4 ms·
I wasn't expecting to like this article based on the headline, but firmly agree with the conclusions they present. I was worried it would follow the same traje
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I wasn't expecting to like this article based on the headline, but firmly agree with the conclusions they present.
I was worried it would follow the same trajectory as the "Big corporations told us they would recycle our plastic, then they didn't" argument which bizarrely never ends with "so let's force them to do so" and more often seems to encourage burying plastics in landfills, which is exactly the thing the companies wanted. Since they sell the input for the new plastic production.
I would add that I think one angle they use is to connect fossil fuel emissions to things you like, presenting the false choice of "thing you like" vs "cutting carbon" when in fact most things could have significantly less carbon if we wanted them to. But obviously fossil fuel suppliers don't really want that as the easiest wins in almost all cases are to simply not burn fossil fuels.
There's so much low hanging fruit that we are missing out on at the moment that if someone is talking about making sacrifices, they're probably scamming you.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago> There's so much low hanging fruit that we are missing out on at the moment that if someone is talking about making sacrifices, they're probably scamming you. That sounds like a very convenient way for us to keep complaining about the problem without ever having to do anything about it. Civilization as we know it is built on this stuff, meaning if we want any significant change in the short term we're going to have to make sacrifices. If you're unwilling to let go of out of season food shipped from half way around the world or disposable plastic trash bags or whatever, will you ever vote for someone who might ban those things? If you're unwilling to pay extra for items manufactured using green techniques, will you vote for the person who pushes regulation toward that end? Frankly, statements like that are why I'm incredibly pessimistic about ever turning our environmental abuses around.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI'll vote for the regulations because I know it's so not a big deal that it's actually a net positive. You on the other hand seem to have a "no pain, no gain" attitude to this, that we all have to suffer to sort this out. Who told you that? How does banning out of season fruit help? Who would vote for that?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago> You on the other hand seem to have a "no pain, no gain" attitude to this If solving climate change were pain-free we'd have done it already. I find it very concerning that there are so many people like you who seem to think it isn't worth doing anything that inconveniences them.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoOr, there was a massive, orchestrated PR campaign of lies that held us back. And one of their repeated motifs was that without fossil fuels we'd be living in the dark ages. And you bought into it for some reason.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y ago...because it's true? Only recently have we been able to wean ourselves off of them for some use-cases. If fossil fuels disappear tomorrow, so does timely international shipping, timely intranational shipping, air travel, a lot of the grid power we take for granted, and probably a thousand other things I'm not even thinking of right now. How the hell is civilization not dependant on fossil fuels in your mind?
- ACAVJW4H 5y agoIs properly burying waste plastic underground and ensuring it doesn’t pollute water streams or break down into micro plastic a good way of long term carbon storage? Liquifying or turning it into syngas seems counter intuitive as we’re releasing a long chain carbon store back into atmospheric co2
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoNo, the evidence is very clear that recycling plastic into more plastic is the best option for minimizing carbon and energy use. There's no benefit to storing carbon if you immediately turn round and extract fossil fuels to replace the carbon you just buried. Even when we start making plastic at large scales from captured carbon, it's still not a good idea to bury that if you then need to go and make more of it. Landfills are just generally not the best option and you'll probably find support for them traces back directly to fossil fuel interests since they very neatly line up with their incentive structure compared with the alternatives.
- kbelder 5y ago>Even when we start making plastic at large scales from captured carbon, it's still not a good idea to bury that if you then need to go and make more of it. I think that's exactly wrong, if it's really made from captured carbon. At that point, it would make sense to make plastic with the sole intent of burying it.
- xhkkffbf 5y agoHah! I've wondered the same thing. What if recycling was the problem? And it's not just plastics. Imagine all of the newsprint that was put into landfills before the Internet and recycling came along. That's quite a few tons of carbon!