5 ms·
The Shadowy Business of International Education
- ssss11 5y agoThe examples are about Canada’s education system but seem to apply broadly to western countries. It’s also largely about shadowy “agents” that are in foreign countries recruiting the students and helping them with the process (for a cut).
- peterkelly 5y agoYou could do a find-and-replace on this article replacing "Canada" with "Australia" and it would all still hold. Universities have become all about moneymaking and will happily accept students who lack the prerequisite knowledge for a course, setting them up for failure when they inevitably struggle with the material. Lecturers get pressured to dumb down course material and pass students who haven't demonstrated adequate abilities in their coursework. I used to teach computer science back in Australia and saw a lot of this first hand. Part of the reason I left was because I didn't feel comfortable being part of this dirty system.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- melony 5y agoThere is an entire billion dollar unicorn from the University of Waterloo called ApplyBoard. Their business is based on this model. There is hardly anything shadowy about it. If you are in the Valley, ask your Waterloo colleagues about the company. It is a very famous startup that gets kickbacks from both parties when an application goes through.
- vlovich123 5y agoHmmm… I had not heard off this startup but I graduated a bit before they were founded
- forkLding 5y agoApplyBoard is quite big now, they raised $375 million recently and was the fastest growing tech company in Canada in 2019 as ranked by Deloitte. They have been quite successful in the specific field they are in. I did some research, my girlfriend paid about $4k USD to a similar company in China for help with filling our her visa application and reviewing admissions essay to a university in Canada. Although now she regrets spending that much as she can do all that stuff on her own when she came here. Students can pay to that range or even more which is why Applyboard can raise $300+ million despite having only served 200k students. International students as an "industry" really does exist.
- vlovich123 5y agoYeah, it always bothered me that international students had to pay 2x the cost at Waterloo. Like I understood conceptually why it was that way, but morally it felt very wrong.
- baybal2 5y agoDepending on the province, but it is your parents who paid for your tuition with your taxes. So international students don't come much cheaper, or expensive to universities. But international students are much easier for universities to get, for both top universities in Vancouver, and small towns further away. For the later, they are almost like a lifeline.
- vlovich123 5y agoI seriously doubt that my mom’s taxes covered the 2x difference that out-of-province students paid. It’s a socialized good which is fine, but there’s something wrong with having a discriminated price. It’s selecting for funding ability rather than the quality of the student, which should be the only goal of education. Certainly, if I’d been forced to pay that rate, it’s likely I wouldn’t have been able to attend. Or more likely would have needed significant student loans which would have drastically changed decisions I got to make without them. Neither scenario seems like a particularly just outcome if the only difference is an accident of geography. Politically, this is a hot button topic because politicians are accountable to their constituents and since some amount of public funds are used on post secondary education, there’s a sense of entitlement. You can even see that in the “performance based funding formula” that Ford is moving Ontario to. And every price hike was always met with a wave of complaints when I attended resulting in tuition freezes. Trying to advocate for the rights of non-Ontarions doesn’t win you political points but it doesn’t remove the unjustness from the story (especially since that foreign funding is actually acting like a large subsidy for in-province students)
- peterkelly 5y agoThe article describes ApplyBoard in detail and explains exactly why it's regarded by some as shadowy: > According to critics, aggregate recruiters allow institutions to avoid any accountability for the actions of the agents representing them. “It eliminates the link between the colleges themselves and the agents,” says agent Earl Blaney. “The schools are now not even responsible or connected to these agents, but they’re the ones selling the school.” It’s a $21 billion dollar industry, he says, with hardly any rules. > ApplyBoard says it vets all its recruiters, rejecting 46 percent of applicants. Approved agents are then trained through online webinars and an interactive course. But institutions seem to understand the potential for abuse that comes with working through aggregators. In the past, Langara refused to allow its agents to work with subagents. “The reason for that is because then we lose the control of who these people are, how they’re representing the institution,” says Van Dam. Last year, despite those qualms, Langara signed an agreement to work with ApplyBoard in what Van Dam describes as a trial period. In theory, there’s nothing stopping an agent that Van Dam rejected yesterday from signing up with ApplyBoard and sending kids to the college soon afterward.
- franciscop 5y agoThis shadowy India/Canada international education contrasts heavily with the exchange programs (also international education) in EU, which are normally some of the best experiences in people's life. The way it works here with the Erasmus program is that you go for 6 months or 1 year to study to a "partner" University, and a student from that University comes to yours. Both students pay the local price instead of the destination price so it keeps costing the same as other years; which is also normally not a big deal since they are both likely free (in most of EU, public free Universities are better than private ones, at least for STEM). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erasmus%2B https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erasmus%2B
- nivenkos 5y agoWorth nothing that Erasmus has government support though. It has a lot of structure and effort put into it. And your home institution still gives you the degree itself, so there's no complications there either.
