3 ms·
> people saying “the science is settled” or “trust the science” These two are not of the same level of severity. The first statement should usually raise eyeb
by kibwen 5y ago
> people saying “the science is settled” or “trust the science”
These two are not of the same level of severity.
The first statement should usually raise eyebrows, as science is almost never "settled". The first and second laws of thermodynamics are pretty solid. For most other things we can entertain some skepticism.
But the second statement raises the question: trust relative to what? If your options are to trust something that appears to follow the scientific method vs. something that does not appear to follow the scientific method, then it's completely fair to favor the first. Sometimes you'll be wrong, and that's fine, but that doesn't mean that science is inherently undeserving of trust.
- User23 5y ago> The first statement should usually raise eyebrows, as science is almost never "settled". The first and second laws of thermodynamics are pretty solid. For most other things we can entertain some skepticism. One of my good friends is a particle physicist and he assures me that he and his peers very much hope the science isn't settled, despite agreeing pretty well with experiment, because the Standard Model is a hideous kludge. The heuristic I use is judging based on my estimate of the statement's Shannon entropy. And most of the time the "follow the science" crowd's statements contain absolutely no entropy. I've already heard it verbatim from CNN or some other usually low expertise source. Furthermore, it's annoying to have people lecture me about PCR tests when they don't even know what a restriction endonuclease is. Note that high entropy doesn't mean correct, but to me it does mean more interesting. Now there are plenty of people out there who demonstrably do not want me to have access to high entropy sources, because they believe them to be wrong. They're certainly entitled to their beliefs, but I dislike the idea of someone else deciding what I'm allowed to read. On the subject of Shannon entropy, I've observed that on technical subjects that readers here have expertise in, like programming, the high entropy comments tend to get upvoted. On the other hand any topic where the crowd here believes "the science is settled" you see the exact opposite effect: high entropy comments are consistently massively disapproved of, while clever restatements of the conventional wisdom with minimal entropy get voted to the top.
- ummwhat 5y agoIronically, you picked the one "law" in physics which is technically a statistical statement rather than a law per se.
- bequanna 5y agoWhat this all fails to consider are the undisclosed incentives and motivations of those “doing the science”. It is shockingly easy to lie with statistics, massage experimental results, or just straight up fabricate the whole damn thing to further your career, get a grant, ego or whatever. What percentage of published research papers are able to be reproduced? Very few. Many “non-intellectuals” inherently know all of the above about human nature, but suffer ridicule when they don’t “trust the science”. It doesn’t take a blue check mark next to your name to realize that people are fallible and will lie to get ahead.