5 ms·
It's never malice. Nobody goes, "hey, this compound is 100% only women and children, let's bomb it." Reality: "A patrol nearby said they took fire from the com
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
It's never malice. Nobody goes, "hey, this compound is 100% only women and children, let's bomb it."
Reality: "A patrol nearby said they took fire from the compound at such and such grid coordinates" It gets bombed. Turns out the unit on the ground was mistaken.
War is hell. War criminals should be punished. But it's not a war crime to make a mistake. I love seeing these posts because it's clear that almost nobody here has experienced war. My ROEs were ridiculously strict on the ground in southern Afghanistan.
It's important to have some context as well:
> According to the United Nations, the Taliban and its allies were responsible for 76% of civilian casualties in Afghanistan in 2009, 75% in 2010 and 80% in 2011.
So sure. Both sides have killed civilians. But one side tries it's best to be accountable and limit human suffering while still carrying out missions. The alternative is to not be there at all.
- trothamel 5y agoThank you for this perspective.
- enriquto 5y ago> But it's not a war crime to make a mistake. I suppose that you are from the USA and your family is living there. Imagine that some afghan-controlled drone intended to kill some U.S. soldiers (a legitimate target because they are enemy combatants). But instead they kill your family. If it was a mistake, by the own account of the drone operator, would you still maintain that the killing of your whole family was not a war crime? Would you defend the drone operator in that case? Please notice that at the moment when they were killed, they were just enjoying a picnic in a field, minding their own business, unbeknownst that in another valley a few miles away there was a secret military training camp. I need to hear from you if you honestly think that the murderer of your family would be innocent in that case.
- rscoots 5y agoThere is such a thing as criminal negligence in choosing and attacking enemy targets. But no, adding a whole bunch of emotional baggage to the act does not suddenly make any collateral death a war crime as you imply here. Bombing runs are woefully innarcurate though, so the good thing is when we have better weapons we'll start using those instead. Unlike insurgency groups who will often kill civilians as a means. Think that was partly the above poster's point.
- coding123 5y agoI'm going to be a little dismissive of the question, but that's how the laws work in the united states. If someone was drunk that's a little different, but from the perspective of someone making a mistake on the road, and a family ends up dead - the person that made the mistake (assuming they prove that in court) does not end up with a murder charge. It may still end up being manslaughter and jail time. Now to more specifically reply. So in the United States we may certainly have war on our doorstep at some point in the future. But our country tries to prevent that at ALL COSTS. We do so by making sure other countries are stable. We may fuck up by inserting into the wrong countries. but if ALL COUNTRIES just stabilize themselves we would NEVER have to go. And by the way, that's why the united nations was created. It would (or should) never allow the united states to insert themselves in a war that was not just. It may end up in an unjust position, but that's not where we started.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y ago> that's not where we started. This is just wishful thinking. The difference between the Afghanistan when Bush decided to invade it and now is that the Taliban are stronger, have more equipment, and basically sure nobody will ever invade them again after the lessons they gave to the USSR and the USA. Same when you look at Irak or Libya. Your idea of stabilizing is completely at odds with what happens in reality.
- gus_massa 5y ago> But our country tries to prevent that at ALL COSTS. I agree. Allcaps included. > We do so by making sure other countries are stable. Ehh... that part is more dubious. For example see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Central_Intelligence_Agency_operations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Central_Intelligence_...
- coding123 5y agoWhat am I supposed to be looking at here. I see an operation to capture Osama. Black sites, some weird other stuff. But I am not finding a specific example of something causing instability (at least on purpose).
- gmadsen 5y agoWhy would I defend an enemy combatant? The issue is whether it is a war crime, it is not. That in no way diminishes the horrible hellscape that is war.
- CapricornNoble 5y ago>>>If it was a mistake, by the own account of the drone operator, would you still maintain that the killing of your whole family was not a war crime? That's not a war CRIME, that's just war. If/when the shooting eventually starts with the Chinese (or the North Koreans), I and my family live down the street from some of the likeliest theater ballistic missile targets in the region. If an errant TBM levels my apartment building, I'll absolutely do everything I can to terminate the enemy soldiers with extreme prejudice...but I recognize that they are doing their jobs, and unless it is proven they were clearly aiming for a civilian target (such as a sports event), then no, I wouldn't consider their acts CRIMINAL.
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoNo one else would be given such a charitable viewpoint. Especially since it was a freaking radio that set off the kill process.
