13 ms·
Black barbers have become mental health advocates for African American men
- da39a3ee 5y agoI know it's well-intentioned, and I know American society has very real structural race problems which shouldn't be ignored or denied, but articles like this really risk being patronizing, and worse, implying that most or all black childhoods are as flawed as the one described.
- 3maj 5y agoWelcome to the American Media Establishment. It's better to just read FT and SCMP while only skimming the NYT/Fox/etc.
- pjc50 5y agoWhy the South China Morning Post?
- drocer88 5y agoSCMP was acquired by Alibaba and has become more supportive of Chinese Communist Party: https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/south-china-morning-post/ https://mediabiasfactcheck.com/south-china-morning-post/ . I can't vouch for this analysis. I think they are not what they used to be.
- 3maj 5y agoThat's unfortunate, I didn't know that. But they used to be fairly unbiased and critical of the Chinese government.
- drocer88 5y agoThey used to be high quality. Many news organizations have dropped a few notches. It is unfortunate that Hong Kong has lost its independence and suffering more and more from Chinese Communist policies.
- aaccount 5y agowhy is this even on HN?
- blueline 5y ago> On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity.
- wisethrowaway 5y agoLeft wing stories: "Intellectual Curiosity (TM)" Right wing opinion: Insta[Flagged]
- chalst 5y agoWhile I find the article and some of the comments interesting, I don't think it's a good fit for HN. Articles should provoke curious conversation; this one, judging from the number of dead posts, is provoking too much tribalism.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoIt's good at exposing racists, that's for sure.
- wisethrowaway 5y agoAnd gulag guards too.
- minikites 5y agoIf it was tribalism, the dead posts would be extreme opinions from both sides. The dead posts here are only from one side.
- wisethrowaway 5y ago
- andyxor 5y agoanother bs article from CNN
- umvi 5y agoReminds me of the Pixar movie "Soul" (which is very good)
- bitwize 5y agoThe barbershop scenes from Soul were one of the things that made me think they were trying to make an authentic, specifically black movie that nevertheless had universal resonance (and they succeeded).
- kmill 5y agoThis reminds me how a chauffeur working for Pixar picked up on what they were up to early in production: https://www.npr.org/2021/03/27/981553332/not-my-job-we-quiz-the-writer-of-one-night-in-miami-on-one-knight-in-miami https://www.npr.org/2021/03/27/981553332/not-my-job-we-quiz-...
- packetslave 5y agoThere's an outstanding featurette on Disney+ about "Soul" (part of the "Inside Pixar" series, I think) where Kemp Powers, the co-director and screenwriter talks specifically about adding the barbershop scene(s) because it's such an important part of the African-American culture.
- minikites 5y ago>Systemic racism has created a unique need for support in the Black community, yet national data shows many African American communities are woefully under-resourced and underrepresented in behavioral health care. The past year has exacerbated these challenges. The pandemic has disproportionately affected African Americans, and the repeated instances of racial injustice and police brutality have led to an increased need for mental health services in the Black community. I'm glad this avenue is available and I'm glad this work is being done, but it's just one step towards making a more just and equitable society. Initiatives like this should be used as a bridge towards real and meaningful change in improving underserved communities affected by the legacies of slavery and current systemic racism.
- wisethrowaway 5y agoLooking forward to the comment that reads "after seeing all these HORRIBLE comments it shows we still need a lot of work to do to educate ourselves about race"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jimkleiber 5y agoYes, Lorenzo! I remember talking to my friend Lorenzo back in 2013-14 when he was just starting this. So proud to finally see someone I know as the top story on HN :-)
- Abishek_Muthian 5y agoThere's a scene[1] in the Pixar movie 'Soul' where the main character(a black man) goes for a haircut to a black barbershop and has a deep philosophical discussion. Director Kemp Powers says 'There's really no more authentic black space in the community than a barber shop'[2] for the reason to have that scene. Your friend and his team has put that space to a great use; Congratulations. [1] https://youtu.be/MPXjSCHsfxY?t=21 https://youtu.be/MPXjSCHsfxY?t=21 [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0GLyDJveVs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0GLyDJveVs
- bsedlm 5y agoThey might not be therapists, but they are filling a similar role as therapy. Sometimes people just need to vent towards an 'objective' (external) listener who will provide feedback of some sort.
