6 ms·
Games in general suffer from the fact that more technology does not necessarily lead to better visual - or narrative - outcomes. There was a period of time wher
by roenxi 5y ago
Games in general suffer from the fact that more technology does not necessarily lead to better visual - or narrative - outcomes. There was a period of time where every game engine producer was very excited about their engine's ability to render hair and I dunno if there are many games where the quality of the hair rendering has been a factor in the graphics. "More realism" runs up against the hard truth that these games are being projected on a 2D screen and can't be realistic. And even if it was, there still needs to be a justification for why that is better - it isn't self evident that more realistic graphics is a batter outcome. The real world is pretty boring, that is why people are playing games.
- billfruit 5y agoHair I'm not sure, but I think the sort of 'dynamic' trees and foliage that move with wind and rain, should add more realism. I hear Witcher 3 had some kind of system that did that, not sure about any other games that do that.
- ajuc 5y agoIt was a little over the top. But yes it was nice. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LzSS5oxKjUA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LzSS5oxKjUA
- oddity 5y agoI'm not a professional artist or marketer, but I suspect the main reason we see the pursuit of realism in games is that it's easy to communicate and coordinate, so it reduces uncertainty across the board. Developing a style is hard and requires a lot of coordination across different teams to understand and internalize what approximations are being made where. At scale with hundreds of artists, it becomes very difficult. If, instead, the approximations are enforced by the tech and the goal the artists need to consider is just to create something realistic, then that's easy to get started with without needing a concept artist to dictate everything. There's probably a crossover point of team size where realism has lower risk and lower cost. In practice, I think what we see is that the more creatively-minded large studios shoot for 90% of assets being "realistic" with some strong stylistic choices for the last 10% that really defines the look. On the marketing side, there's something to be said for knowing that your visual style will be uncontroversial for the most critical time period for getting sales (launch). Looking horrible 10 years from now doesn't really matter if you're trying to recoup your investment today. It has slowed down now because a lot of the low hanging fruit has been done, but a decade or so ago, graphical features were one more reason marketing could point to for someone to buy a game. Some people really do buy games because they look pretty. Even today, there are games notable only for being benchmarks.
- cultofmetatron 5y agoreminds me of the outcry when windwaker was announced to use cellshading. Nowadays people love it but back in the day it was initially reviled by a lot of people before it eventually won them over
- thom 5y agoI think this is true beyond graphics as well. I remember when games started shipping with fully voice-acted dialogue, it felt like all the interesting interactive text based systems (however clunky) were immediately abandoned. This hurt immersion for me far more than text vs speech ever did. I'm excited by the progress in dynamically generated voices in games happening now, although in many cases that seems more like having better placeholders in your asset pipeline than using them as production-level dialogue.
- RobertKerans 5y agoI'd posit that there's a general principle underpinning this that is true for most things (not games, or art, but everything). This is a bit half-formed in my head, but: Computer tech makes certain important classes of things cheaper and more convenient to create. Sometimes it makes those things feasible in the first place. But it's always via enabling of cheap duplication of an existing process. As tech evolves in power, it can do more. The high-speed duplicative properties of computers are the thing that makes them useful. For them them to be generally useful [and critically, financially useful], crafted, stylised, personal aspects are stripped out. So much does not work as well or look as good or is as interesting as things from the previous evolution that were built or provided or staffed by knowledgable, skilled practitioners. But given that skilled practitioners are finite, on average what comes out is better in some useful aspects than most of the efforts of the previous evolution. And on average it's easier to produce/manage/handle at scale. So pick anything: Amazon, Uber, Google search, medical records, 3D games, etc etc, ad infinitum. Almost anything you can use computer tech for. What's being talked about in the comments: it's not generalisable, so it gets chucked. It's too hard to do, so sand off the sharp edges, cut anything that can't be reduced to an algorithm, package the inferior but much more convenient version that can scale (I assume there is some body of thought with literature relating to this process that I should dig into, but I think people like Walter Benjamin and Milan Kundera have probably described it much better than I can w/r/t art [or maybe Ruskin or Morris, though their idea are all maybe a bit idealistic] this destruction of the personal to the service of the machine)
- birdyrooster 5y agoGreat example of this today is real-time raytracing. They look hideous.
- yissp 5y agoAgreed. Looking at https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_video_games https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_video_g... only 2 of the top 10 (GTA V and PUBG) have what I would call a realistic aesthetic. Even looking at the entire list, games with a more stylized look are far more prevalent.