9 ms·
> Large cars also reduce visibility Buses and vans are huge, yet their design helps with visibility ahead. I propose we force trucks to be designed like vans.
by dzhiurgis 5y ago
> Large cars also reduce visibility
Buses and vans are huge, yet their design helps with visibility ahead. I propose we force trucks to be designed like vans.
- addicted 5y agoYou’re right. It’s not so much the cars are larger that lowers visibility. It’s the design with the massive fronts and massive grilles that are higher than the average male’s height. Some of these cars are really insane and it really worries me for the kids in these people’s houses.
- giantg2 5y ago"It’s the design with the massive fronts and massive grilles that are higher than the average male’s height." This seems sensationalist unless you're talking about class A or B vehicles. Especially with your think-of-the-children remark. Do you have data to back it up?
- stefan_ 5y agoI think you should strap a GoPro to your belt some time and walk around a city. It's not think-of-the-children, not being able to see past vehicle fronts is what life is like for children.
- giantg2 5y ago"not being able to see past vehicle fronts is what life is like for children." This wasn't being discussed. Driver visibility was the topic. How do you feel children not being able to see past the front of a vehicle affects their safety? Presumably they are crossing at crosswalks and intersections which would not have cars parked immediately around them and provides visibility.
- crooked-v 5y ago> which would not have cars parked immediately around them Something tells me you haven't visited an urban downtown lately. Vehicles are often parked right up to the edges of blocks, and that can make safe visibility difficult for adults, let alone children.
- giantg2 5y agoWell then maybe the police should do their jobs and start towing people parked within 15 feet of the intersection. It's a bit ridiculous to advocate for more laws when the current ones aren't enforced. Edit: why downvote? In my opinion city design has more of an impact on safety than vehicle design.
- zten 5y agoBut that parking is usually legal. Nothing to tow over, unless the intersection specifically has markings ("daylighting") prohibiting parking.
- giantg2 5y agoWhere do you live? Most states I know of have laws that specifically prohibit parking within 15 feet of intersections or hydrants regardless of if the curb is marked. It's not only for visibility but also for larger emergency vehicles to navigate.
- erik_seaberg 5y agoIn California it’s 15’ from a fire hydrant/station, 3’ from a wheelchair curb cut, and don’t block a driveway/crosswalk/sidewalk. If they want no parking at a corner they mark it red.
- giantg2 5y agoI guess it's mostly an east coast thing, as most of those states prevent parking within a specified distance of an intersection (or stop signs/lights). Or perhaps the cities in CA set it independently from the state.
- ketzo 5y agoI don’t mean this rudely — have you been around many trucks recently? They’re fucking massive. The newer F-150s, while maybe not 6ft tall at the front, easily obscure a child or a short person. I have personally seen extremely close calls at gas stations/grocery store parking lots multiple times because of this.
- giantg2 5y ago"The newer F-150s, while maybe not 6ft tall at the front, easily obscure a child or a short person." Which is not what the parent is claiming. Edit: people are really downvoting factual statements now?
- ketzo 5y agoOkay, so new trucks don’t exclusively have a hood height of 5’9”+. I still think the broader point of “it’s really hard to see people, even adults, right in front of you” is 1) demonstrably true 2) extremely scary.
- giantg2 5y ago“it’s really hard to see people, even adults, right in front of you” Then they should say that instead of sensationalizing it. "1) demonstrably true" Do you have some evidence of this? 1) If you have awareness, you should see objects before they move into any blind spot. 2) Driver height in relation to the hood height plays an important role in visibility, which means that you can see things shorter than the hood height depending on the distance from the vehicle. 3) Many new larger trucks come with 360 degree cameras now, so the blind spots are not an issue.
- jkelleyrtp 5y agoI own a Dodge Ram 2500 and I can say that it's much harder to see things in front of you simply because the vehicle is so large. It's tough to park, tough to take through a small town, and hard to see out of in short-sight conditions. But it hauls a trailer, so it has a purpose.
- crooked-v 5y agoIt's hyperbole, but not by much. For example, a current model GMC Sierra HD Denali straight from the factory floor, before even considering aftermarket lift kits, has a hood line about 55" off the ground. Someone in a wheelchair or an average 10-year-old would be completely hidden from the view of the driver.
- giantg2 5y agoThe parent said F150, which is a different level of truck and lower. They were also talking about full size adult males. Their statement was factually inaccurate. Edit: why downvote? Should we just leave fake information circulate?
- vitus 5y agoIt's pretty close, though. The closest proxy to this that I could find ("inside height" of the truck bed plus "open tailgate to ground") is 57.4-57.7" for a 2015 4x4, while the average adult male in the US is 5'9". https://www.fordfseries.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2019-F150_rozm%C4%9Bry.pdf https://www.fordfseries.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/2019-... I don't know about you, but if you looked at the top 1.3" of my head, you'd just see hair. edit: as pointed out, I am bad at math apparently.
- giantg2 5y agoI think you need to check your math. 5'9" comes out to 69", giving you about 12" visible inches (more dpending on driver height and distance from vehicle).
- anigbrowl 5y agoIt's OK to point someone is being hyperbolic but you are nitpicking many posts on the topic, with 16 comments so far. Maybe just ease back the reply button a bit.
- giantg2 5y agoCan you give me an example of the nitpicking? Mostly I've been pointing out incorrect information or explaining my prior comment because someone misread the comment or didn't read how it relates to the context set by the parent.
- klyrs 5y agoI don't know where you live, but in north america, trucks are getting ridiculously huge. They aren't sold like that, but aftermarket lift kits are extremely common; I fear that there's nothing sensationalist about GP. I live in Vancouver and trucks like this are quite frequent. In places like Texas and Alberta, they're downright common. Speaking of children... little ones can walk directly under these trucks without bonking their heads
- giantg2 5y ago"They aren't sold like that, but aftermarket lift kits are extremely common;" The parent was talking about the design of new trucks. Aftermarket modifications would be a different topic.
- klyrs 5y agoI'd agree, if they weren't so damned prevalent. Their dominating presence on the road absolutely factors into the real and perceived safety that is driving the race towards ever larger cars
- giantg2 5y agoBut then we would be discussing a different topic - forbidding or further restricting aftermarket modifications instead of the current discussion about all trucks and larger vehicles. It seems the stock designs are reasonable and pass various safety considerations (stability, braking, etc) that the extremely modified versions would not.
- klyrs 5y agoNo, that's not a different topic at all. If tax is based on vehicle size, then that tax should increase with aftermarket modifications to the vehicle's size. Likewise, if an aftermarket modification violates vehicle regulations, that should be punished accordingly.
- 5y ago
- Gibbon1 5y agoI have a full sized van. The viability out the front is good, back not so much. I helped a friend move some of her mothers stuff to storage. My friend rented a truck. Driving it my impression is the tall hood results an unacceptable blind spot. Is a child or a short women was in front you wouldn't be able to see them and that's not okay in my book. That said viability of all cars is getting worse due to low slopped roofs and phat A pillars. As a friend says they're making cars safer for the driver at the expense of everyone else.
- WalterBright 5y agoCommercial vans like the Ford E-150 are large, but actually have very good visibility, much better than cars. This is due to the sloping nose, and the big fat side mirrors. It makes sense, as business drivers using those vans often need to get in and out of tight spaces.