8 ms·
Chronic fatigue syndrome
- WordSkill 15y agoI was going set up a startup to serve the Chronic Fatigue Syndrome community but, somehow, I never got around to it.
- antidaily 15y agoat least tell a weed joke.
- stanleydrew 15y agoAm I the only one who finds the writing in the economist to be about as deep as a 9th-grader's book report? I mean I basically learned nothing from this article.
- MaxGabriel 15y agoI stopped following current events a year and a half ago, so I stopped reading the Economist. But from what I remember, no they do often have pretty deep articles. But sometimes reporting is just reporting, and I'd rather have the facts reported than a story blown out of proportion.
- jerf 15y agoIt seems likely in this case that this is more a result of none of this being news to you than a problem with the article itself. It wasn't news to me either, but I know people to whom it would be.
- chubot 15y agoNo, I totally don't get the Economist. People always tell me to read it. Smart people. Then I read it, and it's like a 9th grader's book report, as you say. It's a hair better than Time magazine or Newsweek.
- w1ntermute 15y agoWell, it is called The Economist. If you expect to read intelligent analysis of medical conditions, I suggest you look elsewhere. The Economist is good at providing analysis of economical and business matters. I read it for those components and ignore the rest.
- uriel 15y agoTheir coverage of world politics and other topics is also very good. Only the Science and Technology section is appallingly and depressingly bad.
- w1ntermute 15y agoThen again, that may just be a result of us knowing a lot about Science and Technology. I wonder if those who are experts in economics and those other fields The Economist supposedly covers with skill think the same things about it covers their area of expertise.
- uriel 15y agoI wonder the same, but from people I trust and what I do know, it seems that they are better than pretty much anything else being published this days. Their Science and Tech section is clearly not better than alternatives, and in many ways much worse.
- uriel 15y agoTheir Science and Technology section is tabloid-grade garbage. The rest is excellent and way better than what you can find almost anywhere else.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- mebesilly 15y agoThe problem is that some people have a vested interest in seeing CFS as an organic problem. These proponents of CFS are notorious for mounting hate campaigns against mainstream researchers. That is one of the reasons why CFS has been delegated to the shadowlands of fringe medicine.
- cfshacker 15y agoRubbish. The reason CFS hasn't seen more mainstream research is a chicken-and-egg problem of having no specific angle to research, therefore research isn't done, therefore there's no specific angle to research. When the XMRV stuff broke the research community did swing into action. Scientists haven't decided not to study CFS because someone on the internet hurt their feelings. Medicine isn't omniscient. Blaming extremely sick people for the lack of research into their predicament is absurd.
- vsync 15y ago> Medicine isn't omniscient. Blaming extremely sick people for the lack of research into their predicament is absurd. Granted. But medical doctors are people too. And I can tell you from my experience in the completely different field of technology that I'm far more willing to work with clients who are willing to listen, appreciate effort on their behalf, and are grateful for a solution or workaround that helps them even if it wasn't what they were hoping to hear. If a client made death threats to me (I've had some go off the deep end but never that far) I have to say I think that'd be a swift end to the working relationship.
- shiven 15y ago> When the XMRV stuff broke the research community did swing into action. Yes. And did prove conclusively that XMRV is not the cause for CFS. > Scientists haven't decided not to study CFS because someone on the internet hurt their feelings. No. Funding for research is what makes scientists study anything. Direct your anger to raise more funding for CFS research and you will get closer to knowing the patho-physiological cause (whether you like the answer or not means absolutely nothing). >Medicine isn't omniscient. Just like any other human endeavor. > Blaming extremely sick people for the lack of research into their predicament is absurd. The blame is very justified when you start receiving death threats. Talk of biting the hand that feeds. Jeez!
- cfshacker 15y agoPsychological theories for CFS have been around for decades and have yielded very little by way of testable hypotheses or treatment, despite millions of dollars spent on research. Wessley's highly controversial views and work have been subject to much criticism -- absolutely none of which is reflected in this disappointing puff piece. There's plenty of more news-worthy stuff that's been happening in the CFS world (both good and bad) in recent times than years-old revelation that people don't much like Simon Wessley. The core problem is simply that this conclusion isn't true: "But a psychiatric explanation would not delegitimise CFS. And it might improve treatment and help patients get better, at last." Wessley's theories have been studied. They offer very little to very sick people. They don't get better. It does delegitimise the extremely severe nature of the illness. If they did legitimise, and -- far more importantly -- cure sick patients, great! That would be wonderful. But they don't. We know they don't. Shame on the Economist for not saying so. Psycho-social explanations of CFS seem to be nothing more than "hysteria" rebadged for more modern times. It's easier to say "Well, maybe it's your fault!" than to accept the hopelessness of not knowing what's going on. Actually, that's not true, there has been (and is) plenty of work on the physical abnormalities. For those interested in current happenings in the CFS world, it's worth following: http://phoenixrising.me/ http://phoenixrising.me/ .
