6 ms·
How is "the science here is still uncertain" an argument against masks in schools? If it turns out they are useful, wearing them will have been a good idea. I
by simonw 5y ago
How is "the science here is still uncertain" an argument against masks in schools?
If it turns out they are useful, wearing them will have been a good idea.
If it turns out that they weren't useful, what harm has been caused?
(I'm aware that there are people out there who think wearing masks for a year or two will scar children for life, but for the most part I don't think those people are arguing in good faith. The biggest harm I see is to children with hearing problems who are prevented from lip reading.)
- op00to 5y agoMuh freedoms is why there are still people fighting masks.
- spookthesunset 5y agoGood question. Who are they now protecting? People who refuse to get a vaccine?
- h3cate 5y agoExactly this. This is why the vaccines have been rolled out. If somebody doesn't want to wear a mask now they shouldn't have to if the vaccine has been offered to everyone in their country.
- op00to 5y agoI have a neighbor that has only one lung due to a genetic defect. She is at much greater risk of dying even after vaccination. Your fee-fees are not more important than her life.
- mgalgs 5y agoWith one lung she's at a much greater risk of dying of anything... Let's not pretend that she was never at risk of dying before covid-19...
- Godel_unicode 5y agoOne possible harm I've seen postulated is moral licensing, i.e. wearing a mask makes people feel safer and thus makes them more willing to be indoors in close proximity for longer. A counter-argument says that wearing a physical thing can act as a constant reminder of covid, causing people to act more responsibly. Back on the harms side again, there's a possibility that teaching kids "just do this and don't ask questions" can have negative consequences. Again, the counter argument of letting them ask questions and carefully explaining what we do and don't know can be a positive.
- simonw 5y agoI wonder if there has been research that attempts to answer the question of whether masks encourage less safe or more safe behaviour - it feels to me like something that would respond well to a well designed study.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoAnecdotally speaking, in my corner of England social distancing went out of the window shortly after masks were mandated in shops.
- nerdponx 5y agoIn addition, several of the "masks don't work" studies I saw had to do with people touching or messing with their masks undoing any benefits of actually wearing a mask.
- ummwhat 5y ago>Back on the harms side again, there's a possibility that teaching kids "just do this and don't ask questions" can have negative consequences. Don't worry. The schools teach that with or without masks.
- chlodwig 5y agoIf it turns out that they weren't useful, what harm has been caused? Socializing in masks is massively inferior. It sucks talking to other people and not being able to read facial expressions or to see smiles. Right now American health officials are asking children to an spend the majority of their waking hours for an entire year of their lives (or more??) around friends and teachers without that essential human experience of seeing smiles. That is harm in an of itself. Even if the kids bounce back, and you can't find a developmental difference in any statistic, that year of their life, a year they will never get back, will still have been a year of being deprived of essential human connection.
- pyronik19 5y agoBecause I don't want to is a perfectly acceptable reason to say no. "Muh Freedoms" is all the argument you need.
- Trill-I-Am 5y agoI've worn a mask for probably over 1500 hours in a restaurant that never closed and I and my coworkers have gotten along just fine. I just don't understand why so many people are resisting them so and acting so put upon.
- chlodwig 5y agoDo you plan on wearing a mask for the next year while socializing with your friends? If yes, do you see this as a big burden or a small burden?
- pengaru 5y ago> If it turns out that they weren't useful, what harm has been caused? If masks are ineffective, wearing them amounts to theatrics/fiction. If that fiction creates a false sense of safety, it can encourage people to take risks like interacting in closer proximity than they would otherwise. I have no knowledge or expertise on if masks are effective nor have any children, this is just an observation of what seems like an obvious potential harm.
- danenania 5y agoIt seems obvious that wearing masks all day would hinder social and verbal development in toddlers and small children, at least to some extent. I think everyone can agree that they wouldn't help in these areas? You might think the public health benefits outweigh this concern, but it's disingenuous imo to just assert that there are no conceivable negative effects for a two year old having their first social experiences.
