2 ms·
> Remote Work [...] I thought [in contradistinction to the graph] that Hacker News would have been more ahead of the trend on this one. > For each topic I coun
by OJFord 5y ago
> Remote Work [...] I thought [in contradistinction to the graph] that Hacker News would have been more ahead of the trend on this one.
> For each topic I counted how many times it had been mentioned in a post title
I suspect that's the problem. A lot of trendy discussion happens in comments; I think that's going to be particularly true for a topic like remote work.
People are going to extol its virtues when it's tangentially related to a submission, but especially pre-pandemic there's only so many stories you could submit about it? 'Company goes full-remote'? 'How we handle remote working at Company'?
It'd be interesting to search comments too I think. hn.algolia.com supports it.
- sam0x17 5y agoAgreed. This analysis would be more useful if it was done against comments.
- drpancake 5y agoAuthor here. I agree with you but the only recent HN data dump that I could find contained posts and not comments. I suspect the trend lines would look similar though.
- dredmorbius 5y agoBoth the selection (survivorship bias) and weighting (mentions rather than votes/discussion) are problematic. Discussion itself can be a very poor metric, as when there's a great deal of general agreement there's frequently little (or at least less) as when compared with highly contentious topics. Research methodology can often be restricted by data availability. Finding novel ways to torture^W explore data can be insightful, though raises its own risks (p-hacking, as an example).