- wott 5y ago> The way it works here with the Erasmus program is that you go for 6 months or 1 year to study Let's be honest, in most cases you can replace the word 'study' with 'party'. That's why you end up with "some of the best experiences in people's life", as you say. In many cases, students do not have the required language level to follow and understand courses, so if they bother to show up, the content flies over their head while they are busy decoding the form. Sometimes they do not even speak a word of the language. In some cases, they follow dumbed down courses in a third language (Globish) with a teacher who can hardly speak it, so they never learn the local language, and they learn some bad English.
- marderfarker2 5y agoI was a participant in an Erasmus programme with a German university. In my case the German University created and translated a course to English and the classes and exams were conducted in English. There were some rough edges, such as untranslated terms but it isn’t as hopeless as you claimed.
- unmole 5y ago> One student had boarded a plane after being told they were enrolled in one college only to arrive and find they hadn’t actually been signed up. “This thing is getting nasty,” says Sohal. “It’s a dirty business.” Wait, how did the student get a visa without really being enrolled?
- baybal2 5y agoMini AMA here? I was an international student in Canada 2010-2012, and Singapore 2007-2009. The one in Canada, my parents sent me to had a reputation of a somewhat of business degree mill despite a good name, and rankings. I studied business administration there, and can tell it was useless. I never used any of the skills I learned professionally. Experience of an expat student in such places: Extreme pass rates, with few "hard" programmes to save the face. By Canadian own standards, the academic ethic, and discipline was so, so, but tolerated, with tacit understanding that a lot of "foreign student friendly" courses exist for such sole purpose. There was only 1 real native (in a sense being born there) Canadian citizen out of a class of 24. Everybody else was either completely foreign, recent naturalised immigrants, PR holders, and children of people on investment immigration programs. You pay 3 times the Canadian rate. And yes, my parent used a shady "agent" as well, who very visibly been communicating with uni higher ups.
- wott 5y ago> I never used any of the skills I learned professionally. Well, that's often the case with regular, honest studies too. Most people who work after the equivalent of a Master degree never use chemistry, biology, or post-high-school mathematics in their job (the list is not exhaustive). (I just mean to say that this shouldn't be taken as a single definite criterium ; when you add it to the rest in the bigger picture, it can make sense however.)
- redis_mlc 5y ago> I never used any of the skills I learned professionally. Try harder. I've used every class that I ever studied in either my personal or professional life. When people ask, "How did you do that?", then you know that you're on the right track.
- grenoire 5y agoHonestly my and many of my other friends' experiences going from outside the EU to EU degrees has been life changing (for some, literally so; ones who can't even go back to their countries). Of course it's not easy, and not everybody makes it through, but it's a different story than the scams outlined in this article. It's not a critique that should be extrapolated to all 'international' education.
- tedk-42 5y agoIn Australia we describe education as something we 'export' because it brings in so much cash from foreigners. There's a lot of money at play and pissed off students if they don't do well. Definitely a weird 'business' if you view education as something that's merit based as opposed to bought.
- vbtemp 5y agoIn a similar vein, I refuse to use the euphemism "students" when referring to customers of many US university programs (particular MS programs, but applies broadly)
- KLK2019 5y agoVery fascinating article and appreciate the policy and business context that brought some of the new faces I see in my community. For context I live close to a Canadian university campus which has recently gone through an explosion in foreign enrollment. My partner works as physcian on campus so I hear a anecdotally how it has changed her practice, shifting from sexual health issues (and of course exam deferrments) to more with mental health issues arising from the challenges and pressures these foreign university students face (33% of student body now and probably 50%+ of her cases). The responsibilities they are faced with are immense at such a young age, where their families put so much on the line and expect these students to succeed. I have always been fascinated by the immigrant story, and in Canada I feel there is evolution happening. Like the story mentioned it seems these young, desperate and motivated individuals represent the ideal worker for Canadian employers/government. I have encountered uber drivers, retail workers and tech proferssionals, all from this demographic and they have so much grit. This feels different the previous generation (my parents) were they filled mostly underskilled labour but had childern who mostly went on to more skilled professions. I just hope some form of the Canadian dream is still viable. My parents were able afford a house and have kids who did well in school, to be honest that was thier saving grace both in terms of happiness, retirement and giving them a sense of pride and accomplishment for thier many years of struggle. I know some of my peers fear if they are able to acoomplish even that (even with thier 6 figure incomes) I can't imagine what these newcomers are facing.
- codeisawesome 5y agoWay to paint with broad brush strokes!