- simonw 5y agoThis is a good answer. I've not been thinking in terms of two year olds - I've been assuming this debate is mostly about children who are elementary school and above.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BoxOfRain 5y agoNot to mention the effects on children who struggle with their hearing and need to lip-read, from a disability rights point of view I don't think it's quite as simple as "masking kids is great, end of story".
- spookthesunset 5y agoA year of a kids life is an eternity for them. Two is forever! You are stealing their childhood away from them to protect who, exactly? What is even the point of masking them. Teachers have been vaccinated. Parents have been vaccinated. Kids aren’t at risk. Why this obsession with reducing cases if we took the sting out of covid? Kids need to be children. They aren’t human shields for adults. Adults are expect to sacrifice for kids, not the other way around. Kids deserve their one and only childhood. They don’t deserve to be treated like disease vectors that need to be muzzled to make frightened parents and educators feel safe. Double so when all those adults can get a free, highly effective vaccine. Making them mandatory is even worse. The state has no right to force my kid to wear a mask at school in order to have an education. Parents should be making that call for their own kid.
- simonw 5y ago"Teachers have been vaccinated. Parents have been vaccinated." I really wish that was true! Sadly in the USA the amount of "vaccine hesitancy" remains unbelievably high.
- spookthesunset 5y agoWho cares? If you and your loved ones are vaccinated y’all are good to go. As the article this discussion is about… covid is here forever. Time to accept it and move the hell on.
- simonw 5y agoI care. I'm vaccinated. I can still catch it - I'm much more unlikely to end up in hospital, but it's still an unpleasant illness to have, with a small chance of long-term complications that are not at all well understood. And if I do catch it I can still spread it to others, who may not be vaccinated. I very much care about not killing someone else by spreading Covid to them, even if they deliberately chose not to get the vaccine. I'm furious with them (and with the information sources they consumed that lead them to that decision) but I absolutely don't want to contribute to their suffering or death.
- rayiner 5y agoYou’re absolutely wrong about the last point. The people raising risks to childhood development from masking are serious people making serious arguments: https://healthpolicy.usc.edu/article/mandatory-masking-of-school-children-is-a-bad-idea/ https://healthpolicy.usc.edu/article/mandatory-masking-of-sc... This is as an article by medical professors at USC and Stanford: > At the same time, the long-term harm to kids from masking is potentially enormous. Masking is a psychological stressor for children and disrupts learning. Covering the lower half of the face of both teacher and pupil reduces the ability to communicate. In particular, children lose the experience of mimicking expressions, an essential tool of nonverbal communication. Positive emotions such as laughing and smiling become less recognizable, and negative emotions get amplified. Bonding between teachers and students takes a hit. Overall, it is likely that masking exacerbates the chances that a child will experience anxiety and depression, which are already at pandemic levels themselves. I don’t know if you have young children, but facial expressions are a huge part of communication. My kids are constantly looking at my face to for “is this okay” signals. Kids learn to look at facial expressions of peers to understand what they’re thinking and feeling. There’s just tons and tons of research on this. Masks for kids isn’t like masks for adults, where you can say “well even if they don’t work there’s no harm.” What we don’t have is research showing that wearing masks has persistent negative effects on kids, but based on what we do know that’s a real possible harm that has to be weighed against the possible benefits of masking.
- rcpt 5y ago> My kids are constantly looking at my face to for “is this okay” signals Nobody's expecting you to wear masks at home.
- spookthesunset 5y agoWhats your point, that doesn't invalidate the argument at all.
- rcpt 5y agoYour argument is that kids *might* have trouble developing social cues because facial expressions are hidden behind masks. But, even with masks on at school, your kids have plenty of unmasked time at home. This is one reason why, after 18 months of masking, there is still no data supporting your argument.
- timmytokyo 5y agoThe article discusses a few of the potential harms to young children. At that age, children are learning how to read social cues, and they do that by observing faces. An indefinite mask mandate that lasts for years could have developmental consequences for these children.
- sk2020 5y agoFor the same reasons, I think that lucky rabbit’s feet should be mandatory. Also, horoscopes should be consulted prior to attending schools. If you can think of anything else that didn’t work for this or any other illnesses in history, then I think that you should demand schools make them mandatory, just in case.
- TheGigaChad 5y agoCuckdowncels, get cancer and die...masked.