6 ms·
Germany’s hidden hunger: On the breadline in Europe’s richest country (2017)
- watt 5y ago> But rents are high — and rising — in Fürstenfeldbruck. Why are rents to high? Why are they raising? And _who_ exactly is rising them? I can't see the economic reason why such a large chunk of income needs to go to "landlords". Rents could just as well be very low, set to extremely reasonable level (they should be negligible, maybe 10% of monthly income at most, really). If you are a land-owner, that's about the level of taxation you see. I just don't see why we accept current state of things as the way to be.
- axiosgunnar 5y agoThe rents are rising because the building code is ridiculously prohibitive (NIMBY and because the German state loves bureaucracy, everything takes 10x longer). This is the one and only reason. Everything else is political smokescreen.
- VortexDream 5y agoSame as anywhere else. Lack of supply caused by zoning and an interest in keeping property values high by existing owners.
- lispm 5y ago> I can't see the economic reason The market creates the price: little supply and very high demand. Fürstenfeldbruck is one of the most attractive regions in the country. Generally this is the case for the rest of the metropolitan region of Munich. Fürstenfeldbruck is a small town (< 40k people) near Munich.
- watt 5y agoBy "reason" I mean I don't see how it's justified. The government could work on both the supply and demand side of equation, and increase the quality of life of residents, by allowing a way larger chunk of income stay in their hands.
- southerntofu 5y agoIt's hardly defensible, but since the neoliberal turn in the 80s/90s most global north governments have started to dismantle their public services. That's why they're not working on both sides of the equation: because governments work directly against the interest of the people. Governments and elections are the exact opposite of democracy, because it's delegating powers to representatives instead of exerting "power of the people, by the people, for the people".
- lispm 5y agoLast I've been to Munich public services seemed not to be dismantled. Munich has other problems: it's too successful and attracts people and investors.
- southerntofu 5y ago> public services seemed not to be dismantled It's a very progressive process, not a binary flag. See for example David Graeber's CCC talk on "Managerial feudalism and the revolt of the caring classes". All in all most of the global north appears to have strong public services and cultivate that image to please the middle classes who are happy to pay taxes for that, but they've worked hard to make them harder to reach and impossible to sustain (see also, Covid crisis and public hospitals) in order to "attract people and investors". There's no way a society with good public services can be attractive to private investors, because good public services provide better services at a much lower price than private services. It's either one or the other, and the presence of investors and gentrification is a factor that the social fabric and public services have already been heavily damaged.
- lispm 5y agoHow could they?
- kharak 5y agoI know someone who wants to rebuild his one level apartments into a four level apartment block. Good district in Hamburg. Exactly the kind of thing the city needs. More apartments, increased density, private investment. He's trying to get the allowance to do so for up to two years by now. Every plan his architect makes gets denied for different, petty reasons. Once he manages to fulfill all requirements of the bureaucracy, the true battle will begin. Residents in the area have already said they will do everything in their power to stop this rebuilding from happening. No matter the outcome of this legal battle, that'll add another couple of years until this apartment building becomes reality. Germany has a problem. It's becoming impossible to execute in physical space.
- suction 5y agoIf you put yourself in the position of those neighbours, they do have a point though: New apartments usually means luxury apartments, hence gentrification.
- berlin_build 5y agoSo basically “fuck you, I got mine”?
- chrisseaton 5y agoDoes 10% cover the cost of building and maintaining the housing? If not, who's paying for it instead?
- watt 5y agoBuilding "code" and bureaucracy around it seems to be some kind of weird cult. I bet in this day and age it is actually quite cheap to build, if you look at what costs in term of materials and actual wages of construction workers. Everything else around it is inflated to hell on other hand.
- cabraca 5y agoDue to low interest rates companies(even foreign)are buying land and buildings like crazy, building new ones and rebuilding like crazy trying to raise their return. Prices are skyrocketing. Construction companies have more projects than they can work on. Those new buildings are expensive as hell and rent is rising as well. The average rent in the village i live in doubled in the last 10 years and thats probably due to some restrictions on how much rent can be raised in a certain interval.
- candiodari 5y agoBut without (extremely) low interest rates government spending would have to be cut A LOT ... so who decides interest rates again? Oh wait ... Expecting an increase in rates is like expecting the government to decide it's too big (and not a little bit). Good luck with that. Even very rightist parties in Europe don't even try to make that point any more.
