9 ms·
Highly Vaccinated Israel Is Seeing a Dramatic Surge in New Covid Cases
- danmaz74 5y ago> The good news is that among Israel's serious infections on Thursday of this week, according to Health Ministry data, the rate of serious cases among unvaccinated people over age 60 (178.7 per 100,000) was nine times more than the rate among fully vaccinated people of the same age category, and the rate of serious cases among unvaccinated people in the under-60 crowd (3.2 per 100,000) was a little more than double the rate among vaccinated people in that age bracket.
- peter422 5y agoUnder 60 is not a specific enough age group for comparison of vaccinated vs unvaccinated cases. A 55 year old and a 12 year old have vastly different odds of serious disease, so much so that an unvaccinated 12 year old is less likely to get severe disease than a vaccinated 55 year old. This easily could be biased by the older end of that range being significantly more vaccinated than the younger end. If you want to compare vaccinated efficacy, look for 10 year age group comparisons. Anything else is really leaving you wide open to misleading interpretations.
- ajay-b 5y agoIs it possible The vaccine has the opposite effect on some people, rather than helping them to defend, it makes it easier for them to become infected?
- belter 5y agoFrom a purely scientific point a view, there is no reason for the post above (from ajay-b) to be downvoted.
- r00fus 5y agoWild assertions without data or references are simply trolling.
- dogma1138 5y agoA question isn’t a wild assertion.
- r00fus 5y agoA wild assertion can indeed be posed as a question. It's a dark pattern rampantly used in conspiracy circles.
- ekianjo 5y agoThere's nothing wild about that kind of questions. We know that sometimes vaccines are the cause of re-infections (for inactivated agents vaccines): https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1383764/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1383764/
- linuxhansl 5y agoBecause this hypothesis has already been shown to be false numerous times.
- dogma1138 5y agoAnd the GP was asking a question, not stating it as a fact.
- linuxhansl 5y agoA question that would take 2-3 minutes of Googling to answer. I did not downvote that question, but I still think it didn't have any place here.
- dogma1138 5y ago
- mixedCase 5y agoWhat mechanism are you suggesting would be at fault for such an outcome?
- wayneftw 5y agoFrom my own experience, I see that vaccinated people are less fearful of mixing with large groups of people. That's one way the vaccinated can be more easily infected. It's not a physiological effect but I think it's probably the crux of the whole issue here.
- jonplackett 5y agoBehaviour-wise this is definitely true - not for everyone, but many. But I don't think it wouldn't matter for the comparison because they're looking at rates of serious illness, rather than absolute number of people catching it. Saying that, if seriousness of disease is related to initial exposure amount, perhaps being vaxxed and overly brave could mean you get a higher initial dose?
- wayneftw 5y agoOK thanks. I thought the major concern was the number of people getting it not the number of severe cases... I'm not really sure why it is this way. I would think lessening the spread of it would be the highest priority.
- recursivedoubts 5y agoA possible mechanism I have seen mentioned is Antibody Dependent Enhancement: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibody-dependent_enhancement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antibody-dependent_enhancement I am not a biologist and have no opinion on the matter, I have just seen it mentioned online.
- belter 5y agoInteresting. It seems that this was actually a concern and considered during initial development of COVID vaccines. It seems it was considered not likely to happen but there is this interesting part here from 2019 that caught my attention: "Consensus summary report for CEPI/BC March 12–13, 2020 meeting: Assessment of risk of disease enhancement with COVID-19 vaccines" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7247514/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7247514/ "A syndrome of “disease enhancement” has been reported in the past for a few viral vaccines where those immunized suffered increased severity or death when they later encountered the virus or were found to have an increased frequency of infection. Animal models allowed scientists to determine the underlying mechanism for the former in the case of Respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) vaccine and have been utilized to design and screen new RSV vaccine candidates. Because some Middle East respiratory syndrome (MERS) and SARS-CoV-1 vaccines have shown evidence of disease enhancement in some animal models, this is a particular concern for SARS-CoV-2 vaccines. To address this challenge, the Coalition for Epidemic Preparedness Innovations (CEPI) and the Brighton Collaboration (BC) Safety Platform for Emergency vACcines (SPEAC) convened a scientific working meeting on March 12 and 13, 2020 of experts in the field of vaccine immunology and coronaviruses to consider what vaccine designs could reduce safety concerns and how animal models and immunological assessments in early clinical trials can help to assess the risk. This report summarizes the evidence presented and provides considerations for safety assessment of COVID-19 vaccine candidates in accelerated vaccine development."
