3 ms·
> Specifically, there's an especially tricky road in I-35N in Texas Seems like you could just get some data on that before declaring that "we're not even close
by ajross 5y ago
> Specifically, there's an especially tricky road in I-35N in Texas
Seems like you could just get some data on that before declaring that "we're not even close". How do shipping Teslas do?
FWIW: my impression is that the things people think are hard aren't the problems that are actually hard. People here and elsewhere on the internet have spent years screaming about lidar vs. radar vs. vision. And... it turns out vision basically won. Something like half the Tesla fleet in ths US are vision only in the US now, and... the cars see stuff just fine. We're not having detection failures. It works.
If you watch all the FSD beta video being spread around youtube, much of it by drivers specifically looking for edge cases like this, most of the remaining problems are in pathing and decisionmaking, not detection. The cars see a busy intersection and then get paralyzed (there was an amusing clip from one guy of a car trying to make a left turn, giving up, and repathing a right turn that took it back in a loop only to fail at the same left turn repeatedly), or creep too slowly and annoy other drivers. Or they choose the wrong lane, or misread a multiple traffic light environment, or misread the need for detection (the one really dangerous video I remember had the car deciding to take a left turn across a broad street with a complicated blind corner instead of creeping out farther).
Those are bugs to fix, for sure. But they're not the bugs we thought we had to fix. Those bugs... got fixed.
So you can look at this as a pessimist and say "we'll never get there", or you can judge from previous experience that the hard problems won't turn out to be that hard in the end.
Personally, having been watching the progress in this space, my guess is that Tesla and Waymo (and maybe Mobileye -- no one else is close) get this basically fixed within a year or two.
At which point the debate will shift from "we'll never get there" to "we'll never be able to regulate this appropriately" or somesuch.
- zamadatix 5y ago> Something like half the Tesla fleet in ths US are vision only in the US now, and... the cars see stuff just fine. We're not having detection failures. It works. You and I have extremely different experiences with Teslas. About the only place I could conceive arguing it works is highways and even then I wouldn't trust riding one down the highway without a steering wheel. Hell, my coworker can't even call his out of the driveway because it has been thinking his mailbox is a car for the last 6 months. I think we'll get there and I don't think it'll matter if it's with LIDAR or pure vision but we're certainly not close to being able to remove the steering wheel (regulation aside).
- ajross 5y agoMine drove me to Yellowstone and back with like two disengagements which were my paranoia about other traffic. But yes: the example was an interstate in Texas. And I happen to know it actually works quite well on interstates. So a very reasonable experiment about whether or not automation "will never get there" on edge cases like the referenced interstate is to take a commonly deployed, already available automation technology there and test it. But also recognize that shipping autopilot is now about a year old. All the FSD work hasn't made it to released cars yet. It's very much evolved, but visible only on youtube right now.
- iknowstuff 5y agoSummon uses the old, pre surround video NN. The FSD stack is a whole different beast.
- coryrc 5y agoWe're not having detection failures. Then what do you call them hitting stationary things regularly?
- iknowstuff 5y agoRadar
- ajross 5y agoA lie. Or at least a giant [citation needed]. What evidence exists seems to show (not really surprisingly) that the cars are safer with AP engaged than when not.
- coryrc 5y agohttps://www.necn.com/news/national-international/us-agency-opens-formal-probe-into-tesla-autopilot-system/2536444/ https://www.necn.com/news/national-international/us-agency-o... https://www.foxnews.com/auto/tesla-smashes-overturned-truck-autopilot https://www.foxnews.com/auto/tesla-smashes-overturned-truck-... How often do people hit a giant stationary object in the middle of a nearly-empty freeway?
- FireBeyond 5y ago> What evidence exists seems to show (not really surprisingly) that the cars are safer with AP engaged than when not. Good way to change goal posts. There are many, many instances of Teslas hitting large stationary objects on roads, and who knows more instances of near misses due to driver intervention. When the AP can be engaged, which is usually 'better' conditions. Unfortunately humans don't always have the option of driving in 'better' conditions, so this is an entirely cherry picked subset of data.
- jeffbee 5y agoCmon. There's a video of a Tesla FSD driving on the wrong side of the road, cutting off a car it did not see at an intersection, then accelerating straight into a fence, all in the space of five minutes in Oakland. Tesla has by no means solved the vision problem. Their software is laughably bad. https://youtu.be/antLneVlxcs?t=633 https://youtu.be/antLneVlxcs?t=633
- sedgjh23 5y agoAncient footage, they fixed this bug
- jeffbee 5y agoIt's sort of on you to back up the extraordinary claim that these defects have disappeared in the last five months. Edit: FSD 9 accelerates across double lines toward bridge support in San Francisco. https://youtu.be/GlIdu7prsAw?t=155 https://youtu.be/GlIdu7prsAw?t=155
- rcxdude 5y agoLike it's just a forgotten semicolon which explains all this behaviour. This isn't 'a bug', it's a big, complex, systemic reliability problem.
- leoedin 5y agoFor anyone wondering what "ancient" means - it was 5 months ago. Maybe the commenter has a different definition of ancient than me.
- titzer 5y agoIt's incredible to me that they let this thing on the road. It could not pass a driver's test!
- davidcbc 5y agoTeslas are not self driving cars regardless of what Musk claims. They aren't even close. Even Tesla admits that their "full self driving" mode is only level 2 automation. https://techcrunch.com/2021/05/07/tesla-refutes-elon-musks-timeline-on-full-self-driving/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/05/07/tesla-refutes-elon-musks-t...
- jlund-molfese 5y agoWhat do you call the video of a Tesla mistaking the moon for a yellow traffic light[1], if not a detection failure? That wouldn't happen with a lidar-only or lidar-assisted system. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UF-S2czdCk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7UF-S2czdCk
- sedgjh23 5y agothey said most, not all
- zootboy 5y agoI'm not sure how lidar would help in detecting yellow lights correctly. Seems to me like that has to be a vision system, at least until we get all traffic lights to report their state via radio.
- jlund-molfese 5y agoI was thinking distance—if the object emitting the yellow light is 240K miles away from your car, it can be assumed that it isn’t a traffic signal, right?
- FireBeyond 5y ago"how far away is the light?"
- qwertox 5y agoThis is a strange bug. As if they weren't making predictions about where the yellow light would have to be one second later, by using at least speed and accelerometer data, and compare the expected result with the new reality. This is not necessarily a job for lidar, they are just omitting some checks. At second 18 [1] a street light comes into play which looks similar to the moon. That relative movement is what the system should have been expecting from the moon, but they apparently just re-computed the assumption that the moon is a traffic light which is moving along with the car. It's somewhat revealing that they are not doing these kind of checks. I actually can't believe that they aren't doing it, but I can't see a case where the traffic light would always be at the same spot, if you have velocity and acceleration data at hand. A traffic light is a very important thing. [1] https://youtu.be/7UF-S2czdCk?t=18 https://youtu.be/7UF-S2czdCk?t=18