6 ms·
James Loewen, Author of ‘Lies My Teacher Told Me,’ Dies at 79
- readonthegoapp 5y agoThis guy was _the shit_. I read Lies My Teacher Told Me many moons ago, and it was great because it was so eye-opening, an easy read, and the guy the just seemed like a real one. He was in the early battles against the white supremacist texas education officials.
- dredmorbius 5y agoMy experience was similar. There were definitely aspects of the history which were somewhat familiar to me. The details, however, really fleshed it out. What was entertaining / illuminating was asking my more-aware American friends questions based on the book, and seeing what they were, or were not, aware of. Helen Keller's an interesting example to use, because she's taught virtually universally in primary school as a hero of the disability-rights movement: she overcame deafness and blindess to become an author and speaker, schools and childrens' books teach ... ... but not what she spoke and wrote about. Which tends not to fit into the public-school curriculum as well. (Though perhaps its one of those submarine lessons, a seed planted to emerge later.) I've had a lot of fun asking questions about that, watching peoople look up the story, and minds open. (Usually.) Loewen was an absolute hero. His passing is sad, his gifts are greatly appreciated.
- taeric 5y agoThis sparks some interest in me, as I don't see what is surprising about the things she spoke about. Why/how are folks surprised? They expected more racism?
- jchallis 5y agoI grew up in the twilight of the Cold War and there was definitely a lot of side eye thrown at socialists, labor agitators and pacifists of all kinds. I did have one teacher who proudly shared Helen Keller’s letter to the students who burned her books in Nazi Germany. —— To the student body of Germany: History has taught you nothing if you think you can kill ideas. Tyrants have tried to do that often before, and the ideas have risen up in their might and destroyed them. You can burn my books and the books of the best minds in Europe, but the ideas in them have seeped through a million channels and will continue to quicken other minds. I gave all the royalties of my books for all time to the German soldiers blinded in the World War with no thought in my heart but love and compassion for the German people. I acknowledge the grievous complications that have led to your intolerance; all the more do I deplore the injustice and unwisdom of passing on to unborn generations the stigma of your deeds. Do not imagine that your barbarities to the Jews are unknown here. God sleepeth not, and He will visit His judgment upon you. Better were it for you to have a mill-stone hung around your neck and sink into the sea than to be hated and despised of all men. https://www.openculture.com/2017/05/helen-keller-writes-a-letter-to-nazi-students-before-they-burn-her-book-history-has-taught-you-nothing-if-you-think-you-can-kill-ideas-1933.html https://www.openculture.com/2017/05/helen-keller-writes-a-le...
- dredmorbius 5y agoThis, yes. As a broader concept, this is also an excellent lesson in recognising a missing message. If something is talked about and praised, but always left confusingly vague ... either the speaker is hiding something, or they're aware that they cannot directly mention the subject or events. Either way, it's an invitation to do some digging. Sometimes you find a Helen Keller. Sometimes you find a Samuel F. B. Morse.
- Clewza313 5y agoFor other HN readers who weren't aware (I wasn't), Morse was rabidly anti-Catholic and pro-slavery.
- dredmorbius 5y agoQuiet, yes. Foreign conspiracy against the liberties of the United States https://archive.org/details/foreignconspiracy00mors https://archive.org/details/foreignconspiracy00mors
- dredmorbius 5y agoErm, Quite.
- watwut 5y agoShe was a communist. That is why her ideology is not written about and why people are surprised. They want to teach nice parts of her and dont want to teach off-putting ideas of her. That is the whole point of that chapter in his book.
- taeric 5y agoI guess this one surprises me in how unsurprising that seems to be. (Note, I think she was more socialist than communist, right?) Her life seems a clear case of outstanding achievement that was only possible with outstanding support.
- coliveira 5y agoSimilar to MLK. Most people seem to ignore that he wrote several books, and most of his books are about overcoming the white oppression and promoting socialism. It is hard to see these books even in bookstores.
- dylan604 5y ago>He was in the early battles against the white supremacist texas education officials. I find this interesting as I received my education from a texas public school system. It was not a horrible school as it offered AP courses and even started a CompSci class type class my senior year. I focused my energy in math/sciences, and coasted in history/literature. However, as an adult, I'm realizing that the history that was taught definitely left a lot of details out. One thing that I realized was how European focused the history of WWII was, and the Pacific conflict was all focused on the "big ones". A little on Midway, but clearly it was focused on US involvement. There was nothing on what Japan was doing in China, and very little on what Stalin was doing in Russia. It wasn't until I got to my first few history courses in college that I realized how much of the Civil War was not taught. Go figure from a Texas view point I guess. I had the same professor for the 2 classes I took because I liked how he taught the first class, but then heard from other older students that he was pretty famous for knowing there were blank spots in the average public school curriculums.
- jchallis 5y agoI remember bringing up the racist parts of Gone with the Wind with my parents and having an extremely illuminating conversation on their thoughts and attitudes.
- challengly 5y agoThat reminds me of when I told my 10yo daughter about RGB's passing. She had tears in her eyes. And then she did the Wakanda pose and said “Ruthkanda forever”.
- labster 5y agoI remember when my fourth grade teacher, newly moved in from Georgia, decided to put on a class play of Gone with the Wind. I’m so grateful I annoyed her enough to earn a suspension from school for the remainder of the year, because it was long enough to miss the play. That class was just a lost cause.
- watwut 5y agoWhat did happened during that class? What you said?
- a3n 5y ago> That class was just a lost cause. Nice use of social recursion. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Cause_of_the_Confederacy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lost_Cause_of_the_Confederac...
- labster 5y agoThanks for explaining the joke /s, but the explanation will probably be valuable to people. All that really happened — it’s not just a joke. The incident which caused me to be suspended involved getting chased around backstage by a friend with a fire extinguisher. Which, ironically, is one thing that would have helped Atlanta.
