8 ms·
My understanding was that they were being cut off by payment processors and banks and that drove the decision. Was this resolved?
by duxup 5y ago
My understanding was that they were being cut off by payment processors and banks and that drove the decision.
Was this resolved?
- busymom0 5y agoI would also like to know on whether it's possible for someone to start their own payment processors? There are tutorials on how to start an ISP, so should be possible for payment processors too no?
- Daedren 5y agoNo because the banks from which the payments come from must support said processors. Many countries have their own local payment processors, but it's still only a country-wide thing.
- busymom0 5y agoSo I guess starting a bank is the next step?
- elliekelly 5y agoPayment processing isn’t something a bank gets to decide on their own either. It’s decided by a group. In the US it’s NACHA:https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NACHA https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/NACHA
- jtbayly 5y agoI don’t see any mention of payment processing in there. Have another link?
- LegitShady 5y agoSounds like a cartel gatekeeping the role of processor, and then the processors can put pressure on any business to do what they want or face “the consequences” which means no income (aside from crypto which most people don’t know how to use).
- staticassertion 5y agoThe bar is probably much higher. Among other things you're going to have a ton of regulatory controls to deal with.
- knicholes 5y agoWhy not use crypto? Porncoin2.
- duxup 5y agoIs there a way to do that where customers / content creators don't eventually hit traditional payment processor / bank?
- dylan604 5y agonot until you can reliably buy groceries, pay rent, pay utilities, etc with that crypto, it has to get exchanged for local currency somehow.
- Saris 5y agoYou still need to pass through a bank to convert it to anything usable.
- knicholes 5y agoHow will the banks know the crypto came from porn, though? Receive payments either to your own wallet or straight to Coinbase, convert to USD, transfer to your bank, and we're done, right? What am I missing?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- NateEag 5y agoMaybe that to accept payments the porn company has to publish wallet IDs, so payments can in fact be traced back to them?
- vageli 5y agoThat doesn't seem like it would be a problem for individual creators though, unless all exchanges coordinate to ban sex workers or something (not to mention decentralized exchanges like bisq, or in-person exchanges like localbitcoins).
- after_care 5y agoI think the traditional Visa/MasterCard/American Express/Discover payment processor has established a significant enough moat to make joining them unattractive. There are several challengers like Paypal, Venmo, Zelle, Coinbase, etc that attack from a slightly different angle. I think the thing that is most common is that have super low cost bank transfer options, and they encourage users to maintain a balance. Processing payments locally is 100x-1000x preferable then processing payments externally for these players.
- mschuster91 5y agoPayPal is even worse for sex workers, they're banning people left and right if they even suspect you might be involved into anything relating to it. Their official stance always has been that this is due to the credit card companies, the reality rather is that Paypal doesn't want to deal with the rampant fraud (aka post-nut clarity) in porn.
- PeterisP 5y agoStarting your own payment processor is done reasonably frequently, it has a certain barrier of entry (a few million and a year or two for all the approvals, so feasible with investor backing if you have a valid business reason to make a payment processor) but it's being done regularly and also you can buy and rebrand an existing one, which is a common way to get a quicker market entry at the cost of a bit more money. However, that new processor will be a member of some existing payment systems e.g. Visa network and bound by all the same constraints as the other processors there. Creating your own alternative to a payment system (e.g. a major, widely and internationally supported card network like Visa or MC) is not really plausible. Perhaps you can look at the whole setup of cryptocurrencies+all the crypto exchange companies as something like such an alternative system, so there's one alternative made in this millenium.
- Mvandenbergh 5y agoIt is. The problem is connecting to the rest of the financial system. Imagine starting an "ISP" that had not upstream connectivity. It wouldn't be an ISP then. Same problem here. There's a few players here: payment gateways, this is a service that provides the checkout service on a website and handles protected credit card information. Payment gateways also provide anti-fraud services. payment processors, these execute the actual transaction. They are members of card associations like Visa and connect the card issuing bank and the merchant bank of the payee. merchant banks, these are the banks that hold the company's bank account that the funds from the payment processor come into. card associations, Visa/Mastercard these provide the connectivity and set the high level rules. card issuers, these entities extend credit and may be retail banks or other parties. there is a difference between Amex/Discover and Visa/Mastercard in that the former are also the issuer. That's why you also see Visa debit cards in Europe, they're using the payment processing network but not extending credit. It should be clear that starting a new payment gateway is trivial. It takes money to properly comply but ultimately this is a software business. Starting a new payment processor is much harder but it doesn't matter because all payment processors must comply with the card association rules to get access to that network. Starting your own card network would require attracting issuers who would then issue cards that people could use to pay for OnlyFans... probably not realistic! It was the threat by Visa and MC to cut them off that was the killer here, plenty of payment processors would be happy to take their money but not if the card networks ban the company.
