3 ms·
If the California proposition system results in a passing referendum to torture Bill to death, does a court ruling that the referendum's result is unconstitutio
by vkou 5y ago
If the California proposition system results in a passing referendum to torture Bill to death, does a court ruling that the referendum's result is unconstitutional also mean the proposition system is unconstitutional?
No. Just like when Congress passes a law ruled unconstitutional, it doesn't mean that Congress's existence, or the manner in which it drafts law is unconstitutional. It just means that particular law gets to be overturned.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoLet's compare what I wrote: > For Proposition 22 to be ruled unconstitutional based on its unusually-generous legislative amendment requirement with what you wrote: > does a court ruling that the referendum's result is unconstitutional Did you forget something? Ruling that prop 22 is unconstitutional based on a general feature of all propositions which prop 22 partially shares is ruling that the proposition system is unconstitutional. If you pass a bill of attainder against Bill as a proposition and it gets overruled because bills of attainder are illegal, that says nothing about other propositions. But if you pass a bill of attainder against Bill as a proposition and it gets overruled because propositions are illegal, that invalidates the entire proposition system.
- vkou 5y agoProp 22 does not share a general feature with all propositions, it is unique in the bar it sets for overturning it. At least, a judge seems to think so.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoWhich judge? As has been repeatedly pointed out elsewhere in the thread, this judge, the one overruling Prop. 22, does not discuss the option to amend Prop. 22 by seven-eighths vote of the legislature except to note that there's no problem with it.