- heavyset_go 5y agoSome vaccine candidates can do this, but it would have been caught early on as it's one of the things researchers will look out for. There are some citations here[1] when it comes to this phenomenon and COVID vaccines. It hasn't been observed in clinical trials, nor after mass inoculations. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_misinformation#Antibody-dependent_enhancement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_misinformation#Antibo...
- hammock 5y agoOutcomes suggestive of Antibody Dependent Enhancement (what we are talking about) were seen in animal trials, but the animal trials were canceled.
- higherup 5y agoIts called ADE and if Vaccine generated anti-bodies are not sterilising (as current COVID vaccines are), then the antibodies with the bonded virus, can take the virus to places that otherwise would be off limits to it, making it much more lethal..
- bsaul 5y agoi'm amazed at the number of people still believing high vaccination rates will get us rid of the covid, despite all the evidences of the previous year pointing in the opposite directions (people getting infected multiple times in a short period, variants mutating the spike protein a lot, and more recently vaccinated people still proven to be both carrier and transmitter of the virus). The final nail in the coffin being country-sized experiments like israel, showing no sign of any kind of victory over the epidemic. What surprise me most is the slow rate at which government adjust their strategy.. As an example, my country (france) still is deep in its "vaccine pass" controversial measure, splitting the country in half, and the government seems to show no sign of hesitation or even doubts whether it really is the best thing to do... They're running this strategy based on 6-months old assertions, and half the population doesn't seem to notice it.
- creato 5y ago> That means only 58% of Israel's total citizenry is fully vaccinated. Experts say that's not nearly high enough. 58% isn't that much higher than most other countries. France actually has a higher vaccination rate at 61%! So I'm not sure what you think the "country-sized experiment" is.
- bsaul 5y agothat's a very different take on the situation than what israel experts were saying just a few months ago. They reopened everything thanking the vaccine for that, and being happy of being the first country to heavily bet on mass vaccination. (note that the country is closed to people who don't have a pass, and people have to quarantine when they arrive). It looks a bit like they're changing the narrative now that the next wave is coming, saying vaccination rates aren't high enough after all (i'm curious to see one expert provide a definitive number on the "good enough" threshold, based on models or anything else, but maybe 100% it is ?)
- pseudalopex 5y agoI don't know who Israel experts means. But public health experts in different countries said we wouldn't know until people got vaccinated. Some estimated it could be up to 90% of the population. Governments set lower targets like 70% of adults. But the government targets weren't herd immunity estimates.
- dom96 5y agoThere is a similar story in the UK. This isn't all that surprising for the UK at least (I'm not familiar with how Israel is doing things): "freedom day" was now a month ago so of course more infections will happen. The questions now are: will we see a variant that can escape the vaccines? Will the vaccines becomes significantly less effective at stopping hospitalisation/death within a few months?
- irrational 5y agoWhat is freedom day?
- linuxhansl 5y agoBefore anyone draws the wrong conclusions... 78.8% of the population above 12 are vaccinated. The remaining 21.2% make up about 40% of all hospitalizations. The vaccines are incredibly effective and the situation in Israel does by no means indicate that they are not. Edit: Fixed 11.2% to 21.2%.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoDon't you mean the remaining 21.2%?
- linuxhansl 5y agoOops. Yes.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI mean, don't you feel like this at least somewhat changes your conclusion then? Yes, the vaccines are quite effective, but now it means that the unvaccinated are only doubly overrepresented in new cases, which at least changes the calculus in my mind.
- belltaco 5y agoThe vaccinated folks are mostly old people and people with comorbidities, and the unvaccinated are mostly young and healthy people, so you're not comparing like for like.
- rubicon33 5y agoI think it's still concerning that 60% of hospitalizations are vaccinated patients. Even if 79% of the population is vaccinated.
- markdown 5y agoBest case, the Pfizer vaccine is 95% effective at preventing serious illness and death. This has been known since the beginning. If you vaccinate 100% of the total population, you'll find that 100% of hospitalised and dead patients have been fully vaccinated. TL;DR: This is only concerning if one doesn't properly grasp statistics. Most of us (self included) fail at this.
- golemiprague 5y ago> Only vaccinated Palestinians are given permits to enter Israel and Israeli settlements Many cross from the west bank without permissions, there are known opening in the fence there and the army is not really stopping them since there aren't many terror attacks in the last years.