- vsync 15y agoYour other objections are interesting and I want to research them further. But I wonder how this comment doesn't prove the editorial's point: > It does delegitimise the extremely severe nature of the illness. How does merely positing a psychosomatic origin for the syndrome "delegitimise" its "extreme severity"? Or is it you thinking that mental health is somehow less important than physical health, which doesn't even make sense considering the brain is an organ too? > Psycho-social explanations of CFS seem to be nothing more than "hysteria" rebadged for more modern times. It's easier to say "Well, maybe it's your fault!" than to accept the hopelessness of not knowing what's going on. Uh huh. And it's easier to take the idea of mental health being relevant as a personal insult, like people are saying it's one's own fault, than to accept the hopelessness of not knowing there's a magical cure as soon as the doctors discover the sole physical cause. Again, I really want to read further on research being done on CFS and other subjective and idiopathic syndromes. It's interesting from a medical and social standpoint and I'm close with several people who suffer with such issues. But I've also seen their blind spots related to the issue. I'd like to hear more on the work that's disproven psychiatric origins of the syndrome, since while the editorial touched on Wessley it seemed more to be talking about the need to explore all possible causes and solutions of a problem affecting many.
- ScottBurson 15y agoIn March of last year I was in pretty good shape. I was running 1.8 miles three times a week -- not a lot of miles by hardcore runner standards, but more than most middle-aged men. The previous September I had competed in my first race, and had turned in a very respectable time, about the 64th percentile among the men. And I've always been active, running, cycling, and playing table tennis. It's very important to me. Anyway, in the third week of that March I had a flu-like illness. It wasn't too different from the dozen or two other such illnesses I've had in my life, although it was perhaps among the more severe, lasting a full week. After giving myself a couple of weeks to recover I attempted to resume my previous level of activity. But I was beset by a persistent malaise and severe headaches. After a few weeks it became clear that anytime I exercised, somewhere between 12 and 48 hours later I would have these symptoms. To make a very long story short, I eventually figured out that these were common symptoms of CFS, a condition I had heard of (20 years ago I knew someone who had it) but had known next to nothing about. Further poking around on the Web led me to think that it was probably caused by an Epstein-Barr infection. While I had originally hoped it would get better on its own, eventually it became clear that it was getting worse. I asked my doctor for a prescription for valacyclovir, an antiviral drug, and he agreed. I started taking it at the beginning of (this) March. It has helped quite a bit, though I'm not completely cured -- I've been exercising some, and I still get the symptoms afterwards, but they're not nearly as severe. I'm relating all this to explain why I think it's ludicrous to suggest that this illness is hysterical. I was indeed under a lot of stress at the time I contracted it; I was between jobs, my previous job having ended in a particularly stressful way (it was a startup that ran out of money). If you wanted to say that my stress level was a factor in the etiology of the infection, I'd be the first to agree. But that's very different from saying it's a mental illness. There is a certain institutionalized arrogance in the medical establishment. Some doctors -- not all! -- when faced with a patient whose symptoms they can't explain or treat can't stand to admit that modern medical science still doesn't know everything about the human body. So rather than admitting their ignorance and powerlessness, which would be hard on their egos, they say the disease doesn't exist. Now, which of us has the mental problem? I don't begin to condone death threats. There's no excuse for such behavior. But there's also now plenty of evidence for an organic cause of many cases of CFS. The working hypothesis, as I understand it, is that it's a viral infection of the brain, where the virus is a member of the herpes family, usually either Epstein-Barr or human herpesvirus 6. Hence the use of valacyclovir or valgancyclovir, which were invented to treat herpes infections. BTW, before trying valacyclovir (and indeed before realizing that I had CFS) I did try other medications, which did nothing. I seriously doubt my improvement can be attributed to the placebo effect. So although, again, I don't condone death threats, I also have very little patience with those who, in 2011, are still putting forth what by now is a discredited theory, one that doctors should have been too ashamed to advance in the first place. (Someone is going to point out that some patients have felt somewhat better when given antidepressants. Let me tell you, this is a depressing disease, so I understand how that might happen. I have not heard of anyone being cured solely by antidepressants.)
