears to dispute that.
- balls187 5y agoWhat would he sue them for?
- darkmarmot 5y agomoney?
- ghaff 5y agoGiven that it was legal content and his parents consented, why is it any different from "stage mothers" and others consenting to (and indeed pushing) their children into any number of ads, photo shoots, TV, film, etc.? Otherwise any adult who felt embarrassment over their appearance in media as a minor could sue and parental consent to do those activities has no meaning. ADDED: And if your response is that "But he was nude" then your beef is with the law that didn't make this illegal. There are of course borderline cases. See Brooke Shields in "Pretty Baby" for example which caused quite a bit of controversy at the time. (And, indeed, as I wrote elsewhere, I'm pretty sure no major record label would go near this cover with a 100 foot pole today not because it would likely be illegal but because it would be a lightning rod.)
- canadianfella 5y ago> Otherwise any adult who felt embarrassment over their appearance in media as a minor could su Why would that be a bad thing?
- hackersword 5y ago>Elden says his parents never signed a release authorising the use of his image on the album.
- ghaff 5y agoBut his parents were apparently paid.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThat doesn't mean there was consent and model release paperwork. The record company should (only slightly ironically) keep records. If they exist this case is going nowhere. If they don't - that might get interesting.
- patrickthebold 5y agoOne would think there'd be some kind of implied consent. It's hard to imagine a situation where a record company ends up with naked pictures of someones kid, the parent gets paid, and the parent is genuinely not ok with the pics appearing on an album cover. I agree it's more interesting if there's no consent form, but I still would hope the court would side with the record company.
- burnished 5y agoIs it really an image of "himself" though? Being a baby is more like a larval form, there isn't really a connection for an audience to make between a photo of a newborn and a photo of an adult. What I'm trying to get at is usually when you say something like "nude image of himself" we are used to thinking that the image is an identifying one. But a baby picture isn't identifying in the same way, even to yourself, until some one informs you of the connection. It feels like a different circumstance, you know?
- shams93 5y agoIf they didn't have a signed release then they're basically using this without permission which is a civil violation.
- refurb 5y agoCourts will respond that way, minus the profanity. Usually it’s an immediate approval of a motion to dismiss with prejudice which means final decision and don’t dare even argue about it.
- jes 5y agoI have never seen the album cover. If he was circumcised as an infant - absent a medical diagnosis of disease or defect that can only reasonably be treated by surgery - then he is a victim of cultural male genital mutilation. As to whether it's child pornography, I can't say, but sadly, I can tell you that there are people in the world who get off on infant circumcision. To my knowledge, the "Gilgal Society" was one such group.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- b3morales 5y ago> I wish the courts were ok with a response of That exists in the concept of "frivolous litigation" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frivolous_litigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frivolous_litigation This has been used in response to some "sovereign citizen" cases (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_citizen_movement#Legal_status_of_theories https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_citizen_movement#Leg...), and it can result in penalties like fines. There's also "vexatious litigation", for when you're effectively trying to use the court system to harass someone.
- habitue 5y agoI think there are also opportunities to have a case dismissed before going into the costly parts of a trial like discovery. The judge can dismiss it just based on the merits of the suit, where they just assume all the alleged facts will turn out to be true. (I am so not a lawyer, would love if a lawyer could correct me)
- mywittyname 5y agoMy understanding is that the bar for this is incredibly high, especially vexatious litigation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mzs 5y agoThis album was released when I was in HS and a classmate was asked by a teacher to turn her t-shirt with the album cover inside-out. She asked why and the teacher said it could be CP. She turned the shirt inside-out. I felt the teacher had a reasonable POV.
- Majestic121 5y agoThe point of view is unreasonnable : a child naked is not Porn unless the intent is to make it porn. No one would think to describe a child naked at the beach "porn", why would it be different on an album cover?
- mzs 5y ago"the teacher said it could be CP" So the POV paraphrased was: someone could consider it CP, I'm not going to argue whether it is or isn't, but it will be disruptive and I'm here to teach and the class to learn so let's nip this in the bud and get on with my lesson. I thought that was a very reasonable take on the situation which was getting disruptive first period history class. much more reasonable than a suspension or the like.
- Majestic121 5y agoI still don't think it's reasonable. Restricting yourself on such banalities feels way too much like "the (prude) terrorists have won" If someone made the same case for a woman wearing a regular skirt in class, (I hope) everyone would be up in arms, and rightfully so.
- ghaff 5y agoSo are there no limits to what a high school student can have on a Tshirt--realizing any such limit will be controversial and probably political to some degree? (Personally, I had to wear a jacket and tie though, so what do I know.)
- 5y ago
- sandworm101 5y agoIt wasn't child porn when it was created, but times change. I have noticed that the BBC has started censoring the image (QI) whereas British productions in the past have not (TheBoatThatRocked). Jurisprudence changes. Since Nevermind was published, even nudity is no longer a requirement for child porn in the US. While I don't agree, I don't think the question is the total slam dunk it was decades ago.
- ghaff 5y agoYes; I'm quite confident that this would never be an album cover today. But you can't generally sue of the basis of some past activity that was legal at the time even if it's not today.
- sandworm101 5y agoBut it is being republished daily today. When material is deemed illegal, new copies cannot be created/sold today on the basis that they were legal yesterday.
- ghaff 5y agoThere would probably be a pretty high bar to get this declared illegal as opposed to sufficiently adjacent as to be controversial on something like an album cover. It pretty clearly does not meet the DOJ definition although other countries, perhaps including the UK, may have stricter/different standards. (And it was and would be obviously illegal to distribute in some countries.) https://www.justice.gov/criminal-ceos/child-pornography https://www.justice.gov/criminal-ceos/child-pornography ADDED: And, no, I would not be putting this album cover in my carry-on to get on a plane. I don't really expect a random TSA agent to be up on legal details of what photography is OK and what isn't.
- Freak_NL 5y agoDon't worry, just hit the next album button (but hope that it doesn't random over to Virgin Killer by the Scorpions).
- ravenstine 5y agoIf he wanted to sue, he really should have just gone for the consent angle and not the child porn one. Who exactly would agree that it's pornographic or exploitative? I doubt the vast majority of reasonable people would see the body of an infant in its natural form as anything but innocent on its own, but what do I know. They should have to demonstrate that the dollar bill makes people see the art as depicting child sex work; if this is requested somehow by the defendants, the glove won't fit. This may be a missing detail, but he should have just asked the record company for some money before escalating it. If he did that and they refused, I'm sure that would have been a part of the news story. The logical end to the argument is that children should never appear in any kind of commercial media because they can't consent, which... come on man. Worst of all, though I'm no lawyer, it seems like there's definitely a non-zero chance he'll get counter-sued by each defendant when his own lawsuit falls apart.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mLuby 5y ago> The logical end to the argument is that children should never appear in any kind of commercial media because they can't consent That's not so unreasonable, considering how child stardom seems to mess with kids. Maybe better motion capture+deep fake tech will let professional actors appear as kids in media. Abolishing child labor may have seemed as ridiculous a few hundred years ago as this does today.
- lostlogin 5y ago> I wish the courts were ok with a response of "Are you fucking kidding me, or are you just batshit insane?" It didn’t involve the courts (at that stage), but Arkell versus Pressdram comes close to this. If you haven’t come across it before it’s a short and sweet read. https://lettersofnote.com/2013/08/07/arkell-v-pressdram/ https://lettersofnote.com/2013/08/07/arkell-v-pressdram/
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- void_mint 5y agoEh I mean. There is a naked photo of this person as an infant, that they inherently didn't consent to, being circulated all over the world + internet.