- dTal 5y agoNestled in between "malice" and "honest mistake" is "criminal negligence". When you put yourself in that position - when you invade a country - every resulting civilian casualty is on you. You do not have the moral standing to decide what is and is not acceptable "collateral damage". War is hell, but you chose to make war there. The civilians didn't. >the Taliban and its allies were responsible for 76% of civilian casualties in Afghanistan in 2009 Or to phrase it another way, allied forces killed a third as many civilians as the actual Taliban, a regime noted for its extreme brutality and callous attitude to human life. I'm not impressed.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago> to phrase it another way, allied forces killed a third as many civilians as the actual Taliban > According to the United Nations, the Taliban and its allies were responsible for 76% of civilian casualties in Afghanistan in 2009, 75% in 2010 and 80% in 2011. Interesting. How do you get one third out of those numbers?
- CapricornNoble 5y ago>>>How do you get one third out of those numbers? 25% / 75% = 1/3.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoStrange phrasing. Sounds worse than: America and its allies were responsible for 20-25% of civilian casualties. The UN doesn't use that phrasing.
- Taylor_OD 5y agoAnd every time we slaughtered a family in the middle east over the last 20+ years we've given a man or a son or an uncle with no remaining family a reason to hate the US and to revolt against it. There are almost certainly more Taliban and other terrorist group members who have a legitimate reason to dislike the US than there were 20 years ago.
- queuebert 5y agoI would think that deploying lethal force without positive target ID is against ROE.
- lifeformed 5y agoMaybe not malice but also not just simply accidents - more like negligence. We can't dismiss mistakes in war as simply a cost of doing business. > But one side tries it's best to be accountable and limit human suffering while still carrying out missions. Is that side really doing their "best"? I feel like a lot of these mistakes are avoidable with better procedures, training, and reducing being in situations where mistakes are even possible. I'm not expecting a war to go perfectly but is tens of thousands of accidental civilian killings the best we can do?
- CapricornNoble 5y ago>>>We can't dismiss mistakes in war as simply a cost of doing business. When you are putting fallible human beings into the most stressful and demanding situations imaginable, it's unreasonable to NOT factor in a baseline level of human error. >>>I feel like a lot of these mistakes are avoidable with better procedures, training, What specific procedures would you like to adjust? Escalation of Force? Rules of Engagement? The entire Joint fires killchain? https://warontherocks.com/2017/05/its-about-time-the-pressing-need-to-evolve-the-kill-chain/ https://warontherocks.com/2017/05/its-about-time-the-pressin... >>>I'm not expecting a war to go perfectly but is tens of thousands of accidental civilian killings the best we can do? Against adversaries that actively use the civilian population as human shields, or who pretend to be civilians themselves to exploit our ROE? Yeah, that's a decently low casualty rate for TWO DECADES of dropping bombs on a country, across countless thousands of aircraft sorties. It's still led to some technical solutions to the problem of collateral damage, which is why we have the Small Diameter Bomb family: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GBU-39_Small_Diameter_Bomb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GBU-39_Small_Diameter_Bomb and also the R9X variant of the Hellfire missile: https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/munitions/agm-114r9x.htm https://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/munitions/ag...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lifeformed 5y ago> it's unreasonable to NOT factor in a baseline level of human error. I'm not saying human error doesn't exist, but that the amount we tolerate is too high. > Yeah, that's a decently low casualty rate for TWO DECADES of dropping bombs on a country, across countless thousands of aircraft sorties. It's easy to reduce that casualty rate: stop dropping bombs on a country for two decades. My point is that the cost of a civilian death is too low. If we considered the moral cost and not just the strategic cost, our calculations would conclude that we can't afford to start this war. The dubious moral reasons for doing it are not outweighed by the moral harm that would result. I get that you're addressing the technical aspects of collateral damage in a war, but an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure. In a justified war, we can tolerate civilian deaths as a necessary evil, but if the war is not just, then aren't all such deaths an unnecessary evil?
- drewcoo 5y agoWe're talking about drone attacks, not invitations to our lemonade social. It is always malice. This might help clear it up: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/malice https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/malice
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- watwut 5y ago> Nobody goes, "hey, this compound is 100% only women and children, let's bomb it." Actually, people do. That happens fairly regularly in conflicts. Civilians are often a target by policy. Plus, by neglect - superiors not caring what this or that sociopath does. In Afghanistan case, there was period when per policy anyone with walkie talkie counted as valid target. Phones did not worked. So there is fair chance some attacks hit civilians and it was policy.
- ashwagary 5y agoDidn't they knowingly bomb weddings? Is he saying the US was surprised that innocent women and children were at weddings?