- GeekyBear 5y agoSome information on which groups among the fully vaccinated are seeing a serious breakthrough infection. >As of 15 August, 514 Israelis were hospitalized with severe or critical COVID-19, a 31% increase from just 4 days earlier. Of the 514, 59% were fully vaccinated. Of the vaccinated, 87% were 60 or older. https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/08/grim-warning-israel-vaccination-blunts-does-not-defeat-delta https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2021/08/grim-warning-israel-... and >comorbidities were more frequent in patients with vaccine breakthrough infections in comparison to a large case series on unvaccinated hospitalized patients - including hypertension, diabetes, heart failure, chronic kidney diseases, chronic lung diseases, dementia and cancer. Moreover, 40% of the patients were immunocompromised. https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210713/Israeli-study-of-breakthrough-infections-following-full-BNT-Pfizer-vaccination-4025-immunocompromised.aspx https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210713/Israeli-study-of-... So the serious infections are concentrated in those who are older, immunocompromised, or those who have other conditions already known to be linked to having a more serious case.
- ekianjo 5y agoI'd like to see the number of serious cases by age brackets, and by profile of patients (with comorbidities and not).
- ekianjo 5y ago> Preliminary research in Israel suggests booster shots significantly increase protection against the coronavirus a week after a person receives the third dose. Which research? Thanks NPR for citing your sources?
- DanielDent 5y agoThings that matter a lot these days: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Base_rate_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson%27s_paradox Someone that's done some analysis using the above mental models: https://www.covid-datascience.com/post/israeli-data-how-can-efficacy-vs-severe-disease-be-strong-when-60-of-hospitalized-are-vaccinated https://www.covid-datascience.com/post/israeli-data-how-can-...
- hammock 5y agoNotwithstanding any fallacies that may exist (can you point out a specific one?), the best available scientific evidence suggests that natural immunity is much stronger than the vaccines against COVID: "Israelis who were vaccinated were 6.72 times more likely to get infected after the shot than after natural infection". https://archive.is/RlwBc https://archive.is/RlwBc
- somewhereoutth 5y agoBy natural immunity I think you meant to say disease induced immunity. Just to be clear about what that actually entails.
- DanielDent 5y agoHere's a very quick summary of what I linked above: In Israel it would be easy to look at the data and conclude that vaccines are providing ~67% efficacy against severe disease/death. But, once the data is broken down into buckets that help address confounding variables (i.e. different vaccination rates among different age groups), things look very different. All of a sudden efficacy numbers are looking better than 90% for a lot of people. This will similarly matter a great deal as people try to figure out how long vaccines provide protection. The groups that got vaccinated the earliest in many places were older people and health care workers -- groups which start out at higher risk, and also have a higher probability of less effective immune response to vaccines (older people). As a result of that, it will be easy for analysts that don't consider that issue to under-estimate the effective time period of vaccines. The archive.is link you provided isn't working for me at the moment, but to address your statement in the context of the above framework: The group of people most likely to have been infected with the virus are not the same as the group of people most likely to have antibodies as a result of immunization. In many places, there are a lot more younger people who have gotten infected with the disease than older people. There are other socioeconomic and behavioural differences too. Given that young people tend to have a more effective immune responses to begin with, and given that they have been shown to have better outcomes after being infected with this virus, it's easy to see a way to incorrectly conclude that stronger immunity results from infection-acquired antibodies, even if the opposite may be true. In short: Apparent differences may be better explained by the fact that it's a different group of people who have been infected vs those who have not been infected.
