6 ms·
Like the author, I've tried a ton of open source handheld platforms, and I've recently moved to CalyxOS for my daily driver. (And about to sell a box o' device
by neilv 5y ago
Like the author, I've tried a ton of open source handheld platforms, and I've recently moved to CalyxOS for my daily driver. (And about to sell a box o' devices to help cost-justify buying a second Pixel for a backup CalyxOS device.)
As Android devices go, CalyxOS seems a good choice, if you're willing to not have all the Google service conveniences. I actually found some of the UX smoother than on iPhone, and e-mail worked better. Though note that CalyxOS is not as polished for privacy out of the box as users might assume.
One big problem is that Android is massive, and also doesn't seem to have been designed or deployed in practice to be privacy-friendly, nor especially open source-friendly. Even back in the FirefoxOS days, if you built that from source, it was clear there was no way you could audit or maintain all its Android dependencies (my hope was that they'd throw out the Android layer as soon as they could).
I have some hopes for Purism's Librem 5 Phosh running atop a mainlined Linux with open drivers (and ideally firmwares) on many devices at many price points. Though available hardware tends to be fundamentally insecure.
There also seems to be an additional barrier of US carriers imminently requiring VoLTE, and in some cases only allowlisting a small number of models.
- CyberRabbi 5y agoHow are cross-distro Linux app packages looking these days? Not so much the packaging aspect but the sandbox environment they set up to run third-party apps in peace. Is this something librem is working on?
- m4rtink 5y agoI would expect lots of mobile apps to ship via Flatpak these days.
- CyberRabbi 5y agoDoes flatpak create a sandbox comparable to iOS?
- kaladin-jasnah 5y ago> There also seems to be an additional barrier of US carriers imminently requiring VoLTE, and in some cases only allowlisting a small number of models. Is this all carriers, or just some? I know that AT&T is the main one since I'm affected by it (their whitelist arbitrarily removes my OnePlus 6 from being supported this February despite the phone supporting VoLTE), but I heard that other carriers such as T-Mobile are still working without VoLTE. Either way, the whole "requiring VoLTE" thing could even be a problem for some custom ROMs (not even GNU/Linux phones) since I believe VoLTE support is something that ROMs sometimes miss, which will be pretty bad. While I'm not a full "privacy" user (yet), I use custom ROMs for extending the lifetime of my phone and getting newer updates than I would on the stock ROM, and carrier limitations could seriously threaten a lot of things.
- toast0 5y agoAs I understand it, US carriers already turned off 2G and are turning 3G off real soon now. If your phone doesn't do VoLTE and wants to do a voice call, that won't work when 3G is turned off.
- kaladin-jasnah 5y agoAT&T takes it a step further. Only if my phone does do VoLTE and AT&T puts it on their magic whitelist (which you can bet, for example, is not going to have the PinePhone on it) am I going to be able to use my phone at all on AT&T's network (well, at least that's my understanding). Other carriers might not have a whitelist though—but I'm not sure.
- toast0 5y agoI recall T-Mobile used to be pretty uptight about using band X for LTE only for VoLTE phones because they wouldn't be able to go from data to dialing 911 if they only had band X coverage (it was better for TMo if the user had no coverage in that case for regulatory reasons), but I think TMo is less strict about what phones they'll provision for VoLTE. I only remember trouble getting my first LTE phone to work, but LTE was newish; once I got a TMo firmware on it, it would provision and unlock whatever band it was I was trying to use, even though the IMEI would have been for an ATT model.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- cookiengineer 5y agoHonestly, I don't understand the selling point of CalyxOS over LineageOS. Can you explain the differences? The website just seems to be a little mumble about Privacy without explaining the technological differences. As a daily driver, I'd recommend a setup of an official LineageOS device, combined with a set of Apps to increase the level of privacy: - AppWarden to check for trackers and loggers - RethinkDNS as a VPN firewall and adblocker - Privay Browser (f-droid build) - Permission Manager X to remove permissions from Apps via AppOps - OsmAnd for Navigation - Oeffi for Public Transport Navigation (in Germany) - Element or Telegram FOSS for chat, because Signal still requires microG or other Google Services for their auto backup, which I don't agree with. I would also recommend to bet on LineageOS because the community is vast, and it's more likely to survive (given the past with Cyanogen and its company) than other forks that are maintained by 1-3 people. Personally, I hope that phosh and plasma mobile can be feasible app alternatives and I hope that Purism and the Pine movement can change the ecosystem. But, as of now, developing a GTK4 or QT5 app (compared to making an Android app) is still PITA and seriously lacks better development tools and IDEs.
- circularfoyers 5y agoI believe the appeal for CalyxOS is attempting to bring more convenience with privacy, where apps you've mentioned are already installed. A major difference is the inclusion of microG, which means you have more freedom to use apps you have no alternative to (e.g. government apps, banking apps, etc). I'm aware of the LineageOS for microG project, however apart from the aforementioned preinstalled set of apps, CalyxOS includes many system patches shared by other projects such as GrapheneOS, which include privacy enhancements on default AOSP DNS fallbacks, connectivity checks, NTP, and more. I would also like to mention that Signal does not require microG or Google Play Services for auto backup (or notifications). The backup files are stored locally on the device and can be easily synced with Syncthing, Nextcloud, etc.
- cookiengineer 5y agoAh, okay, makes sense. The network connectivity, NTP issues and others are the reason why I have Termux installed (to be able to modify the /system/etc/hosts file, as the network core library ignores VPN settings). Granted, streamlining these apps makes more sense to the end user. I wish Android would have a package manager that would allow creating a meta package for this kind of stuff.