3 ms·
The hospitals and doctors offices are run privately in Canada. Health insurance is what is run publicly. But you can still pay out of pocket if you wanted to fo
by dmix 5y ago
The hospitals and doctors offices are run privately in Canada. Health insurance is what is run publicly. But you can still pay out of pocket if you wanted to for a family doctor.
The Tweet suggests its a purely private vs public debate which misrepresents the positions being taken. This debate is about extending the current system to be a total government monopoly on paying for a family doctor vs just having nationalized insurance as it already is. Two degrees of public.
I'm not even sure the Liberals are trying to make this a policy position anyway. Most likely it's about spinning the oppositions character.
In reality it's a minor problem. If you prevent a tiny subset of doctors from accepting voluntary payments they can just move to the US, like plenty of them already do every year. The argument that people are currently being deprived of something is pretty weak which is why hardly anyone cares.
- chrisfosterelli 5y ago> Health insurance is what is run publicly at a provincial level. But you can still pay out of pocket if you wanted to for a family doctor. I don't think this is true. For e.g. in BC, clinics cannot sell medical procedures to a BC resident if the procedure could be covered by MSP. Several other provinces have similar laws. I agree with your phrasing of _what_ is up for debate, but the _current_ state is essentially a total gov monopoly on paying for health care rather than vice versa.
- dmix 5y agoYeah true, it's really only about family doctors. Medical procedures, specialists, and hospital bills are a different matter entirely. If you think your current family doctor is not diagnosing you properly you can already go get multiple opinions for free. And with more and more family doctors being accessible by phone and video chat (covered by the province) the benefits of a private doctor are pretty limited.