- bennysomething 5y agoThe prices are what people on mass are agreeing to pay. There isn't a land lord conspiracy raising the rent. Should some third party decide this instead? Should this apply to to every transaction, not just rents? Instead, in a free market people make decisions on their own, do they want to live close to town where it's expensive or would they prefer out of town where it's cheaper etc. Having some third party decide prices sounds reasonable at first but the freedom it removes is huge. Also price fixing always has the same impact. Reduced supply.
- southerntofu 5y agoIt's not exactly a worldwide conspiracy of landlords, because there's not a single table gathering them all to drive this plan. But there is a great amount of coordination between landlords and local politicians in the process of gentrification. Gentrification is something a single owner can't achieve, and that a disorganized group of owners can't achieve. It requires a strong coordination with public authority to deploy efforts to "clean the neighborhood", "evict squats and replace them with nice-looking artistic venues" or "setup new transport connections". See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gentrification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gentrification > Reduced supply I'd like to see evidence of that. Despite their glaring architectural issues, many public housing programs in Europe after WWII have led to cheap housing for many people. Here in France public housing in big cities, my approximation is that public housing rents are 10-40% the private market rents. Also, the waiting lists are long nowadays (was not already the case) because our governments are dismantling public housing programs and slowly privatizing anything. Finally, why would "reduced supply" matter when there's already an abundance of empty apartments/houses? Without even mentioning vacant office space which is a scandal on its own, there's millions of empty living spaces in the global north. According to official french gov. statistics it's 2.6M empty apartments.
- bennysomething 5y agoYou think there is an abundance of empty apartments? Based on what?
- 5y ago
- the-dude 5y agoWhat surprised when I first learned about it : Germany only has a minimum wage since 2015 : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage_in_Germany The article is about food banks too. I am from NL, and the first food bank here was established in 2000. Why were there no food banks in the 80s?
- cabraca 5y agoafaik there are no state run food banks. In germany those are mostly non-profit ngos. One of them is 'Tafel Deutschland e. V.' that is operation since 1993. https://www.tafel.de/english-information/ https://www.tafel.de/english-information/ edit: replaced "official" with "state run"
- the-dude 5y agoWhat is the difference between an official food bank and a NGO? AFAIK, all food banks in NL are NGOs. edit: I wonder if the Tafel date of 1993 has anything to do with the reunification.
- kalleboo 5y agoSweden still doesn’t have a minimum wage - that kind of negotiation is left up to the unions that do it on a per-industry level
- masklinn 5y ago> What surprised when I first learned about it : Germany only has a minimum wage since 2015 : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage_in_Germany https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage_in_Germany That's because historically this was managed through ubiquitous trade unions and collective agreements. The need for a legal minimum wage increased due to the rise in contract / temp work, and US corporations moving in (notably Amazon whose approach to labour relations has been distinctively american).
- chrisseaton 5y ago> After proving their eligibility, customers are given an identity card Eligibility checks, identity cards, someone literally stamping a record card - doesn't seem very Germanic. Are so many people really going to food banks without a good reason that you need to have this authoritarianism to catch them out? If someone turns up asking for food can they not be trusted that they're probably not doing something so embarrassing for fun?
- the-dude 5y agoIn NL it is no different, you actually need to prove you have insufficient income. I actually wonder where it would be more relaxed.
- chrisseaton 5y agoIn the UK I think you just turn up and say you need food and they trust you. I'm very skeptical of the idea that rich people are putting themselves through the humiliation of saying that they aren't able to support themselves in order to get free grocery basics.
- suction 5y agoMaybe well-educated, upper class rich people wouldn't. But your new-money-types totally would do that to save a couple of Euros they could spend on booze / drugs / their luxury car lease.
- the-dude 5y agoI don't think the problem are rich people. I think the problem is probably poor people who try to extract more from the system ( by touring all food banks for example ). But you can always ask them ( the food banks ) if you are so skeptical. 2 other anecdata's : In the US, people are converting their food stamps into soda, because soda is more tradeable ( more liquid ) than anything else. They sell it to SMBs to convert foodstamps into money. I frequent the second hand stores which are partially aimed at the same group. They sell stuff, furniture, electronics and clothes for very low prices ( think € 3 to € 5 for a pair of pants, € 20 for a TV etc ). These shops use very very very adhesive price tags, to the point I need solvents to remove them. I asked them about it : do people really try to switch price tags on € 3 items? Yes they do.
