3 ms·
> It seems like disengagement numbers from testing are on the order of 10-20K miles. That’s no longer the case. Waymo is over 30k miles per disengagement, how
by Retric 5y ago
> It seems like disengagement numbers from testing are on the order of 10-20K miles.
That’s no longer the case. Waymo is over 30k miles per disengagement, however it’s also a meaningless number.
The point of disengagement’s isn’t a proxy for accidents it’s to avoid cars simply shutting down in traffic and make it really clear the car is confused. Waymo is operating driverless taxis with as I said over 20 million miles often with an empty car and they’re using a call center to handle edge cases. People remotely pilot the car at very low speeds when needed, but the car must come to a safe stop on it’s own.
Having someone handle an edge case every 30k miles hours for is cheap enough to be bundled into a new car’s price. Worse case they pull off the road and call a tow truck, but more normally they can get the car to a place or can safely drive. Put a drunk driver in a car with that behavior and you don’t get accidents every 30k miles.
- perl4ever 5y ago>it’s also a meaningless number Saying something is meaningless doesn't make it so. Often things don't mean what people would like them to mean, but every observation means something. If Waymo is operating in particularly easy environments, then it's plausible that it's not as good as a 30K mile interval would imply. But that number definitely implies an upper bound, because if they could go longer, they would. Do you have a source for there being no safety driver physically in the car and the car always finding a safe state on its own?
- Retric 5y agoIt’s the Wamo one service in a very limited area of Phenix that’s operating without a safety driver. They started in 2020 with 10% of the rides without a safety driver and it’s been ramping up. There’s been a fair amount of coverage for example: https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2021/01/04/waymo-driverless-car https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2021/01/04/waymo-driverless-... The safe state thing is inferred based on the list of crashes so far. Clearly it’s not going to always work perfectly to the end of time, but it’s good enough that their testing it without a safety driver in the car which says quite a bit.