- Groxx 15y agoI think one of the major problems with "CFS" is that it's an umbrella term. Seriously. If you have persistent fatigue and they can't diagnose you with anything else, you have "chronic fatigue syndrome". It's no wonder research is inconclusive and hard to come by. My brother and I both got CFS at the same time, with similar initial-diagnoses (tested positive for Mono), and we've been fighting off the effects for quite a few years now. For myself, I went from soccer-playing high-energy kid to going between bed and the couch for about a year and a half, in the span of a few days. What changed after a year and a half was that I was getting ever-deeper in a depressive cycle, and managed to recognize it and escape - I realized it was literally a lethal path if I didn't fix something. Very good motivation, that. From then, I basically spent 5 years wasting a little more energy in everything I did, and very very slowly got some stamina back - it took me about 5 years from the start of it all to get to the point where I could go back to school for a couple hours a day. The remaining year and a half got me back to almost regular hours. I still have some problems, but am able to get around most of them now because I have very acutely learned the difference between being fatigued and literal physical exhaustion. And I've become extremely patient / stubborn in my progress - a few years to make a small improvement isn't all that long any more. I still waste energy left and right, but it's no longer a necessity. I am a rare exception, and I count myself lucky, not strong-willed. Getting to where I am now hasn't been entirely my doing - it has faded on its own to a fair degree. --- So, throughout all this, I've kept watching the research a bit, and one thing sticks out like a sore thumb - the umbrella term. Studies have a hard time finding individuals, and a hard time finding ones with possibly-similar causes, because it manifests so many different ways (my brother had and has severe migraines, I've had digestive and muscle pains). And if it doesn't help everyone, it's not a cure. It's disorganized and counter-productive, and the same thing happens to almost every umbrella term in every field. And due to all of this, we've had tons of blood tests, left several doctors who take the stance that it doesn't exist, and found a surprising amount of people with similar experiences. Doctors who can't accept things they didn't learn in school disgust me - I'm very glad we've found a couple that don't. They've been wonderful. For my brother and I, I can say this: we don't know how to manifest positive tests for Mono using our minds. The rest of it is possible, but I find it unlikely, and neither of us were under odd stresses prior - both good at school, had friends, no real family troubles, etc. No doubt some of it is psychosomatic, but it varies by person, and there are definitely other factors in play in many cases. I very highly doubt many (most?) CFS cases are entirely psychosomatic. I have no problem with it being psychosomatic (really, it wouldn't bother me - it'd mean less wasted on tests and more on attempts), I just doubt it's the main cause.
- konstruktor 15y agoThe problem is not this researcher doing his research. The scientific process can deal with several opinions on a topic, since the better theory will eventually yield better results, more publications and more acceptance in the global scientific community. Everything should be fine. But he's not just a part of the global scientific community, but also a researcher at a prestigeous university in the UK, where the poltical climate of the last few years has happily called everything off mainstream antisocial. The UK is a country where there was a serious discussion about not calling obese people obese anymore, because it is not insulting enough, but that one should call them fat. In such an environment, a theory among many, stating that CFS is caused by mental illness, can easily be spun into CFS sufferers just being lazy folks who don't want to work, because science says so. (Ignoring that mental illnes, like a physical illness, is actual illness and not a bad character trait) This is a problem with the UK, not with this researcher.
- ZoFreX 15y agoI've had CFS and I still find many of the "sufferers" completely insufferable. I don't know if this is a UK phenomenon, a western phenomenon, or just a thing that people do, but the majority of people who choose to disclose to me that they have a mental illness are self-diagnosed. CFS is one of those things (like ADHD and Asperger's) that is very appealing to people who have certain problems. I don't think this disease will be taken seriously until we actually have diagnostic criteria, proper names, proper understanding... Overall, acceptance of mental issues as real problems is definitely growing in this country.
- flocial 15y agoWhy can't something be medical AND psychological? Stress, bad diet, lack of social interaction, etc. Our bodies and minds are legacy material thanks to the technology we created. What I don't like about the medical profession is how they jump to definitive conclusions to many things and fail to question so-called established wisdom. Symptoms are as real as the patient feels it. It's not over until they feel cured. Anybody who's struggled with something outside their power knows that strength of will can work miracles but only get you so far.
- cfshacker 15y agoWell, you wouldn't say someone with AIDS had problems with "Stress, bad diet, lack of social interaction", for example. Yet Dr. Nancy Klimas got interested in CFS patients when she found they were sicker than her AIDS patients. (Of course, outcomes for AIDS patients are far worse!)
- savemylife 15y agoThis is my current diagnosis, for those who might have been following my story from over a year ago (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1399450 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1399450). I've been wanting to publish an update to this story on HN, but I'd been hoping for better news first. My last doctor (a very good, well-known Rheumatologist in my area) spent a long time working with me. After months of trying everything he knew, he put it to me like this: * You have Chronic Fatigue Syndrome. Name sucks, but that's what it's called right now. * What you have is real, it's not "in your head". * A typical outcome is that you will start to feel better when you turn 50 or 60. In other words, my best outcome is to hang on for another ten to twenty years and hope that I feel better then. I've been dealing with this since college, but this is the year that I finally had to admit I was failing, and had to quit my job.
- ScottBurson 15y agoYou don't mention looking into the EBV/HHV-6 possibility. I urge you to investigate it immediately. Here's Dr. Martin Lerner's Web site: http://www.treatmentcenterforcfs.com/ http://www.treatmentcenterforcfs.com/ He recommends a collection of tests which could confirm a diagnosis of EBV or HHV-6. (My doctor and I agreed to skip the tests because my symptoms were not nearly as severe as yours and the tests are not quite as reliable as one would like; it seemed simpler just to start me on valacyclovir and see what happened. But for a more severe case like yours, the tests are probably a good idea, I would think.)
- gallamine 15y agoWhen I was 9 years old I developed a low-grade fever for several (9 - 12) months. During that time I was frequently in the Dr.'s office trying to find a reason. None was found. After that year, I always called myself chronically exhausted. Nothing seems to help. I've tried blue/green algae, homeopathic stuff, essential oils, fast food diets, regular exercise, full vegan diet, and so on. Nothing has helped. I've been to several doctors since, with no apparent cause ("take a multivitamin", or "take vitamin D"). I'm heartened to see I might not be alone.