3 ms·
The issue, though, is that if you look at most causes of significant inflation, while people like to blame "money printing", it is actually almost always a big
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
The issue, though, is that if you look at most causes of significant inflation, while people like to blame "money printing", it is actually almost always a big supply shock that is the root cause.
With rental housing, there are 2 major supply shocks:
1. Much new housing was put on hold during the pandemic.
2. Critically, the eviction ban over the past 18 months has absolutely killed many small time landlords. Any prospective small-time landlord would certainly think twice about getting into the business now, and many existing small-time landlords are doing everything they can get out. It doesn't help that landlords are basically demonized by a large section of the political class. The end result is this: https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/selling-out-americas-local-landlords-moving-big-investors-2021-07-29/ https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/selling-out-america...
So, at the end of it, it comes down to basic supply-and-demand, and the supply side got crushed.
- xxpor 5y agoI don't see why small landlords are relevant to a supply shock here. If supply has been effectively destroyed by people not paying rent but also not being evicted, that should affect everyone right? In other words, it'd only matter if the bottleneck is the amount of capital buying houses to rent coming from small landlords. We all know that's not the case though, the bottleneck is the actual supply of housing.
- gbronner 5y agoThe pandemic made it relatively cheaper to use rather than rent space. So some units are off the market and are in use as guest units/ extra bedroom/whatever
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoSmall landlords are relevant to the supply shock because, after seeing the effect of the eviction moratorium, many will opt to either (a) not rent out existing space they own at all, or certainly find less risky ways to rent it out, like STRs, or (b) find something else to invest their money into in the first place. Also, there is evidence that small time landlords are much less aggressive when it comes to evictions (see https://www.atlantafed.org/-/media/documents/community-development/publications/discussion-papers/2016/04-corporate-landlords-institutional-investors-and-displacement-2016-12-21.pdf https://www.atlantafed.org/-/media/documents/community-devel... from the Atlanta Fed). This means that small-time landlords provide a greater percentage of the supply for "marginal renters", i.e. renters who are more likely to miss payments. When that supply goes away it means there will be more competition among these marginal renters to find a place to live.
- ldoughty 5y agoThe problem actually goes much further back than the pandemic... The housing bubble/crises lead to a massive supply of homes being foreclosed on and purchased by wealthier groups. It also lead to a large exodus of home building professionals as the demand dried up. This resulted in the US building 500,000+ fewer homes per year than the typical demand of the growing population normally demands. The US is now > 7,000,000+ homes behind were we should have been at this point, which means home prices skyrocket making them unavailable to entry level workers. On top of this, it's a common strategy among the wealthy to but a 2nd, 3rd, or more homes, which they rent to rent out at their mortgage rate or higher because the system allows it... So someone who can't get a $1200/month mortgage (for an example) now has a $1200 rent paid to someone for their second home... Though generally they pair up with others or other couples to live together and afford the rent... This also ignores the trend of businesses engaging in the activity.. buying homes in mass for rental properties instead of the typical apartment/townhouse apartment developments.
- UncleMeat 5y ago> . Critically, the eviction ban over the past 18 months has absolutely killed many small time landlords. Any prospective small-time landlord would certainly think twice about getting into the business now, and many existing small-time landlords are doing everything they can get out. It doesn't help that landlords are basically demonized by a large section of the political class. The end result does not have to be what you mention. We can enact policy to ensure that housing is available to the masses. I don't personally spill many tears over the landlords who lost money. For years, every time people have asked "why can the landlords extract rent", they respond with "the landlords take on the risk". Okay. So this is the risk coming back around. There was never a guarantee that landlords would always make money, nor should there have been.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoIt's not about "spilling tears" for anyone, it's about creating the right economic incentives to ensure there is plentiful housing supply, and having an eviction ban for 18 months absolutely kills that incentive. And when it come to "the landlords take on the risk", well, in the past, this was always true. There's the risk of bad tenants, the risk of unplanned environmental damage (just ask anyone in Texas who had to go through major floods or ice storms with no power), etc. But the extended eviction ban basically was changing the rules in the middle of the game, to what amounted to government appropriation of property without just compensation, and that is exactly the type of risk any decent functioning government is supposed to prevent.
- sooheon 5y agoYou're right, a sudden eviction ban is a gross market intervention that helped tenants and harmed landlords, and on the net caused market failure. My only point is that the status quo of privatized claims to unearned land value increments is a gross market failure in the other direction.
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoThis is true for the majority of asset classes now. Stocks can't go down, the Fed will press buttons. Housing can't go down, the Fed will press buttons. The dollar can't go up, etc...