- kamfc 5y agoCounselors are more like it. Or a stranger at the bar you can vent to. Therapists do more from my personal experience.
- randomopining 5y agoWhy do people need to meld their ego with some nebulous "classification"? Like yo I'm black. Yo I'm white. Yo I'm asian. In reality, all humans are a continuous spectrum based off of groups of people that evolved in certain conditions over thousands of years. What does a "white" person from Ireland have in common with a "white" person from the Caucuses? What does a "black" person from Sierra Leone have in common with a "black" person from the deserts in the northeast of Africa? Why does the media make us segregate ego formation based off of these shallow descriptors? Black white etc.
- ajsnigrutin 5y ago> Why does the media make us segregate ego formation based off of these shallow descriptors? Black white etc. Because it mases us fight eachother, and not the ones that we should be fighting.
- booleandilemma 5y agoDivide and conquer.
- abc_lisper 5y agoIt is like the ship of Theseus. Aggregates exist because that's how we abstract, even though calling it identity would be wrong. I don't know what a good solution is.
- refenestrator 5y agoIdeally we could unmoor it from the arbitrary 100 year old census categories. Yeah, you have to draw arbitrary lines somewhere but our current set is really dumb.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chickenpotpie 5y ago“ What does a "black" person from Sierra Leone have in common with a "black" person from the deserts in the northeast of Africa?” They face the same discrimination in America and in that they find companionship
- whatshisface 5y agoIf HN can look past the usual tropes, there's something interesting here. Lewis is trying to solve a problem a lot of other people are trying to solve: how can you have a normal community in US culture? Let me list a few solutions and you will see why his is better than average. 1. Religion. Pros: Going to church has tied communities together for millennia, and if you could just find some better pastors, it could continue for several millennia more. Cons: Secularly administering religion like a drug to treat social ills is against the precepts of every known religion, due to the fact that we'd all expect missionaries to believe what they're preaching. People who go around saying "I believe because it helps me" but who do not actually believe anything notwithstanding, we all know that's not self-consistent. 2. An amalgamation of historical myths and power structures that tie people together on the basis of perceived brotherhood. Pros: People love being tied together on the basis of perceived brotherhood, tribal identity has been around a long time, and there is no debating with the idea that it works. Cons: This is a description of every supremacist organization. 3. You talk to the guy at the barbershop. Pros: You like to talk to the guy at the barbershop. Cons: You can't go if you don't have the money for a haircut. None of these options are perfect... but the barbershop plan is not that bad.
- x86_64Ubuntu 5y agoOne word about the cons of #3, you can absolutely go to a black barbershop with no intentions of ever getting your haircut. Older black men will sometimes hang out there, or stop by through the day on the weekend just to catch up with one another.
- ouid 5y agoThis is such a poorly crafted argument that it's hard to imagine it's not in bad faith. You listed religion twice! The only way this is representative of any kind of "normal" culture is if you have defined it that way. Let's think about a couple more ways that you could go about obtaining a community in the US. leisure: clubs, cafes, live music events, bars, gyms. proximity: neighborhood, induced parent communities from child communities. functional: PTAs, HOAs, coworkers, colleagues. etc.
- 5y ago
- zthrowaway 5y agoThis is common with cosmetology and all people regardless of background, my mother has been in that business for her entire working life and it’s surprising how much therapy she has to do outside of just cutting hair.
- intorpor 5y agoThese "articles" have one single purpose: to create more racial disparity.* Reference: https://imgur.com/a/uycJp3E https://imgur.com/a/uycJp3E Time to wake up.
