5 ms·
What an utterly redundant point. If you catch and do not die from the virus then yay for you I suppose, but you'll still spread it around while you have it, yo
by XorNot 5y ago
What an utterly redundant point.
If you catch and do not die from the virus then yay for you I suppose, but you'll still spread it around while you have it, you still might die from the virus, and there is literally no downside to having a better immune response when you inevitably do catch COVID-19 as we're all going to eventually.
Like everything else, the goal of every single public health measure at the moment is to avoid having a huge portion of the population all need hospital services at the same time though.
This article is asking a stupid question, and the answer is predictably stupid.
EDIT: Pile on anti-vaxxer downvotes, the speed with which you're dumping these in makes it apparent you're not reading the article.
- timthorn 5y agoThe question asked by the article is sensible. The uncertainty explored is whether, having had an initial vaccination, future natural infection would produce a better defence against variants than booster shots that target the spike protein alone.
- XorNot 5y agoWhich is irrelevant: the booster vaccines are to provide sustained protection against the variants we have now and reduce the risk of serious complications. There is no situation in which it is a good idea to be infected with a virus rather then vaccinated against it, and comments on provided immunity from infection are irrelevant: you either become immune to what infected you or it kills you.
- walterbell 5y agoCurrent Covid vaccines are non-sterilizing. They reduce symptoms, but cannot guarantee that you will not be infected. This is covered in the article in the discussion of antibodies in the upper respiratory system (obtained from natural infection) vs antibodies in the blood (obtained from vaccination or natural infection). Future nasal vaccines, delivered by inhaler, could potentially provide sterilizing immunity, preventing infection: https://news.ycombinator.com/edit?id=28256342 https://news.ycombinator.com/edit?id=28256342
- bluGill 5y agoThe vaccines reduce infection chances greatly, and even if you get it they reduce the time you have it and thus how much time you can spread. Non sterilizating is technically true, but misleading. We are still better off with vaccines and can probable eliminate covid with high enough vaccine rates.
- walterbell 5y agoHopefully upcoming nasal vaccines will be even better, as noted by the UK's SAGE, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/long-term-evolution-of-sars-cov-2-26-july-2021 https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/long-term-evoluti... > Whilst we feel that current vaccines are excellent for reducing the risk of hospital admission and disease, we propose that research be focused on vaccines that also induce high and durable levels of mucosal immunity in order to reduce infection of and transmission from vaccinated individuals. This could also reduce the possibility of variant selection in vaccinated individuals.
- jeromegv 5y agoFunny how those anti-vaxers in hospitals don’t advocate that it was all worth it for their immunity they just built. You either get the immunity through a shot or through an infection. One has very much worse chances of bringing you to the hospital.
- Vecr 5y agoWhy? Natural boosting is totally legitimate, look at the rotavirus strategy in the US for example. You get the vaccine three times soon after you are born, and then never again after that, because your immune system matures and you get infected (without severe symptoms) many times.
- foobarbaz33 5y agoFor sake of discussion assume all infections are accidental, and everyone follows anti-infection protocols to the letter. Here are a few (but not all) states someone can be in. A. vaccinated B. vaccinated -> natural infection -> recovered C. vaccinated -> booster D. vaccinated -> booster -> natural infection -> recovered Let's assume it was proven state D has the best efficiency against covid variants. Option D includes the booster. So boosters would always be a good idea. But even if boosters are a good idea in all cases, it is worth studying whether people in state B or C have better efficiency against covid variants. Gaining knowledge is good. It may (or may not) be a fact that state B has superior efficiency to state C.
- ekianjo 5y ago> EDIT: Pile on anti-vaxxer downvotes, You don't need to be an anti-vaxxer to disagree with what you wrote.
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoSure. But. There is more to life then just maximizing safety in perpetuity. We must live and move on with the business of life.
- rossdavidh 5y agoI'm not an anti-vaxxer, I got vaccinated. I don't think the article is stupid. Even if you disagree with the idea (and I don't, necessarily), it's a valid question to raise, and the discussion is a productive one to have.
- hartator 5y ago> no downside to having a better immune response Side effects increase when we vaccinate younger population - that includes long term ones - Whereas younger population are very unlikely to have serious symptoms from the virus.