- hammock 5y agoThere is more than vaccinated vs unvaccinated. There is also naturally acquired immunity. The best available science points to many interesting things you may not be aware of: "Israelis who were vaccinated were 6.72 times more likely to get infected after the shot than after natural infection". https://archive.is/RlwBc https://archive.is/RlwBc "Researchers from Washington University in St. Louis also reported last month that 11 months after a mild infection immune cells were still capable of producing protective antibodies. The authors concluded that prior Covid infection induces a “robust” and “long-lived humoral immune response,” leading some scientists to suggest that natural immunity is probably lifelong." https://archive.is/DkgW2 https://archive.is/DkgW2 "Researchers from the Cleveland Clinic also published a study recently of 1,359 people previously infected with Covid who were unvaccinated. None of the subjects subsequently became infected, leading the researchers to conclude that “individuals who have had SARS-CoV-2 infection are unlikely to benefit from COVID-19 vaccination.”" https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.01.21258176v2 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.06.01.21258176v... A recent study found that the current vaccines do next to nothing to help the body’s CD8 T-cells, which is the key to long-term immunity. https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-medicine/fulltext/S2666-3791(21)00203-2#relatedArticles https://www.cell.com/cell-reports-medicine/fulltext/S2666-37... “A natural infection induces hundreds upon hundreds of antibodies against all proteins of the virus, including the envelope, the membrane, the nucleocapsid, and the spike. Dozens upon dozens of these antibodies neutralize the virus when encountered again. Additionally, because of the immune system exposure to these numerous proteins (epitomes), our T cells mount a robust memory, as well. Our T cells are the ‘marines’ of the immune system and the first line of defense against pathogens. T cell memory to those infected with SARSCOV1 is at 17 years and running still.” said Dr. Ryan Cole, a Mayo Clinic-trained pathologist who runs one of the largest independent laboratories in the US who has spent the past 16 months examining and culturing SARS-CoV-2 specimens. https://archive.is/o/4suZi/https://www.theblaze.com/op-ed/horowitz-israeli-government-data-shows-natural-immunity-from-infection-much-stronger-than-vaccine-induced-immunity https://archive.is/o/4suZi/https://www.theblaze.com/op-ed/ho... A national survey shows 68% of Indians have SARSCoV2 antibodies, compared to 25% in January and 1% last spring. Experts say this is why cases and deaths have plunged so fast since May, even though few Indians are fully vaccinated. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/21/covid-19-antibodies-detected-in-67-of-indias-population https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jul/21/covid-19-antib... Protection of previous SARS-CoV-2 infection is similar to that of BNT162b2 vaccine protection. https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.04.20.21255670v1?fbclid=IwAR0w8MOeRMivI9bjLJtcF3zCfjtlziyzmcHiCMrdvMIX1LSUuL0e11Smuqk https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.04.20.21255670v...
- somewhereoutth 5y agoDepressing to read all the anti-vax and pro-Covid comments on this generally enlightened forum while much of the healthcare system of the southern US is being overwhelmed by un-vaccinated Covid patients.
- belter 5y agoI am not arguing against vaccination or saying you dont have a valid concern. But I think we need to also make sense of scenarios like for example India. Has only 9.2% of fully vaccinated and if you look at the daily infection rates it dropped dramatically. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/world/india-covid-cases.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2021/world/india-covid-c...
- lucb1e 5y agoI've stopped trying to attribute infection rates to other statistics, especially individual ones. There seems to be very little rhyme or reason to the incidence. Sometimes there is a very clear mistake made, like in the Netherlands they opened up night clubs and bars and suddenly we had the fastest-growing wave so far and anyone outside of 15-25 years old wasn't even participating. But most of the time it's really not so clear what is causing or preventing infections without rigorous research. At a minimum, one should also be looking at test rates and incentives to not get tested (needing to go into quarantine iirc in many countries, having to pay €40 just for a single low-quality nose test as of Oct 1st in the Netherlands, those sorts of things), since merely the incidence does not tell the full story. Then there are weather changes (temperature, humidity, time spent meeting others indoors vs. outdoors), avoidance of close contact or travel, face mask requirements, adherence to rules and recommendations, etc.
- ajkdhcb2 5y agoIt seems the vaccine does little to prevent vaccinated people from spreading the virus. So what is the point of vaccine passports, is that based on outdated data? Preventing serious injury seems unrelated to this question; it seems the unvaccinated are only putting themselves at risk.
- stmfreak 5y agoThis infomercial brought to you by Pfizer.
- stevenalowe 5y agoSo… since Armor only stop arrows 95% of the time and wears out in 6 months, armor is useless waste of resources. (Facepalm)
- Expirat 5y agoSo... Since there is a 0.2% chance of dying from covid(adult male in his 40s) you must take a vaccine that wears in 6 months, and take booster shots every year. You can still end up in hospital, you can still infect people, but it lowers the dying risk a bit. Also, government forces you to take this and if you refuse your rights are taken. Yep. Totally not stupid. Truly the work of scientists. (facepalm)
- armona 5y agoThe current figures are: - There are 21.9 hospitalized in severe condition per 100K vaccinated above the age of 60. - There are 225.9 hospitalized in severe condition per 100K un-vaccinated above the age of 60. Vaccines are incredibly effective, you are 10 times as likely to be hospitalized in severe condition if you are above 60 if not vaccinated.