- jacobrobbins 5y agoThis is really interesting and seems like a great example of how small businesses are better for their community than chains. When I lived in Fort Greene brooklyn I was surprised by how many barbershops and hair salons there were, like 5 or more on the single little triangular block at fulton and greene. It seemed clear they were providing more of a community function than just the utility of getting a haircut that i was familiar with. On a side note I never got comfortable with making conversation while getting my haircut and eventually settled on just cutting my own hair at home. That said I never tried the barbershop-type places and usually went to pretty generic haircut shops.
- gizmo686 5y agoIsn't McDonalds also well known to be a community center?
- rytor718 5y agoThe black community in America has known this forever. We've had to rely on these kinds of businesses, not just as sources of goods and services, but as literal community centers that help people out, sometimes for free. Thats still true, same for salons, corner grocery stores, churches etc. Growing up, these little pieces of community were amazing and still are. While people are of course a little different, I still see these things in the community where I live and they still have the same compassionate professionals most of the time. They dont just sell things. They also give.
- djtriptych 5y ago
- okareaman 5y agoFor me, this article is about mentoring younger people and benefits it provides. I mentor a young brilliant programmer who I used to work with. I maintained a relationship with him after I retired. He called me up last night frantic about some issues. I know he drinks too much and that he has mental health issues, so I was able to talk him through it. We talked about solutions for his drinking problem. He thanked me later for helping him. He calls me about 3 times a year with these freak outs. Helping him makes me feel useful and doing some good. I have a similar relationship with my son, so this programmer is like an adopted son, which I encourage because my philosophy is we are not alone in the world, but have people around us that care about us and are willing to help if we can put down our pride and ask for help. I wouldn't be alive today if I hadn't asked for help and then let people help me.
- systemvoltage 5y agoThat felt good to read, thanks.
- SinParadise 5y agoYou are a good man.
- okareaman 5y agoThank you. I think most healthy people have this goodness in them but the modern world puts more emphasis satisfying the self. I discovered the benefits of practicing kindness when someone was kind to me.
- touisteur 5y agoI feel we're not exposed much to that kind of positive behaviour while growing up. Busier and busier parents and grandparents, overwhelmed teachers, goal-oriented sports coaches. I can locate a few forks-in-the-road in my formative years, and they have to do with someone noticing I was hurting and being a little shit not to hurt others but out of despair, boredom, frustration, etc. and taking the time and energy to steer me towards creating, investing in doing rather than thinking (high school librarians), or to make me think on myself and what I was bringing to the teacher/student relation (later high school librarian) and helping prepare me for university. I just feel it's almost impossible to learn mentoring and 'giving back' when you haven't been either the target of it, or been witness to it.
- sandworm101 5y agoIt isn't because they are barbers. That is secondary. These are men's groups. This is men helping other men. Thanks to continued differences re hairstyles barber shops are one of the very few all-male places left in modern society (other than locker rooms which have a distinct competitive air). So it is no surprise that many urban men feel at home and are more willing to talk at the barber than anywhere else.
- namlem 5y agoI'm not sure that's entirely true. I feel like the same dynamic is still present in mixed-gender salons.
- imbnwa 5y agoI can vouch that in both Black and Puerto Rican barbershops, the ones in my neighborhood and have attended for most of my life, the range of possible topics is much less confined than a unisex space. Like, to the degree that I have to question your level of experience. It's not just dude's safely talking about their problems as the article highlights, that's an aspect, its literally dudes speaking freely without female intervention, e.g. men talking sex, etc. When a mother comes in to drop off her son or waits idly with him until he's gotten his cut, or a barber's girlfriend makes a quick stop in, the topics will change. Dudes don't just keep talking about the multiple women that they're engaging simultaneously in the presence of women (I understand one may find this topic distasteful but that's how some men use that space) , particularly since in these neighborhoods there are three degrees of separation or less, if not out of simple decency. Edit: Just to inflect this even more personally, my mother even was explicit about her desire for me to be acculturated more thoroughly in common Black masculinity by dropping me off at the barber shop because I was, relative to the other men in the world I grew up in, too bookish and (what gets called) introverted (I don't really like the use of that term but that's a different discussion), i.e. relatively feminine. That didn't really work, lol, but it was one of the few times she made her thought process explicit in my presence, which is why I distinctly remember it.
