12 ms·
> This guy didn't even have an addiction problem, I'm almost certain the judge is getting some sort of incentive to punish these people with this program. Mayb
by lelanthran 5y ago
> This guy didn't even have an addiction problem, I'm almost certain the judge is getting some sort of incentive to punish these people with this program.
Maybe. After reading the entire article, I think that it's a little more complex. The convict gets the option of jail or chicken farm.
After choosing the chicken farm, the convict still has the option of doing the jail time instead. The reason they work so hard, endure the horrific conditions and do so without pay is because they still feel that it is better than jail.
The problem arises when Judges (who, like you said, may have an incentive to provide slaves) start weighting the jail option heavier in order to promote the chicken farm option; for example, offer 5 years in jail or two years in slavery.
Another problem with biased Judges is that they may start convicting based on the labour requirements, not on the criminal intent, element and other factors.
Anyone here who also read The Talisman (Stephen King, Peter Straub)? Similar thing there.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> The reason they work so hard, endure the horrific conditions and do so without pay is because they still feel that it is better than jail. There may be sunk cost issue involved here as well: as I understand the article, whether you drop out of the "rehab" program in the first month or last month of your planned stay, you're going to prison for the full time. So the longer you stay in the program, the stronger your incentive to stay until the end.
- lelanthran 5y agoThat's why I said it is complex.
- ethbr0 5y agoFurthermore, not to discount that the program is literally feeding and preaching to these people. So, aside from the power disparity (send them back to jail on a whim), there's an omnipresent opportunity to propagandize whatever you want. And I'm pretty sure CAAIR isn't spending a lot of time talking to people about how chicken processing is hard, backbreaking, unsafe work, and prison is a viable option.
- tyingq 5y ago>The convict gets the option of jail or chicken farm I'm not convinced that's always true. There's many different courts from different states sending people there. At the very least, there are probably threats of much longer prison times. Like "1 year at the chicken farm" or "3-5 years in prison" perhaps. Or "1 year at the chicken farm that's eligible to be expunged from your record" vs "1 year in prison that will always be hanging over you in the form of background checks". Prosecutors and judges are quite good at making optional things not really optional and have all sorts of levers they can pull (credit for back time, waiving court costs, dropping X of Y charges, "enhancements" of charges, pre-sentencing conditions, deferred adjudication, and so on).
- kwhitefoot 5y agoProviding jail as the alternative fits the definition of forced labour under the 1930 UN Convention on Forced Labour "UN Convention No. 29 concerning forced or compulsory labour defines ‘forced or compulsory labour’ as ‘all work or service which is exacted from any person under the menace of any penalty and for which the said person has not offered himself voluntarily’. " See https://www.un.org/ruleoflaw/files/ILO_Convention_29.pdf https://www.un.org/ruleoflaw/files/ILO_Convention_29.pdf
- lelanthran 5y agoThat doesn't say what you think it says. There is no menace of penalty; the person in question is already sentenced to imprisonment for their crime. The option to escape imprisonment via "rehab" or "labour" is done voluntarily while they are under the sentence handed to them. IOW, the convict is offered an option to not serve their imprisonment. They're free to reject it and continue to serve out their imprisonment. This is not forced labour, as their is no penalty imposed on them for refusing the offer.
- goldenkey 5y agoThe jail time is almost always higher than it would have been under normal circumstances in order to make the choice "forced" without actually being forced. It's an age old trick of plea deals and prosecution perversion.
- watwut 5y ago> After choosing the chicken farm, the convict still has the option of doing the jail time instead. Per article, majority "chooses" jail. Also, lets not pretend people are making some kind of free will choice here. The legal system heavily influences which decision it sees "right" and which is going to be punished.