4 ms·
You could use this article's underlying thesis to explain why a lot of tech companies fail as well. Google Health is a good example of failing to appreciate sp
by dmix 5y ago
You could use this article's underlying thesis to explain why a lot of tech companies fail as well.
Google Health is a good example of failing to appreciate specialization and domain-expertise. Trying to draw value from broad generic data collection when IRL it requires vertical-focused domain-oriented collection and analysis to really draw value.
Funnelling everything into a giant pool of data only had so much value - reducing it to just a proprietary API integrations platform in exchange for valuable data.
This AI analogy extends to healthcare in real life: The job of any generalist doctor is largely just triaging you to the specialists. You reach the limits of their care pretty quickly for anything serious.
AI is much the same way, the generic multipurpose tools tend to quickly lose value after surface level stuff before requiring heavy specialization. Google's search engine is full of custom vertical categorization, where simple Pagerank wasn't enough.
This is why startups can be very useful to society as they get forced to focus on smaller issues early on, out of pure practicality, or quickly die off if they try to bite a bigger problems than they can chew.
Almost every major multi-faceted business started off with a few 'whales' on which they built their business.
Most of the biggest startup flops have been the ones that took VC really early before doing the dirty hard work of truly finding and understanding the problems they are trying to solve.
- iamstupidsimple 5y ago> Google Health is a good example of failing to appreciate specialization and domain-expertise. Trying to draw value from broad generic data collection when IRL it requires vertical-focused domain-oriented collection and analysis to really draw value. I'm not sure I agree with this statement. From what I've heard, Google Health employed a huge team of doctors and they were included through the entire feature development lifecycle, similar to how the product org functions in other software companies.
- dmix 5y agoHiring a broad set of domain experts != a domain/vertical focused business. ‘Doctors’ can cover a massive disparate field of study. My point is they did it backwards, they should have found real world healthcare problems to solve then built the common ground between them. Building a generic API platform or cloud database turned out to not be the problem anyone needed help solving. Most companies who did the integration to Health did it for marketing, not because it was essential to any business value. How many companies have done “AI” merely for marketing too? Google search ranked websites better than anyone, they zeroed in on that one problem and removed all the cruft, while Yahoo and others were jamming as much crap into their ‘portals’ as possible. Google seemed to have forgot that lesson. Waymo fell for this too. They built an entirely new type of car and gambled on a whole new taxi service (among other promises) that would entirely disrupt transportation - as the starting point. Innovation rarely ever jumps ten steps ahead like that. They chose to solve a thousand problems at once while the rest of the world with actual delivered products are struggling to solve even assisted highway driving in high-end luxury cars.. cars people were going to buy anyway.
- AlbertCory 5y agoAlgorithm: 1) Decide to take over Domain X. 2) Hire a bunch of people from Domain X. Don't hire anyone who doesn't agree that you can take over X. 3) Make them report to the people whose idea it was in the first place. If they say "Hey, maybe this wasn't such a great idea" then push them out, as an example to the rest. 4) FAIL. Note that #1 is the key. The decision to do it precedes the hiring.