- wongarsu 5y agoI suspect that OnlyFans realized they have the choice of either having a business that makes it incredibly hard to process payments, or to have no meaningful business at all. It's too late to pivot the brand to SFW with a couple of users going slightly over the line (similar to Patreon).
- moksly 5y agoThere are US laws that I can’t remember the names of which make financial institutions legally responsible (probably bad English) for crimes that happen on platforms they sell their services to. So VISA could be fined for any trafficking that happen on OnlyFans. This is also why Pronhub had to remove almost all their videos if they wanted to keep credit card services. As an European I’m a fan of laws that make platforms and big tech responsible for the content they house, but there is no denying that vetting that every OnlyFan sexworker is a task they can’t likely perform easily. Of course moderation is only one of the solutions, paying money and accepting the financial damage that may come from lack of moderation is another. Of course the big banks know this, which is why they charge an insane margin for their credit card services to platforms like onlyfans, it’s likely they simply upped the price behind the closed doors.
- marktangotango 5y agoCoinbase (and other financial services) do a pretty good job of requiring photo id on signup; I don't know what OF procedure is, but there's definitly precedent.
- littlecranky67 5y agoI'd be interested in the Coinbase verification requirements, do you have a link? Like a lot of Companies these day they don't give that information away before you sign up and agree to their ToS.
- quantumBerry 5y agoIt's government provided ID + SSN + photo of yourself + address / personal details. If your gov ID doesn't have your current address you have to show a utility or other bill. That all wouldn't be good enough for sex crimes though, because even if you have a passport + gov ID + a notary signed statement saying you are 18 and your own mother vouching for you, the counterparty can still be convicted of rape if it turns out you're lying about your age. Of course this is really all just to keep the law abiding law abiding. Criminals on the dark web will just buy a forged electronic id package and KYC is bypassed.
- jliptzin 5y agoI don’t understand why they don’t just use Bitcoin or some other crypto, seems like this is the exact use case it was designed for
- barbazoo 5y agoIt's not practical to use bitcoin for individual transactions due to the high cost. If there was an easy way for non-tech people to cash in and out of crypto currency easily I bet that would be a good alternative.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoNow ask yourself how much business they could do if they couldn't process credit cards or make cash payouts?
- nemothekid 5y ago>I don’t understand why they don’t just use Bitcoin or some other crypto, seems like this is the exact use case it was designed for The most popular options, BTC & ETH, are incredibly expensive for $20 subscription payments.
- quantumBerry 5y agoSo pay with LTC or XMR instead? There are plenty of high liquidity coins with low transaction fees, these are just a couple examples. If the alternative is to not cam at all it seems pretty obvious, even if you are unbanked and get hit with 7% fees from an ATM or crypto-fiat in person moneychanger. It's also trivial to exchange BTC to LTC (or other low fee coin), you don't even need KYC or in some cases to even use an exchange (atomic swap BTC-LTC). So the cam girls could take fees in LTC and then swap them to BTC once they have enough value to be worth the transactional costs.
- webinvest 5y agoNo. Ones with transaction fees under $3.
- 5y ago
- chipotle_coyote 5y agoYes: > “The proposed Oct. 1, 2021 changes are no longer required due to banking partners’ assurances that OnlyFans can support all genres of creators,” [an OnlyFans spokesperson] said. https://variety.com/2021/digital/news/onlyfans-drops-porn-ban-sexually-explicit-policy-1235048705/ https://variety.com/2021/digital/news/onlyfans-drops-porn-ba... The Variety article theorizes that the backlash may have actually been exactly the outcome OnlyFans wanted, because they were able to focus public outrage toward the banks and payment processors putting them in that position.
- brundolf 5y agoI'm honestly surprised the market forces are strong enough that the banks have to care about the bad PR at all Nobody wants to change banks even when it affects them directly. How many people are going to change banks out of principle? I guess some Gen Zers might be motivated not to pick Chase as their first bank?
- chipotle_coyote 5y agoI don't have great answers to that, although I think by "banking partners" they actually mean "credit card companies" and most specifically mean MasterCard, which (assuming reporting on this I've read is correct) was or may still be in the process of further tightening their policies around adult content. Well, a not-great but plausible answer, maybe -- companies make changes, both good and ill, because they're panicked over PR fiascos all the time. From all appearances, MasterCard announced those policy changes because of PR pressure that was put on them by "Exodus Cry," a fundamentalist Christian anti-porn activist group. OnlyFans may have calculated that their best bet was to knock Exodus Cry off their hashtag-save-the-children pedestal.
- skohan 5y agoHonestly that seems even more far-fetched. Visa and MasterCard are essentially a duopoly. Where on earth are customers going to flee to on bad pr?