- ceilingcorner 5y agoIt goes against pretty much everything in the zeitgeist, but yeah, men and boys are really hurting from this lack of all-male spaces. I hope culture boomerangs around enough to permit them sometime soon.
- holdupnow 5y agoI wish I had this at my barber.
- andyxor 5y agono matter how cute the barber story is, you can't ignore the fact this is political propaganda from a primary propaganda source. it's what pg calls "submarine PR", in this case for Dems "systemic racism" agenda, the more people believe this bs the more votes they get.
- poopypoopington 5y agoHonestly what? How is what you're saying not a racist dogwhistle? It's political propaganda why? Because they're Black?
- andyxor 5y agothere is no evidence for systemic racism, is a purely political invention. Dems are fishing for minority votes through their favorite propaganda channels, but I don't think this will help them
- andscoop 5y agoThis comment is so far from my reality that I feel we must have different definitions of systemic racism. So I’m curious, what does systemic racism mean to you? Or to flip your statement around, what would systemic racism look like to you if it were to exist?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andyxor 5y agoDon’t bring up controversial political points if you don’t want to hear opposing views.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jjtheblunt 5y agoNo mention of Coming to America, where this happens? That resonated with white kids in suburban america too (i'm one) who had the same experience, with friends' grandfathers the longtime town barbers. My grandfathers had both died when i was tiny, so it was the only grandfather situation i had recurringly, and it wasn't just white or just black, btw. it's just a healthy thing, so good seeing it still goes on!
- ceilingcorner 5y agoThis used to be the case for most communities in America, before we decided that externalizing and professionalizing everything was the "economically efficient" solution. If you had a problem, you'd talk to the elder folks in your community and see what they thought about it. Now we barely know our neighbors and our community elders are shipped off to special-purpose holding facilities.
- tartoran 5y agoYes. Let’s hope it makes a comeback. The current direction is unsustainable..
- ProjectArcturis 5y agoI don't know, the confidentiality of a professional therapist is huge. Plus a lot of the elders I know would advise you to deal with depression by sucking it up. Or try to pray the gay away.
- kzrdude 5y agoNow a professional therapist might not want to tell you to do anything at all. The ones I've met have been very passive. They listen, it's great, but they don't point in any direction.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoWhile it's true that my therapist never tells me to do much of anything, he often offers me some much needed perspective I can use to make my own decisions to do or not do things. So, I guess you can say I indirectly get direction from my therapist.
- leetcrew 5y agodepends on the therapist and your situation. lots of difficult decisions in life come down to what you personally value. the therapist can talk it through with you, but they can't decide your values for you. on the other hand, if you're depressed and spend most of your time in bed, the therapist might strongly recommend that you try going outside more.
- motohagiography 5y agoViewing masculine gatherings and mentoring relationships through the lens of "therapy," is patronizing and another example of filtering culture through the narrative of powerlessness. Here's another take. Most people who say they want you to talk about your feelings are predators looking for angry and vulnerable young people who they can manipulate with sympathy and groom for other pipelines and agendas. The barber shops represent a barrier to those people because heterosexual men typically don't relate well to the sort of enablers who prey on young men, and those personalities cannot navigate masculine environments well. It's useful to ask whether people who say they are operating on the pretext of "healing," and "trauma," are really just morbidly attracted to weakness and vulnerability, and if so, why. These barbershops are places created by black men as a place to gather and have some community, and the reasons for a CNN reporter to pay them any attention at all should be treated with suspicion. Journalists aren't part of the communities they cover, they are scavengers and mainly a nuissance to what they perceive to be power, so if you start seeing them, it's probably because there is something nearby whose vulnerability or weakness has made it a target to co-opt into their narrative. Those barber shops are community treasures, and I'd wonder whether they benefit from having someone else co-opt their story and re-tell it on their behalf.
