4 ms·
Timeshares have most of the downsides associated with home ownership combined with the downsides of renting. However, it’s a bad deal mostly because the margin
by Retric 5y ago
Timeshares have most of the downsides associated with home ownership combined with the downsides of renting. However, it’s a bad deal mostly because the margins need to be high to sell them. Splitting a lake house or cabin in the woods among 2 to 4 families can be far more affordable than a second home without the overhead associated with owning and managing a rental. Few people actually want to use a second home every weekend, but renting something 10-20 weekends a year adds up.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ghaff 5y agoThough splitting ownership has its own set of problems. Someone I know had split ownership with an extended family of a couple old properties on the Rhode Island coast. One of the properties was bought out by one of the owners a couple of years back. The other property is being sold. One of the issues is that it had just gotten too hard to coordinate everyone for the short summer season and generally handle upkeep. Joint ownership for much more than a very simple place invariably gets into at least some level of disagreement over things like maintenance and upgrades especially if not everyone is in the same place financially.
- JAlexoid 5y agoYes, that's why an LLC and a contract associated with it is a much better form of ownership. NIMBYs subverting these contracts makes things much worse.
- ghaff 5y agoLLCs and contracts don't solve the complexity of coordinating a large group of people especially as in this case when the season for using the house as a group family vacation place was really less than three months.
- JAlexoid 5y agoContracts that set out the rules - work best. If you buy a share in a property with the understanding that you have first-come-first-serve booking of timeslots - all other arrangements are based on good will alone. That beats arguing in an extended family without set out rules.
- ricardobeat 5y ago> without the overhead associated with owning and managing a rental Pacaso charges monthly fees for upkeep. What’s the difference?
- Retric 5y agoPacaso is a rather traditional timeshare, but not what I am talking about. Let’s call it joint ownership without a 3rd party. They likely pay 3rd party’s do upkeep, but at whatever standards the group decides not an independent management company. This can also include improvements like wheelchair ramps, boat docks etc or even removal of things like TV service etc. Again it’s exactly what the group decides without excess or profit.
- ricardobeat 5y agoI may have gotten this wrong, but Pacaso looks like joint ownership (of an LLC), not a traditional timeshare. I don’t really see the difference from what you’re describing here, other than not hand picking the cleaning company - which most people probably consider a benefit.
- Retric 5y agoFirst their increasing the purchase price by 12% right off the bad that money is simply lost to you and your friends. On top of this they also charge a monthly fee. Second, if you and your friends are sharing a cabin in the woods, why would you need a cleaning company? Sure, if nobody used it for 6 months you might schedule something ahead of time, but it’s not like you trash your house evey day your there.
- ricardobeat 5y agoI’m going by what I’ve read here, not having owned a timeshare myself. The main issues seem to be, in fact, cleaning and maintenance, plus the hurdle of organizing everything. This stuff is very straining on relationships. Someone has to do the purchase paperwork, deal with permits, hire cleaners, builders, inspectors, check their work, schedule, payments, and so on. Sounds like a ton of annoying work, and they are targeting a millionaires market already - I bet a lot of people with 600k to spare think it’s worth the 12%.