4 ms·
I wonder how disruptive it would be if we let other countries set up health care centers in the US to compete.
by mensetmanusman 5y ago
I wonder how disruptive it would be if we let other countries set up health care centers in the US to compete.
- EliRivers 5y agoPresumably you don't just mean the creation of healthcare companies in the US that are foreign-owned but still subject to the exact same current US system (because that would just be the same as now, essentially); presumably you mean something really innovative (or crazytown, depending on view!) like allowing a section of a US population to outright join a foreign system. For example, Seattle decides to switch to the UK NHS, cuts a deal with the UK whereby everyone in Seattle pays into the UK treasury at the same rate UK citizens do towards the NHS, and the NHS takes on a responsiblity for universal healthcare in Seattle for Seattle citizens. Is this the kind of idea you mean? Certainly would be interesting and as a spitballing conversation piece, fun to discuss.
- philjohn 5y agoThe problem with that is that, when it's an extra cost, the uptake may well skew towards those who are more dependent on healthcare with chronic conditions. Single payer works because the risk pool is spread overy everyone in the entire country - and everyone has to pay (it's part of income taxes). That's why the ACA mandate was a thing.
- EliRivers 5y agoYes. It would have to be everybody in. All of Seattle pays in, no exceptions. You say "the problem with that". Pitched another way, we could say "the benefit of that"... when it's an extra cost Would it necessarily be an extra cost? I understand that the amount typically paid in the US on health insurance, by the individual and employers, compares badly with the amount paid in many other systems that provide better healthcare for less money.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThen the healthy/richer people move to a suburb of Seattle. The reason nationwide taxpayer funded healthcare works is because it is not easy to move to another country.
- mumblemumble 5y agoIt's not like they would be able to import the legal, regulatory and economic environments that foster their lower prices or better outcomes. I would assume that all they would really be able to bring to the table is brand recognition.
- elliekelly 5y agoLegal, regulatory, and economic environments have been “imported” before. I’m not sure how well they actually work in practice but the Colón Free Trade Zone and the Kazakhstan Astana International Finance Center, come to mind as examples. Even Hong Kong, to some degree, started as an “imported” legal system.
- vsskanth 5y agoYou don't need other countries, just allow US entrepreneurs to setup health care services. Google "certificate of need" and you'll see why these hospitals virtually have monopolies in so many counties. US Healthcare nowhere close to a free market.
- fineIllregister 5y agoCertificates of Need solve a very real problem that "free market" health care had. Having health care exposed to boom and bust cycles was unacceptable to people. You'll have to propose an alternative solution better than "well maybe you die" if you want to change that.
- throw_m239339 5y agoAny "foreign hospital" would have to abide by the same standards as "American ones". Furthermore, if it's for profit, I don't see why "foreign establishments" would have lower costs, they'd try to maximize their profit as much as "American ones". Medical tourism is a more cost effective alternative, for dental care, eyesight, or even some heavy surgeries. The problem is the people who would likely benefit the most from that often don't even have a passport... I made the same point about education cost in the rest of the west VS USA previously. Americans are entitled to travel or study in a lot of foreign countries without any hurdle, most of them don't ever take advantage of it for arbitrage.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoWe could let them import their standards to see if the US standards are better or worse.
- tsjq 5y agonot even mega Joint Venture could make any progress. they shut down . "Haven was a not-for-profit, healthcare-focused entity created through a joint venture by American companies Amazon, Berkshire Hathaway and JPMorgan Chase. The entity's stated goals were to improve healthcare services and lower costs for the three companies' employees, while making primary care easier to access, making prescription drugs more affordable and rendering insurance benefits easier to understand." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haven_Healthcare https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haven_Healthcare
- elzbardico 5y agoBecause the insurance/hospitals/pharma cartel have their ways to ensure that new entrants that don't play ball suffer some nasty consequences.
- someguydave 5y agoDoctors and nurses are just as complicit in holding out for more cash.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThere is nothing wrong with people bargaining for what they are worth. Especially for laborious jobs working around sick people. I do not exactly see all my work from home friends who I know are working less than 40 hours a week Mon to Fri 9 to 5 clamoring to go help at the hospital right now even at current nurse's pay.