3 ms·
I was in Google Ads from 2008-2010. At that time, there was a limit of 3 top ads and 8 right-hand-side ads. The top ads generated the vast bulk of the revenue.
by AlbertCory 5y ago
I was in Google Ads from 2008-2010. At that time, there was a limit of 3 top ads and 8 right-hand-side ads. The top ads generated the vast bulk of the revenue.
They were also in blue or yellow (I forget which, but one was WAY more lucrative than the other!) so it was very easy for the user to distinguish an ad from a search result.
I just did the canonical $$$ search "flowers" on my Macbook. The entire first page was ads and they are not colored anymore (although they do say "Ad"). There is also a Maps snippet which shows where I can buy flowers.
What happened? Well, I can guess: they did experiments, and not coloring the ads produced more revenue. I know from talking to ordinary users that they often say proudly "I never click on ads!" Now they do.
- azalemeth 5y agoAnd, simultaneously, I've switched search engines to DDG (something I last did in the mid 1990s -- to Google!), and have multilayered network, browser, and hosts-file level adblocking. Such is the price of progress...
- AlbertCory 5y agoDDG is pretty good and it's my first try for searching. Occasionally Google is still better. Just today, I was looking for old financial data on Synoptics (late 80s). Google has books & journals from back then; DDG does not.
- ExtraE 5y agoI just tried this (firefox on iOS, new england). Google asked for my location and I said “no”. TLDR: 2 ads, the rest organic. Top-2 were ads, a maps widget, organic result, people also ask, 4 organic results, people also search for, images, 4 organic, 1 ad.
- asdff 5y agoReally? I just did this on desktop and the first two pages were all advertisements for florists. These sorts of links used to be demarked as ads on google search in the before times. Wikipedia didn't even appear until page three. That used to be the first result for a typical noun search.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI very rarely click on Google Web Search ads. I very rarely use Google Web Search. Poor relevance and ubiquitous tracking is a key condern. But the ad-spamming is also tremendously out of hand. I'd switched to Google from AltaVista in 1999. I ditched GWS effectively by 2013. Yes, I'll still occasionally run a "!g" bang search. And there are Google services I find genuinely useful --- Google Books and Ngram Viewer most especially. But the bloom hasn't been anywhere near that rose for a long, long, long, long time.
- hlau 5y agoReally surprised to hear that you’re not getting the relevance out of Google. Are most of your searches in a specific domain that’s somehow not covered properly by Google? And is there a search engine that does a better job for you? I’ve tried using services like DDG and find myself falling back to Google more often than not.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe problem is generally typical of online content as a whole given SEO gaming and commercialisation. DDG's bang searches and the ability to fluidly target searches to specific sites with less typing and fewer hops is a key differentiator. The most relevant quality content tends to come from published rather than online sources, or by going direct to source. The Web has been a mistake. That said, Google's SERP page content, layout, tracking, and advertising all effectively drop relevance by a tremendous amount --- I've got to consciously filter out Google's own crap on top of the irrelevant web results returned. DDG's cleaner presentation increases effective quality by a subjectively-assessed factor of 2--10. Date-bounded search remains one of the very few reasons to favour GWS for a specific search, though even that is highly unreliable. Often what I want is a searchable archive from a given period, not a guestimate of a date-ranged search over the live Web. Even in Google Books, date-ranged search results very often fail to return content from the requested period.
- _nalply 5y ago> The Web has been a mistake. In hindsight, what would have been better?
- caust1c 5y agoHoly shit. No wonder google doesn't give a shit about adblockers. Those people would be the ones who care about litigation and stopping this shit. Easy to let such a small % of users slide when the other 99% will willingly fall into the ad trap. This is insane: https://i.imgur.com/bdtvyXF.png https://i.imgur.com/bdtvyXF.png
- helen___keller 5y agoWow, I had no idea because it's been so long since I've been without ad blockers. Interestingly, I tried the same on DuckDuckGo and it seemed almost identical: some inlined ads, shopping results, have to scroll down to find actual search results. (main difference: embedded non-ad results like wikipedia and news).
- AlbertCory 5y agoFor the other canonical query, try "mesothelioma." An info box on the right, and four ads on the left. At one time, this was the highest-priced ad in Google (idk if it still is), because personal injury lawyers were desperate to get clients.