3 ms·
What's going to be a game changer is when stories start breaking about owners who rent out their space as a way to lure in people for killing or torturing them.
by mgkimsal 15y ago
What's going to be a game changer is when stories start breaking about owners who rent out their space as a way to lure in people for killing or torturing them.
Right now it's about "you were stupid, why did you rent your space out to strangers?". Later on it'll be "why did you try to save $20 and go sleep some place where you're 110% vulnerable?". You don't control the locks, you don't know the neighborhood or even the layout of the house all that well (are there cameras in the room spying on you?).
If Holiday Inn or Marriott had tried to go 'downmarket' by trying to get in the "rent out your space with us - we'll handle the booking logistics", they'd have been eaten alive by the insurance costs of dealing with QA on thousands of rooms/spaces they don't control. They'd have too much name brand recognition and goodwill in their names to lose by leaving customer safety and security to chance. ABNB seems to be coming at this from the other way. What do they have to lose? Investor money? It's a big experiment for them, which they're hoping will pay off, but I think there's a reasons beyond "laziness" or "not getting it" to explain why larger companies well-versed in hospitality/property management have not gone down this road.
Will things still work out for ABNB? They might, but they're taking such a hit on this by not just making some of these situations right, then changing their procedures and policies. Apparently these incidents - as infrequent as they may be - have been occurring for a while. There's probably quite a few more that haven't come forward because they've felt it was their own fault, much like domestic abuse spouses blame themselves. Not really wanting to see ABNB fail, but can't help watching this play out, and I somewhat suspect it'll get worse before it gets better.
- rokhayakebe 15y agoWhat's going to be a game changer is when stories start breaking about owners who rent out their space as a way to lure in people for killing or torturing them. I agree 100%. However I ask say how in the world did you think about this?
- mgkimsal 15y agoMy wife and I watch a lot of murder mystery movies as well as true crime stuff. AirBNB is a "48 Hours" episode waiting to happen. Ann Curry and Keith Morrison will have a field day with it.
- pseudonym 15y agoSomeone's been watching Hostel. That said, I wouldn't be surprised if there have already been cases of hosts faking complaints to AirBnB about "that guest stole X Y and Z"-- but because they're only after money in the first place, they're a lot easier to shut up.
- dspillett 15y agoI thought it too when I heard about the service and how little vetting is done (i.e. not, it is all left to the users). A fair number of rape/murder/other cases involve an unwitting victim being lured into situations that they naively (or just incorrectly) think should be safe. It is far from a daily occurrence in any given area but such cases are in the national news often enough (and fictional realms also) to figure in the minds of the more paranoid! 1. think of using AirBnB, 2. perfectly healthy paranoia kicks in and starts listing worst-case scenarios, 3. book into a large well known chain hotel instead...
- mgkimsal 15y agoNot just 'no vetting' is done, but they actively discourage you from making your own outside contact with the other party until you've already paid. Craigslist doesn't go that far - they do hide your email, but they don't stop you from trying to do your own vetting.
- mbreese 15y agoDon't forget about the inevitable hidden cameras...
- ig1 15y agoThis already happens on classified ad sites, people regularly go into strangers homes to purchase a wide range of goods with close to zero pre-checks. And yes people do get killed when they turn up at someone's house with 5k in cash to buy a car. Doesn't seem to have stopped the classified business from working...
- mgkimsal 15y agoWhile you're right, it hasn't stopped them, "classifieds" have largely been eroded by things like Craigslist, which do allow you to do a bit of research and contact on your own. They don't prevent it. And I typically am not paying for the privilege of meeting my ransacker/assailant. What's more, CL (and others) actively try to scare you with warnings about how not to get scammed and such. ABNB doesn't seem to take that approach, trying to wrap the whole thing up as a comfy/pleasing experience.
- ig1 15y agoCraigslist is a classified site, and it's had it's share or rapes and killings: http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=craigslist%20killing http://www.google.co.uk/search?q=craigslist%20killing
- hugh3 15y agoThough interestingly, there wasn't nearly as much blame heaped on craigslist when this happened as is currently being heaped on airbnb.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- watchandwait 15y agoCL is free and arms-length for rentals, while AirBnB is an active broker and financial participant in their rentals.
- jbooth 15y ago
- simonw 15y agoIt's a lot easier to hold a host accountable for a crime, since their address is on record.
- jimbojones 15y agoThe whole concept is a disaster waiting to happen. What is going to happen when criminals start exploiting this system of casual rentals? Imagine all the different things people can do with control of your home and address, not least of which is using it as a base to receive stolen merchandise or dangerous/blatantly illegal goods. When will the first swat team need to be called to one of these locations? I can't recall ever being to a hotel that didn't require ID... why would anyone rent out their home/apartment without meeting the people in person and checking their ID?
- coffeemug 15y agoThere's probably quite a few more that haven't come forward because they've felt it was their own fault, much like domestic abuse spouses blame themselves. A different way to put this is that most rational people recognize that letting strangers into their home is completely within the realm of their personal responsibility. AirBnB will have to put some processes in place in order for the business to succeed in the mainstream, but that doesn't absolve the hosts of responsibility for their apartments. Comparing this to domestic abuse victims is ludicrous.
- temphn 15y agoHow is this different than craigslist, a dating site, meetup.com or really any site that allows random people on the internet to meet each other in person? People need to have some smarts about who they meet with. The service can do some things, like integrating the Facebook graph, but ultimately the two parties to the transaction must be responsible for checking each other out before they meet.
- mukyu 15y agoWhat's going to be a game changer is when stories start breaking about owners who rent out their space as a way to lure in people for killing or torturing them. This has already[1] happened with an actual hotel, so you had better stick with Holiday Inn (and make sure it is really a Holiday Inn). [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._H._Holmes#Chicago_and_the_.22Murder_Castle.22 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/H._H._Holmes#Chicago_and_the_.2...