3 ms·
Just to follow up your note on the E-commerce Directive, is that the same point of European law that England accidentally/conveniently forgot to enact in its lo
by Silhouette 15y ago
Just to follow up your note on the E-commerce Directive, is that the same point of European law that England accidentally/conveniently forgot to enact in its local interpretation?
I've heard what I suspect is the same issue raised before, in the context of End User Licence Agreements. The question of how EULAs can have any legal standing if you don't buy the software directly from the copyright holder was raised: if a contract necessarily involves consideration in both directions, and you get nothing of value from the copyright holder in return for "agreeing" to their often onerous EULA after you've completed the purchase of your software from a third party, what right do they have to impose any conditions on you at all? The answer being debated was that by merely running the software in the normal manner for which it was purchased, you are inevitably making copies (in RAM etc.) and thus copyright law applies and you require a licence. Ah, but making transient copies in the course of normal use is excluded from copyright by the point of law we're discussing, right? Except that unless something changes since I last read about this, that point of law hasn't actually been legislated in England, and thus this shady argument for EULAs having some sort of legal weight isn't completely DoA.
Apologies for not citing the source of this argument. It was a rather interesting and well written paper, by a law student IIRC, but I regret that I didn't bookmark it at the time and have never been able to find it again since.