37 ms·
Why not set SUVs and trucks as the default then? One ould have to select the vehicle capable of accommodating the most people and situations. Many large/tall pe
by giantg2 5y ago
Why not set SUVs and trucks as the default then? One ould have to select the vehicle capable of accommodating the most people and situations. Many large/tall people have trouble fitting into cars. You can't pull livestock in a car either.
It's like two people are in a room. One says they're hot. The other says they're cold. The hot person can only take off so many clothes, while the cold person could put on warmer clothes.
Edit: is nobody reading this in the context of the parent comment?
- tshaddox 5y agoWhy should there be a single default, instead of a default for each actual use case?
- giantg2 5y agoBecause they are claiming that the energy mismatch is immoral. Still allowing larger vehicles on the road does not address that mismatch and the "moral" aspect.
- ironman1478 5y agoCar makers are making this the default. Ford is (or has?) eliminated cars from their American offerings. The problem is that even within the class of SUVs and trucks, those vehicles have gotten larger and faster over time. The analogy of the hot and cold person assumes the hot person is wearing a t-shirt and sweater, when in reality when you compare it to vehicles, it's more like they are wearing that gortex jacket from Seinfeld + 3 layers of sweaters. People don't need to cater to somebody unreasonable. People don't need SUVs. They provide like no advantage compared to a wagon to most people and endanger everybody else.
- giantg2 5y ago"Ford is (or has?) eliminated cars from their American offerings." What? Do you have a source? "People don't need SUVs. They provide like no advantage compared to a wagon to most people and endanger everybody else." Can you pull a livestock trailer with a wagon? Anytime you get in any vehicle there is the potential that you endanger other people. Should we ban EVs? A Tesla S can weigh more than an F150... "The analogy of the hot and cold person assumes the hot person is wearing a t-shirt and sweater, when in reality when you compare it to vehicles, it's more like they are wearing that gortex jacket from Seinfeld + 3 layers of sweaters." Then the analogy still works well because the hot person still has clothes to remove. It's when people complain about being cold in the summer and don't wear heavier clothes while the warm people are already wearing the socially acceptable minimum. It's about approaching constraints.
- jbigelow76 5y ago"Ford is (or has?) eliminated cars from their American offerings." What? Do you have a source? Doubling down on the livestock angle? I thought you were trolling. Can you pull a livestock trailer with a wagon? I see now that domestic livestock logistics is a passion of yours. Surely you have sources to tell us how many F-150s it takes to get our bacon to the local Wal-Mart.
- giantg2 5y agoPlease read the comment chain. If you ban SUVs and trucks, there is a segment of the population that will be negatively affected by not having the ability to perform their tasks. The question was way ban SUVs and not cars - that eliminates the energy mismatch and allows the most people the utility they need. I'm asking that person if they've thought of these details when they made their comment.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ironman1478 5y agohttps://www.google.com/amp/s/fordauthority.com/2020/10/executive-explains-decision-to-discontinue-ford-sedans-in-north-america/amp/ https://www.google.com/amp/s/fordauthority.com/2020/10/execu... Not everybody needs to do those things. I have lived 28 years without owning a truck and will never need one. My father knows how to drive many sized trucks for work, but he never needed to own one. Trucks provide utility and to be clear, I singled out SUVs because they have basically no value for people buying them, except that it makes them feel safe because they aren't the smallest vehicle on the road anymore. Most are terrible off-roaders and if people need to carry more people they can buy wagons and vans. Also, the EV remark. The issue is that SUVs are correlated with more deaths, including hitting peds at higher rates. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_sport_utility_vehicles https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_sport_utility_v... If an EV car was correlated with higher deaths than other vehicles, that should be examined and we need to consider it.
- jbigelow76 5y agoYou can't pull livestock in a car either. Yeah, because so many people are trying to fit three head of cattle into a fucking Ford Expedition.
- giantg2 5y agoThe other person is saying the mismatch in size/weight is immoral, so SUVs should be banned. I'm asking why ban SUVs and not cars. That eliminates the mismatch and provides use to the most people because there are things you just can't do with a car, and even people who cannot comfortably/safely fit in them.
