4 ms·
"Air can be perfectly still and powered flight works just fine." No it can't. "For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction"; if the plane is expe
by jerf 15y ago
"Air can be perfectly still and powered flight works just fine."
No it can't. "For every action, there is an equal and opposite reaction"; if the plane is experiencing lift a.k.a. an upward force (in the fully Newtonian sense of the term) from the air, the plane must be imparting an equal and opposite force downward on something else, in this case the air, which will cause the air to be accelerated downward. A plane flying through the air does not merely cut through the air, it actually causes a downwards net acceleration. Nothing else is possible. (That's not to say it doesn't do so by some clever work in the details, including on the leading edge of the wing where some air is briefly pushed upwards, but I'm talking about the net force on the air considered as a whole.)
There's an amazing amount of misinformation in this area and a lot of people have managed to talk themselves into positions where somehow forces are distinguished from the masses and accelerations in question, or some other similarly gibberish splitting of unsplittable concepts. ("F = ma" is a mathematical statement saying precisely that there is no difference between a force and an accelerating mass, there's nowhere to wedge the two apart, they are fundamentally, deeply, profoundly the same thing. The school system does an incredibly poor job of teaching what equality truly is and a surprising amount of subsequent failure to teach math stems directly from that simple oversight... but I digress.) A vehicle accelerating upward must be doing so by pushing something else downward, be that rocket exhaust, electromagnetic radiation (theoretically possible but impractical on Earth), or, yes, air. (Or more generally, any vehicle that is accelerating with less that the acceleration dictated by gravity towards Earth, but I think it's easier to see if we postulate an aircraft actually accelerating upwards.)
- Retric 15y agoPeople have trouble understanding the gravity = acceleration bit. However, I find if you walk someone though the idea of ground effects vs high altitude flight they can quickly grasp the downdraft issue. AKA ground effects means the air is acting like a pole and supporting the craft due to an increase in pressure on the bottom of the craft AND and increase in pressure on the ground. High altitude flight means there is no direct increase in pressure below the craft just a downdraft of air under it. Granted that motion eventually bounces off the earth but it can take a while and and the path need not be directly down (ex: crosswind) and it need not be the same width as the airplane, but it does flow from the airplane all the way down to the ground.
- geuis 15y agoSorry, let me tighten up what I said. When I said "air can be perfectly still" I didn't mean to imply no downward force was generated. That was obvious to me so I didn't add that bit. What I mean is that the air that a wing traverses through doesn't have to be moving already, aka wind or air current. The power of the engine pushes the wing through the medium, and the action of this of courses causes downward air movement and thus elevates the wing.
- jbri 15y agoRather than "powered flight", it might be better to talk about "heavier-than-air flight". If you used this concept to create a shell around a neutrally bouyant blimp, then you could (in theory) move it through the air without at all disturbing the prevailing air currents in the area it was moving through. You would generate some turbulence as you were getting up to speed or changing course, but when you're not doing that you wouldn't need to exert any net force on the air.