- RubberSoul 5y agoMy high school history teacher recommended his book to me when I was junior. I loved it, and even wrote to the author regarding a mistake I thought I found in the book (pretty arrogant of me). Loewen replied generously. I don't remember the exact exchange, but he was so encouraging. It meant a lot to me in high school that he replied.
- touisteur 5y agoKudos to your teacher, for recommending you the book (personally because of your unmanageable curiosity :-) or generally to the class ?). I wish my teachers had tried drowning teenage me with good, challenging books. Kudos getting the courage to write to an author you admired. Putting your words on paper, letting someone that wrote know that they reached you. That your motives might not gave been noble (arrogant is a good phase to live as a teenager, we need to learn that we are a crafty, amazing bunch, we humans, to celebrate it, and we need to be taught hubris concretely, its positive and negative sides, etc.). Kudos for him to write you back, with encouraging words. He probably got a good chuckle or two, and took the time, in a way, to show you you'd touched him. Wholesome human story, thanks for sharing.
- gumby 5y agoMy kid, in his first year in a US school, apparently asked the history teacher in class, "Wait, didn't XXX happen in the fashion YYY?"* and was told it wasn't taught that way. I asked her about this in the parent meeting and she said indeed, what he had learned was correct but she needed to teach things in the approved way so that the students would pass the standardized tests. This isn't meant to imply the US is in some way particularly evil about this -- all countries have some sort of origin myths. This is more a comment on the effect of state level standardized testing. * actual issue wasn't race-related so I elided it.
- frozenport 5y agoMet him over a decade ago while I was doing undergrad. Dude wanted to go hang out with 18 year old anarchists. I liked his optimism about the brotherhood of man, but he voiced a few non-scientific opinions about GMOs that rubbed me the wrong way.
- mathattack 5y agoCan you share more? Sounds like a healthy skepticism to authority.
- labster 5y agoHistory professor not expert in biology! Film at eleven.
- loco5niner 5y agoOr rather: "Author with contentious views tends to have unreliable thinking patterns"
- watwut 5y agoThe Book contains stuff the historians are consistent about. None of it is some obscure or controversial among historians.
- loco5niner 5y agoSure, you can claim that. And the GP can claim that the author tends to have unreliable thinking patterns. From the authors own viewpoint, he would want us to investigate that for ourselves.
- watwut 5y ago> From the authors own viewpoint, he would want us to investigate that for ourselves. That is not what his book said. It said nothing about having kids or anyone investigate independently. The book listed multiple ways in which textbooks mislead, leave important parts of story put or even directly lie. The book claims these have consequences (to large extend in making history boring and unreal).
- pwdisswordfish8 5y agoNon-cookiewalled: https://text.npr.org/1030442282 https://text.npr.org/1030442282
- newdude116 5y agoLooks interesting but mainly about history. BTW, One lie the Americans are told in High Scholl is that the US won the 2nd World war https://youtu.be/DwKPFT-RioU?t=245 https://youtu.be/DwKPFT-RioU?t=245 (one icon represents 1000 people)
- mbrodersen 5y agoIt’s part of the myth Americans teach each other. All countries have their myths and the myths are always constructed to make people feel good about themselves or to make people feel good about how much better they are today. America functioned mostly as an arms dealer during the 2nd world war, getting rich in gold selling weapons to Europe, financing a huge boom in manufacturing that made the US #1 in the world for many years following the 2nd WW. It is absolutely true that the US played a major role in the allied winning the war. But not the way it is told in movies/stories. The majority of Americans, for many years, wanted to do nothing helping Europeans. While millions of Europeans were fighting the Nazis, giving their lives to defend their homes.
- throw0101a 5y ago> is that the US won the 2nd World war Without US manufacturing capacity things would have gone differently. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lend-Lease https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lend-Lease Khrushchev: > "If the United States had not helped us, we would not have won the war," he wrote in his memoirs.[1] "One-on-one against Hitler's Germany, we would not have withstood its onslaught and would have lost the war. No one talks about this officially, and Stalin never, I think, left any written traces of his opinion, but I can say that he expressed this view several times in conversations with me." * [1] http://militera.lib.ru/memo/russian/khruschev1/28.html http://militera.lib.ru/memo/russian/khruschev1/28.html * https://www.rferl.org/a/did-us-lend-lease-aid-tip-the-balance-in-soviet-fight-against-nazi-germany/30599486.html https://www.rferl.org/a/did-us-lend-lease-aid-tip-the-balanc... Apparently something like one-third of the tanks during the Battle of Moscow were British: * https://doi.org/10.1080/13518040903355794 https://doi.org/10.1080/13518040903355794
- mbrodersen 5y ago
- nullc 5y agoIt's a great book, I think Bob Young recommended it to me at Linux expo in 1995 or 1996? Amusingly, that book recommendation is one of the only things I remember from the conference and it's totally linux-unrelated. :) I would have found history in school much more interesting if it reflected the content of that book.
- specialist 5y agoRIP. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_W._Loewen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_W._Loewen Loewen also wrote about "sunset towns", another vile strategy for enforcing racial segregation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sundown_town https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sundown_town I grew up in a very white, very affluent area. I was gobsmacked when I learned about sunset laws, that most of the prime real estate had been seized during the internment of Japanese, etc, etc. Topics definitely not taught in school, nor discussed in the press. FWIW, my introduction to a lot of these topics and themes was David Neiwert's Orcinus blog in the aughts. https://dneiwert.blogspot.com https://dneiwert.blogspot.com
- gumby 5y agoThere weren't merely sunset towns -- Oregon wrote the sunset clause into it's state constitution!
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoIs it still there?
- gumby 5y agoNo