- cabraca 5y agoWhile germany as a country might be rich, a lot of people are far from it. 20%+ of working people are in low-wage jobs. 5,6% are unemployed. The Medium net household income is ~23000€. High taxes, high cost of energy, high cost of gas. The state pension scheme is basically doomed to fail in the next years when the boomer generation retires.
- jansan 5y agoGermany is not the richest county in the EU. We may, as a country, be the richest, but only because we have the largest population. Per capita wealth is in the upper third of the EU. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_distribution_in_Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wealth_distribution_in_Europe
- watrami 5y agoI volunteer for a "Tafel" in the center of Munich for about four months now, and here the main issue is related to immigrants. I can state with confidence that about 19 out of 20 people coming there have an arab background, and the vast majority have more than 7, sometimes even 10, people in total in their household. And you can see from the cards they need to show, that most of them are children. Many of the migrant kids I've met can't speak any German. Even kids that are already 10 years old. Thus I believe this situation will escalate even further in the future, as it will be very hard for these kids to get a proper education without the needed language skills. It makes you feel really bad to see them growing up in such an environment without much chance for a better life. But ultimately this is due to their parents decision to have so many kids, even if they can't afford simple food.
- the-dude 5y agoWhat is a mod ?
- watrami 5y agoFixed the typo.
- newsclues 5y agoIn Canada similar situation is playing out. Lack of assimilation and heavy reliance on the social safety net, is leading to animosity.
- southerntofu 5y agoWhy would "assimilation" be a goal? Of course giving children opportunity to learn (including the local language) is good, but pretending a single culture and way of life needs to be shared among everyone is an imperialist construct. Not everyone born to a land shares the same culture. There are huge cultural shifts between faiths and political sides, for example, and it's not a problem. A society that is not multicultural has a settler's mentality which is profoundly racist. For example here in France, at the same time the colonial process aimed to destroy local cultures in the colonies in Algeria/Indochine/etc, public schools were used as a weapon to destroy the local cultures and languages in Bretagne, Alsace, Occitanie, etc... A few generations of beating children who spoke their native tongue, suggesting that french was a somehow superior language (and assimulation was a requirement), was enough to annihilate most local cultures. EDIT: I also don't understand why "reliance on safety net" would be a bad thing. There's a reason such mechanisms are in place, and one's contribution to society can hardly be measured in purely economic terms.
- DrNosferatu 5y agoFun fact: I shared this article on Facebook just now, and when I pressed "post", FB showed me an auto popup allowing to enable charity contributions via my post... The whole point that what we need is Political Change rather than charity seems to be a far, far concept...
- allendoerfer 5y agoIt's a complex topic. To really grasp it, you have to follow a long line of effects and consequences. When I try to follow it to search for an ultimate single reason, I end up at "the Euro is to weak for Germany". Historically there has been a circle of world-leading quality of exports rising the value of the Deutschmark, making it harder for Germany to compete, pushing the need for innovation and investments, creating higher payed jobs, producing world-leading exports again. Germany had a highly educated labor-force directly integrated into corporate boards and organized in powerful unions. Germany's oldest party SPD was the political arm of those unions, a labor party. Governments where either right-wing (CDU, Angela Merkel's party) or left-wing (SPD) with a third, liberal party (FDP) switching between the two. In the early 2000s, SPD started a program called "Agenda 2010", liberating the labor market and shattering itself in the process, because it affected its own clientele. They did it as a consequence of Germany being called "the sick man of Europe" in the 90s, because of its economic problems following the unification. The reforms worked in the sense, that the German economy has been running for years without significant recessions. Unemployment has been steadily declining (pre Corona). But the quality of the economy has been changed. Germany is successfully competing in low-paid areas of the economy (e.g. meat-processing), a country like Germany should not be able to compete within an open European market. I think in the end, while having some reasonable liberations in it, Agenda 2010 just accomodated for the fact that Germans (and Northern Europe) are now being paid in a currency, that has not enough value for it's economic output.