- whymauri 5y ago>Most people who say they want you to talk about your feelings are predators looking for angry and vulnerable young people who they can manipulate with sympathy and groom for other pipelines and agendas. I'm not really sure what this means... are you lumping in licensed therapists and social workers in here? Seems unfair to me, IMO. I guess just a little clarification would be useful, not trying to tear down your view or anything. I'm equally skeptic of journalists from big orgs like CNN coming into these spaces.
- motohagiography 5y agoThe examples I was thinking of came from growing up in a city where there is a layer of social workers, teachers, "educators," and even therapists who encourage young men to blame their problems on society and an oppression narrative instead of equipping them with the tools to develop constructive masculine friendships with boundaries. There are real systemic social issues that men who are american and black must face, but the article reframing normal relationships as therapy is precisely the kind of framing that harms male friendships. Maybe this coalition is doing good work, but anyone who leads with problematizing men talking about their feelings earns very reasonable suspicion, imo. The main reason I see men having trouble connecting is because they haven't spent enough time around another men to learn the normal cues and boundaries. Setting up their friendships in yet another relationship that treats them like problem children isn't going to help them.
- wobbly_bush 5y agoA question on the article title from someone who is not aware of the latest words to use w.r.t. race - why is it "Black barbers" but "African American men"? Why aren't both "black" or both "African American"?
- pvaldes 5y agoMost probably just a style choice. Is discouraged to repeat the same adjective again and again in a paragraph. Using a synonym the second time you see again the same concept is better. Rules for poetry are more permissive or sometimes even encourage it for emphasis. In prose to see -black- barbers... -black- clients... -black dogs-... -black- neighborhood... would sound stupid and boring after a while.
- dang 5y agoQuestions like that can be interesting but unfortunately there is no way that a comment like this will lead to interesting responses—just flames from users who, for whatever reason, have other, stronger feelings than curiosity right now. Therefore it's best, as the site guidelines ask, to "Eschew flamebait. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- racl101 5y agoBecause I have thick hair that grows fast I have to go to the barber often. So when I go to a barber I go for the quietest most disinterested barber I can find. I'm not good at doing small talk with the people cutting my hair. If they don't speak English even better. Thankfully my hair is simple to cut, although.
- joncrane 5y agoThis is timely because just yesterday I was watching "Central Intelligence" with Kevin Hart and The Rock. Early in the movie Kevin Hart's wife tries to get him to go to therapy and he says 'Black people don’t go to therapy. They go to barbershops to talk about their problems. And then they watch “Barbershop.”' I think therapy can be useful for people of all races, shapes, sizes, and genders, and I support all initiatives that encourage mental health.
- kelvin0 5y agoI think being able to talk about issues in your life and have an attentive ear is 50% therapy right there. Too many men keep things to themselves for too long. Once they feel cornered, their only perceived course of action is usually anger and violence in extreme cases.
- armchairhacker 5y agoBarbers are one of the few jobs left where the people servicing you actually converse with you. Grocery stores, restaurants, ride-shares, gyms, even your office are getting more impersonal. Which is honestly not a bad thing. I don't need to bother someone or get bothered when I'm going shopping or just want a meal, and I might not necessarily socialize well with my co-workers even if I work well with them. But we need other avenues for adult socialization. Current apps like social media and Tinder are garbage. Apps have the fundamental intention down: connecting people with similar interests. But online is not a replacement for in-person, all these popular social media apps are gamed and monetized. It's a hard problem.
- Slow_Hand 5y agoThe option to speak at length with a client while carrying out the work is a very satisfying quality in a job. I drove a pedicab every weekend for five years in downtown Austin and one of the great pleasures of the job is having your clients’ undivided attention for 5-10 min. It’s a perfect amount of time to get to know someone. Many times I would hit it off with them so well that we either exchanged info or I parked up up my cab and we continued to hang out for the evening. I’m someone who abhors small-talk, but if you give us time enough to connect in a sincere way it leaves you feeling great about the people you can meet.