- jbigelow76 5y agoI'm asking why ban SUVs and not cars. Because you are willfully ignoring the pedestrian angle by saying the default should be SUV over sedans. Here's one of many sources that is very easy to google for. https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-suvs-are-more-lethal-to-pedestrians-than-cars https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/new-study-suggests-todays-s...
- giantg2 5y ago"Because you are willfully ignoring the pedestrian angle by saying the default should be SUV over sedans." I'm not ignoring it, I'm taking a systems thinking approach to the proposed ban. If it's all about pedestrians, then we should also ban EVs (all cars, really). https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/axa-insurance-claims-high-end-evs-crash-more/ https://www.cnet.com/roadshow/news/axa-insurance-claims-high... https://frankellawfirm.com/are-electric-vehicles-leading-to-more-pedestrian-accidents/ https://frankellawfirm.com/are-electric-vehicles-leading-to-...
- jbigelow76 5y agoIf it's all about pedestrians, then we should also ban EVs (all cars, really). You've opened yourself up to the same absurd reduction, saying if even one farmer is disadvantaged then the standard should be towards the heavy pick-up/SUV instead of the sedan. You talk about "systems" and you say you are not ignoring the pedestrian portion of the system but you have not spoken to it. I would like to hear your position on the energy mismatch between pedestrian vs heavy vehicle as compared to energy mismatch between sedan and pedestrian. What is your perception of the pedestrian, their agency, their right of way in regards to the roads, etc... in the system you have in your head?
- richk449 5y ago> Why not set SUVs and trucks as the default then? (1) Many people can't afford larger vehicles. (2) It is a bad idea to make everyone spend more money on transportation. (3) Larger vehicles have worse gas mileage and are thus worse for the environment. (4) How do you implement the "baselineing"? Does congress pass a law that says all cars on the road must weigh more than X lbs? Seems like an odd policy. (5) Moving more people to SUVs will increase pedestrian and bike deaths, not decrease. (6) So everyone has a SUV. Won't some people just buy bigger SUVs to regain their previous safety status? Doesn't this just cause a race to the bottom? Why would you want to encourage that?
- giantg2 5y agoI'm not actually advocating this. The other person is saying the mismatch in size/weight is immoral, so SUVs should be banned. I'm asking why ban SUVs and not cars. That eliminates the mismatch and provides use to the most people.
- mike00632 5y agoAnd also ban walking and bikes you mean?
- oefnak 5y agoOr maybe genetically engineer people to be bigger.
- giantg2 5y agoNo, but clearly society has accepted the risks with cars, right? They could change city design be safer, or change the drivers test to be less of a joke. After all people do still die when hit with smaller vehicles. And looking at the study, you cloud just limit speed. Pedestrian outcomes are the same for cars and SUVs under 20 mph.
- jjeaff 5y agoThat's kind of like saying that instead of denuclearization, let's just make having nuclear warheads the default and everyone else can get warheads too.
- TomSwirly 5y ago> Why not set SUVs and trucks as the default then? Apparently you aren't joking. 1. Because of pedestrians. 2. Because of bicyclists. 3. Because SUVs and trucks are wildly wasteful of the environment 4. Because SUVs and trucks are expensive so it means the rich kill the poor. 5. Because we are destroying the planet with our emissions and our waste, and you advocate more waste? Seriously?????
- giantg2 5y ago1 and 2 can be handled via other means, like city design and speed control. 5 - EVs would not be producing emissions. 3 and 4 - you can also say these things about cars.
- gilbetron 5y agoTwo cars colliding are safer than two SUVs colliding, it's simple physics. More energy = more damage, generally speaking. I'm 6'4" and never have trouble fitting in the vast majority of cars. In fact, most sedans are more comfortable for me than many SUVs.
- giantg2 5y agoEven with a rear-facing car seat behind you? I find it extremely uncomfortable, and even unsafe, if your knees are touching the dash and/or your head is touching the roof. "Two cars colliding are safer than two SUVs colliding, it's simple physics. More energy = more damage, generally speaking." There's also more energy absorbing material from the amount of energy the crumple zone can absorb. And the interior space make it less likely that it will crush you if the crumpling does extend into the cabin. "There are 20 percent fewer deaths when two SUVs collide than when two cars collide." This is an older article with some outdated info (like A pillars are larger and impact zones on cars have gotten higher), but this seems to refute your claim. https://issues.org/graham/ https://issues.org/graham/