3 ms·
Returning to this after the digression below: I'm not willing to dismiss all of a source based on incidental errors. I may even be willing to allow some major
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Returning to this after the digression below:
I'm not willing to dismiss all of a source based on incidental errors. I may even be willing to allow some major factual or rational flaws where a piece does point out some salient point, or serves as a foundational resouce of some sort. (You could include virtually all of mythology, fables, philosophy, and/or religion in this description.)
Where a source is clearly making a motivated attempt at deception, or where it shows a clear ambivalence to truth (Frankfurt's definition in "On Bullshit"), and there's nothing in the source that's not otherwise available ... my tolerance drops sharply.
This is where the intentional deception of a tremendous amount of narrative (I hesitate to even call it "information") deserves a death penalty.
The attitude expressed by supermemo.guru seems to fall squarely in this camp.
I address the point of intellectual honesty and journalistic standards, of admitting and publicly noting errors, in this somewhat tedious subthread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28261042 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28261042