7 ms·
I hate when my bank calls me about something and then asks to confirm my identity prior to giving out details about my account. Even when I think I know what it
by gnicholas 5y ago
I hate when my bank calls me about something and then asks to confirm my identity prior to giving out details about my account. Even when I think I know what it is about (e.g., a transaction with my card was declined just before the phone call), I feel very strange giving out any information to an inbound caller.
One thing I have thought about doing is providing mistaken information to the caller and see if they go along with it. I came up with this idea when one bank said they could send me a text message and I could read back the number to them (huge red flag).
Does anyone else have any ideas for how to authenticate a BigCorp caller whose corporate policies do not allow them to provide any account information to the people they are calling?
- sReinwald 5y agoTell them you feel uneasy giving out details over the phone to an inbound caller, hang up and call their service line directly. The only way you can be sure you are talking to your bank is if you are calling them.
- gnicholas 5y agoYeah that works, but it's usually time-consuming to get to the specific department that actually called. I wish these companies could route your call to their fraud dept if their fraud dept had just called you, but sadly this doesn't seem to have caught on yet.
- solarengineer 5y agoIn Singapore, Banks send regular reminders that they will never ask us for our personal information over a phone call. It is slowly becoming "common knowledge" among the non-tech-savvy folk I meet in everyday life.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoThen there's an antifraud scenario, when the bank still calls you and asks stuff, now you need precise classification what they can ask you and what you can tell them.
- Angostura 5y agoWait a couple of minutes or call back from a different phone. In the UK it may still be possible for an attacker to hold the line open after you hang up - and then simulate the dial tone.
- sebzim4500 5y agoI've heard this, but I don't understand it. Doesn't the UI feel completely different when it comes to placing a call versus using the keypad on an existing call? On android at least you have to explicitly show the keypad.
- Angostura 5y agoThe UI feels exactly the same if you are using a landline.
- theshrike79 5y agoHow? If I explicitly push the red button on my mobile phone, how does the line still stay open? I can understand this attack via land line, but who seriously has a land line in 2021? Even my 93 year old grandma has a mobile phone. (Albeit we did get her one that looks like a land line phone :D )
- stordoff 5y agoMy grandmother (80s) and her circle of friends all use landlines to communicate. Technically her's is a VoIP line since about six months ago, but it's designed as a drop in replacement (uses the same phones/numbers) so I wonder if there's a possibility the attack is still open. I also use a landline fairly often (mostly out of habit), and most companies only have my landline number as I don't want them contacting me while I'm out/busy. You're right that it's a dwindling number, but it's certainly not at zero yet.
- VMG 5y agoCan you really be sure though? How hard is it really to redirect outgoing calls?
- nextlevelwizard 5y agoYou'd have to have access to the cell tower your phone is connected to. At that point the attack is pretty sophisticated and very targeted.
- abestic9 5y agoGoogle called me wanting to confirm my business address and asked me a bunch of personal details, as well as a 6 digit code that was going to be sent to my number (the one they called me on?). I refused and told them to give me a number to call them back on and they said they didn't have that facility. I then asked if they could email me or point me to a form and they said they could only do it on that same call. After 10 minutes in a verification tug-of-war, the rep escalated me to someone who did provide proof they were actually Google (using a field I updated in my account). All up it took 15 minutes and felt very fraudulent until they finally gave me some helpful context.
- ThrustVectoring 5y ago> told them to give me a number to call them back on I hope you managed to communicate that you needed it to be able to independently verify that this number belonged to the purported caller. Eg, if it's from your "credit card company", the number should show up on the credit card company's website.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- egberts1 5y agoummmm, caller ID are easily spoofed, no?
- wildfire 5y agoyes. And they are starting to understand more and people know that too. Typically banks, when challenged here in Australia, will ask you to hang up and call the number on the back of your card (debit or credit). Normally they give you a reference number so when you are speaking with someone, you can bypass things and pick-up with the person you were originally speaking with.
- nucleardog 5y ago> Does anyone else have any ideas for how to authenticate a BigCorp caller whose corporate policies do not allow them to provide any account information to the people they are calling? I mean, it's really their problem, isn't it? If you need something from them, call their customer line and ask. If they need something from you, then they'll figure it out. I had a financial institution call me one time and ask "Is this nucleardog?" "Yes." "Alright, this is reallyfastwords can we start by verifying your date of birth?" "No. You called me. I didn't even catch who you are. What can I help you with." "I'm with really fast words. I can't tell you anything until I verify your identity." "You called me. You verify your identity first." "If you don't verify, then I can't tell you why I called!" "That's fine." There was a loooong pause before she finally decided on "Okay, what _day_ in June of 1985 were you born?" and apparently that was satisfactory.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y ago> I mean, it's really their problem, isn't it? They'll typically make it your problem by blocking a transaction or your account...
- gnicholas 5y agoI've tried having them give me a checksum of the last four digits of my card number. They refused.
- gjs278 5y agothat’s the stupidest request to make of a customer service rep. good lord.
- jmiserez 5y agoBanks themselves tell you not to give out their info, so that scenario plays out more often than you think. I've had it happen and they just sent a letter by mail instead.
- nobody9999 5y ago>Does anyone else have any ideas for how to authenticate a BigCorp caller whose corporate policies do not allow them to provide any account information to the people they are calling? Definitely. Hang up the phone and call the phone number on the card associated with your account or look up the appropriate telephone number and call them back. If they're legit, they will be perfectly fine with that. If not, they'll likely squawk about it. Either way, the correct process begins with you hanging up without providing any information to the caller. My bank will also send SMS "fraud alerts" with a request to confirm or deny a transaction. That's the same situation, IMHO and the right action is to call the known to be valid phone number for their customer service. Perhaps there are other, fancier ways to do something like this, but as a general rule, scammers can't change the customer service phone number printed on your card, or hack third party services just to give you a fake phone number online.
- bennyp101 5y agoMost banks here (UK) have a mobile app, so I've always wondered why they don't use that to auth the call? Bank: Hey I'm calling from HSBC, want to verify it? Me: Sure Bank: Ok, so open you mobile app, and enter 637482 Me: Ok, cool thats given me 274893 Bank: Yep, that's all confirmed so ...
- CubityFirst 5y agoI feel like training users to input codes into their banking app could lead to other less safe practices.
- adwww 5y agoShould even be possible for the apps to trigger a notification saying a valid inbound call is about to happen.
- another-dave 5y agoThat would save you giving out personal details to authenticate yourself, but may lull people into dropping their guard & divulging personal details before the bank authenticates on _their side_ — as in, nothing in that script prevents a scammer saying "Yep, that's all confirmed" no matter what the person says & then a lay person may feel more secure even though they've proved nothing
- gnicholas 5y agoThis is exactly why I’ve thought of giving a fake reply, since the only way for me to know that they’re who they say they are is to see if they can recognize both an invalid response and a valid one.
- bennyp101 5y agoI was thinking more that once you put the code in, it says that it is a valid call (or not) then you get the response code to give back - at that point they can continue as normal
- theshrike79 5y agoOut here in developed-land I get a link mid-call via SMS, which I can confirm with the CS rep on the phone. I click the link and authenticate with my bank credentials or mobile auth certificate. The CS rep gets my info, which is authenticated to be correct and we get on with our day.