4 ms·
It's a nice piece of hardware, reminiscent of old IBM water-cooled mainframes. But as a solution to self-driving, it's doubling down on a failed strategy. If th
by Animats 5y ago
It's a nice piece of hardware, reminiscent of old IBM water-cooled mainframes. But as a solution to self-driving, it's doubling down on a failed strategy. If they haven't been able to avoid hitting solid obstacles with what they've been doing, more data won't help.
- delaaxe 5y agoDid you watch their presentation? They're definitely not trying to solve self-driving with just "more data"
- kjksf 5y agoYes, more data will help. More data did help with all other Deep Learning problems, from Go to speech synthesis. GPT-3 is orders of magnitude better than GPT-2 because it has more data. It's really Deep Learning 101. Furthermore, it's a non-sequitur of an argument. Dojo is generic neural network training chip. It can be used to speed up any and all Deep Learning problems. Self driving is one such problem. During AI Day Tesla also presented, in depth, the architecture of the Deep Learning network they use. If you have a critique of their approach or can show how a competitor's approach is better, then do share with the class. If you don't it's just lazy "Tesla bad because they solved a problem that no-one else solved"
- Weryj 5y agoIt's not just more data, it's more unique scenarios with more samples of each. More edge cases to train on, that's got to help when training on more complex dimensions on the existing model. They're not just going to bloat the dataset with straight driving.
- delaaxe 5y agoI've worked in data science and most of time, "more data" is just more noise. The guy from comma.ai says the same thing.
- berdario 5y ago1 - you should prove why you think that this problem is just like the other deep learning problems 2 - it's not true that "no-one else solved" this problem. If we define this problem as: have a self-driving vehicle which safely navigates its environment and does not endanger its passengers or the people outside. See the Waymo whitepapers: waymo.com/safety/performance-data Ultimately, even if we agree that what Tesla is working on is orders of magnitude better than what's currently available from them, that might not cut it: Let's assume that the current obstacle detection is 99% accurate... if the newer versions/improved models are 99.9%, 99.99%, etc. accurate... we'll still have a 0.1, 0.01, 0.001%, etc of chance of an obstacle not being recognized. Tesla cars are a small fraction of those on the road, and there've been several deaths already. If million of Teslas will be sold, those small percentages will still mean a significant number of accidents and deaths caused by Tesla. If instead a Lidar reliably detects all obstacles, well in advance of the vehicle approaching it (and the car will stop/disable self driving if the Lidar becomes unoperable, e.g. due to bad weather)... it would be irresponsible to persuade huge swaths of the population to let a machine drive the vehicle, without providing the extra safety that a Lidar enables.
- vardump 5y ago"If million of Teslas will be sold" To date, Tesla has sold about 2 million cars. Not sure how many of those support HW3 "FSD capable" computer, but I'd guess 1,5 million.
- _ph_ 5y agoYou should not mix up the current "autopilot" with the software used in the "full self driving" software package. The traditional autopilot used mostly radar, which is known to not work well with non-moving obstactles. As radar has not much spatial resolution, it relies on the doppler effect to separate moving obstacles (slower cars) from the background, which could be anything, from a stopped car to trees or bridges at the road side. The FSD software package so far has been rolled out as a beta only, to a few selected users. It is based on vision entriely and aims to properly identify everything on the road. The solid obstacles have all been hit by the previous auto pilot version. In the new cars currently sold, the radar has been replaced by a pure vision implementation close to the FSD software, so it remains to be seen which level of safety can be achieved with that.
- panick21 5y agoAll radar based lane keeping solutions have this problem. That is why Tesla is moving away from them. The current version of Autopilot already will no longer have the same issue. If you buy a Model Y or Model 3 in the US, it has no radar anymore.
- Animats 5y agoradar based lane keeping solutions Nobody uses radar for lane keeping. It can't see the lane lines.
- panick21 5y agoI am talking about the overall architecture to make your typical highway standard lane keeping solution. Pretty much every manufacture now has one and they always use forward facing camera and radar in combination. Of course the radar can't see lanes, but its essential for seen if there are cars ahead and how fast they are. All of these solution suffer from the same problem of the radar not being good to detect a stationary object. That is where you have to do more with the camera data or add some form of lidar. I think some 1 car (Audi maybe) use solid state lidar. Tesla has switched to vision only for the most part. No company yet uses active lidar as far as I know.