2 ms·
> Whilst killing all life within 1km of any Taliban is ridiculous and absurd, the thought of a true extermination strategy of the Taliban should be on the table
by watwut 5y ago
> Whilst killing all life within 1km of any Taliban is ridiculous and absurd, the thought of a true extermination strategy of the Taliban should be on the table. At the very least as a thought.
It is neither ridiculous nor absurd.
It plain simply involves killing almost everyone in an area. Which is called genocide. It is doable. Nazi done it. Khmer Rouge done it. Hutu in Rwanda done it.
You want to frame it as attacking Taliban, which is not true. Majority of victims would not be Taliban. It would be quite literally going to Afghan to commit genocide in half of it.
> The grand "prize" of all this suffering is the country firmly back in the hands of the Taliban, under Sharia law.
Anyone including women have better chance under Sharia law then they have under your proposal. Cause your proposal is to plain kill them. You don't get to propose killing people and then saying someone else is cruel.
> Altogether, I don't believe it is unreasonable to wonder if the "good intentions" approach's outcome isn't just as terrible or worse compared to an actual extermination approach
Under Taliban, those people are alive. With your approach, they are all dead. So, they are better off now. I don't think few terrorism victims in USA is good enough excuse for that.
> One could at least contemplate what would have happened if the US had directly engaged with the Taliban, and use its full military, diplomatic, intelligence and monetary might to do so.
They did and lost.
- fleddr 5y agoDid people all of a sudden lose the ability to read, or what? "It plain simply involves killing almost everyone in an area." No, not almost everyone. Only Taliban. Which arguably is complex, but surely if the US would make full effort to infiltrate and map the network, such selective targeting would be possible. "Cause your proposal is to plain kill them. You don't get to propose killing people and then saying someone else is cruel." It gets even weirder, I guess. You know the very point of the Afghan military was to kill the Taliban, right? Together with the US backing them up, they managed to kill 52,000 Taliban and other opposition fighters. What exactly do you think happens in a war? "Under Taliban, those people are alive. With your approach, they are all dead." All? The Taliban is estimated to have a force some 50,000 strong, 100,000 tops if you include weak allies. That's 0.13% of the total population. So you're saying that the selective targeting of the Taliban, will also wipe out the other 99.87% of the population? Some 38 million people? Get the fuck out of here.
- watwut 5y agoKilling all life within 1km of any Taliban literally involves killing all people there. And it is not even Taliban hiding among civilians. It is them living with their parents in their village. > Together with the US backing them up, they managed to kill 52,000 Taliban and other opposition fighters. What exactly do you think happens in a war? Not every war is going on with goal of killing everyone in an area. So while civilians always die, what you propose has that extra step of being genocide. > The Taliban is estimated to have a force some 50,000 strong, 100,000 tops if you include weak allies. That's 0.13% of the total population. Yes, because your plan is to not just kill them, but to kill everyone around.
- fleddr 5y agoAre you drunk? I did not make the "killing all life" remark, it's by another commenter. I specifically said to target an exterminate the Taliban. "Not every war is going on with goal of killing everyone in an area. So while civilians always die, what you propose has that extra step of being genocide." No that is the exact opposite of what I propose! "Yes, because your plan is to not just kill them, but to kill everyone around." What!?
- sadfkhjasdf 5y agoA better solution would be to use small drone swarms and create a surveillance state in the rural areas. Each drone can see about 100m2 at 100m height. So 10K drones for 1 km2 = 10 million dollars. Attach weapons and you have zero risk of life and can maintain a permanent presence, that can essentially be automated by AI and computer vision. And I've only spent 0.01% of the yearly spend on the war. This is clearly the future of warfare.