6 ms·
>The rise of newspapers and magazines meant that tales of the bizarre and the outrageous could circulate widely and quickly, while the rapid increase in printed
by duxup 5y ago
>The rise of newspapers and magazines meant that tales of the bizarre and the outrageous could circulate widely and quickly, while the rapid increase in printed advertising made it easy to promote stunts and shams.
Yeah I gotta say I think we know how that might be.
- Waterluvian 5y agoSo what caused things to improve between then and the advent of the Web?
- dleslie 5y agoPublicly owned broadcasters and news agencies came into existence, in some countries, and unburdened by the need to compete primarily on gathering attention they could focus on quality. The CBC and BBC, for example.
- jagged-chisel 5y agoDid they improve? Anecdotally, as a kid in the 80s, I can recall plenty of shams being published. They were limited by physical printing and word of mouth. Going digital just made this information even easier to transmit faster and farther.
- np_tedious 5y agoWe all bought into the "razors/poison in the Halloween candy" bullshit. "Poisoned candy myths - Wikipedia" https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoned_candy_myths#:~:text=Poisoned%20candy%20myths%20are%20urban,Halloween%20trick%2Dor%2Dtreating https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poisoned_candy_myths#:~:text....
- nixpulvis 5y agoNot to be cynical but, what makes you assume it ever improved? I kinda assume it has just been getting worse and worse. I'm somewhat young still, so I don't have a large personal memory of the times before The Web.
- azernik 5y agoFrom my short pre-Web memory, I feel there was a "brief" (several decades) period when a small number of regulated (and after regulation ended, acculturated) neutral TV news channels provided a baseline common narrative. That was already eroding in the '90s, as the massive expansion of available channels through both cable and better over-the-air encoding created a similar publishing boom. Both cable and talk radio in the '90s-'00s presaged the greater impact the web and social media would have.
- nixpulvis 5y agoI too have that feeling, but it still feels somewhat misguided... I can't quite place why. Perhaps I'm just being too pessimistic, that things could in fact be better again. I wonder... Many common narratives are themselves hoxes or scams. Many regulations exist to simply protect the scammers. So I'm not quite sure I agree with your implication. I do however agree that culture was more uniform which could cause the illusion of being taken for a ride a bit more appealing. As for today, I'm amazed at how few people I know even half as pissed off as I am, so maybe they're all still happily on the ferris wheel too?
- azernik 5y agoThe common-denominator media didn't put a stop to disinformation and scams, but it did provide some limits to how completely they could alter your worldview. Information contradicting the mainstream media (which was a realer institution then than it is now) had to be quite convincing to take hold.
- NL807 5y agoI think it's worse! Social media creates a bubble effect where nonsense gets amplified more efficiently and reaches a wider audience. It's having quite a detrimental effect on society right now.
- s3tz 5y agoI think the proliferation of it made people aware and learn quickly to proceed with caution on many fronts.
- admissionsguy 5y ago>> The rise of newspapers and magazines meant that tales of the bizarre and the outrageous could circulate widely and quickly, while the rapid increase in printed advertising made it easy to promote stunts and shams. Was it worse than millenia of unchallengable state-sanctioned bullshit that preceded it?
- Mordisquitos 5y ago> Was it worse than millenia of unchallengable state-sanctioned bullshit? Before the advent of mass media there was no "unchallengeable state-sanctioned" anything. The was a mix of local news and gossip, word-of-mouth, announcements from the local aristocrat or landlord, and more or less accurate rumours arriving from travellers.
- bbarnett 5y agoTrue, but, state craft also had paid snitches to watch, and report on state/king/etc unfriendly talk, which would sit in pubs, or just wander around listening. They also had people spreading state policy/thought, too. Before wide scale monitoring, such as phones, then computers, then internet, massive numbers of people were paid to listen, even in modern times. Mass media was surely an important change, but our ancestors didn't let things go uncontrolled, for, while all of the above was being done internally, external enemies were spreading propaganda to crush foreign kingdoms. This sort of stuff has likely been happening since the dawn of humans, two villages rivaling over local hunting grounds or some such.
- Ialdaboth 5y agoKings had secret agents and diplomats fooling around, sure. But you need the technical/societal advancements and the production surplus brought by modern civilization if you want to be able to run a totalitarian state.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoFeudal cultures were far more limited and totalitarian in every possible way. Serfs literally weren't allowed to leave their villages without a good reason - like war. There was an intellectual monoculture with the Church using scare stories about the fate of the disobedient to terrify serfs into compliance. There was no access to books or personal development. You worked the land, you paid your tithes, and if you were lucky you survived the numerous famines, illnesses, bandit raids, and larger military campaigns, and passed your rented land on to one of your sons. The big difference between that kind of totalitarianism and the modern kind is the fact that the Church has been replaced a more diverse media. In fact there's less diversity than there appears to be. The liberal tradition means there's at least the possibility of independent thought, but it's less common than it might be. In the West, non-compliance and failure-to-be-useful are enforced with brutal economic sanctions. But you can at least think about starting a business and having some nominal independence - which wasn't an option in feudal times. But there's a proselytising corporate monoculture instead of a proselytising religious monoculture [1], and it's very hard for many to imagine that other systems may be possible - never mind better for them. [1] In many parts of the US, you get both.